[matlab] Octave/Matlab: Adding new elements to a vector

Having a vector x and I have to add an element (newElem) .

Is there any difference between -

x(end+1) = newElem; 

and

x = [x newElem];

?

This question is related to matlab vector octave element

The answer is


x(end+1) = newElem is a bit more robust.

x = [x newElem] will only work if x is a row-vector, if it is a column vector x = [x; newElem] should be used. x(end+1) = newElem, however, works for both row- and column-vectors.

In general though, growing vectors should be avoided. If you do this a lot, it might bring your code down to a crawl. Think about it: growing an array involves allocating new space, copying everything over, adding the new element, and cleaning up the old mess...Quite a waste of time if you knew the correct size beforehand :)


As mentioned before, the use of x(end+1) = newElem has the advantage that it allows you to concatenate your vector with a scalar, regardless of whether your vector is transposed or not. Therefore it is more robust for adding scalars.

However, what should not be forgotten is that x = [x newElem] will also work when you try to add multiple elements at once. Furthermore, this generalizes a bit more naturally to the case where you want to concatenate matrices. M = [M M1 M2 M3]


All in all, if you want a solution that allows you to concatenate your existing vector x with newElem that may or may not be a scalar, this should do the trick:

 x(end+(1:numel(newElem)))=newElem

Just to add to @ThijsW's answer, there is a significant speed advantage to the first method over the concatenation method:

big = 1e5;
tic;
x = rand(big,1);
toc

x = zeros(big,1);
tic;
for ii = 1:big
    x(ii) = rand;
end
toc

x = []; 
tic; 
for ii = 1:big
    x(end+1) = rand; 
end; 
toc 

x = []; 
tic; 
for ii = 1:big
    x = [x rand]; 
end; 
toc

   Elapsed time is 0.004611 seconds.
   Elapsed time is 0.016448 seconds.
   Elapsed time is 0.034107 seconds.
   Elapsed time is 12.341434 seconds.

I got these times running in 2012b however when I ran the same code on the same computer in matlab 2010a I get

Elapsed time is 0.003044 seconds.
Elapsed time is 0.009947 seconds.
Elapsed time is 12.013875 seconds.
Elapsed time is 12.165593 seconds.

So I guess the speed advantage only applies to more recent versions of Matlab


Examples related to matlab

how to open .mat file without using MATLAB? SQL server stored procedure return a table Python equivalent to 'hold on' in Matlab Octave/Matlab: Adding new elements to a vector How can I make a "color map" plot in matlab? How to display (print) vector in Matlab? Correlation between two vectors? How to plot a 2D FFT in Matlab? How can I find the maximum value and its index in array in MATLAB? How to save a figure in MATLAB from the command line?

Examples related to vector

How to plot vectors in python using matplotlib How can I get the size of an std::vector as an int? Convert Mat to Array/Vector in OpenCV Are vectors passed to functions by value or by reference in C++ Why is it OK to return a 'vector' from a function? Append value to empty vector in R? How to initialize a vector with fixed length in R How to initialize a vector of vectors on a struct? numpy matrix vector multiplication Using atan2 to find angle between two vectors

Examples related to octave

Octave/Matlab: Adding new elements to a vector Differences between Octave and MATLAB? How to concat string + i?

Examples related to element

How can I loop through enum values for display in radio buttons? How to count items in JSON data Access multiple elements of list knowing their index Getting Index of an item in an arraylist; Octave/Matlab: Adding new elements to a vector add item in array list of android GetElementByID - Multiple IDs Numpy ValueError: setting an array element with a sequence. This message may appear without the existing of a sequence? Check if one list contains element from the other How to get the focused element with jQuery?