How do JavaScript closures work

Question

How would you explain JavaScript closures to someone with a knowledge of the concepts they consist of  for example functions  variables and the like   but does not understand closures themselves   I have seen the Scheme example given on Wikipedia  but unfortunately it did not help

User · Answer

Also     Perhaps we should cut your 27-year-old friend a little slack  because the entire concept of  closures  really is        voodoo    By that I mean   a  you do not  intuitively  expect it    AND     b  when someone takes the time to explain it to you  you certainly do not expect it to work   Intuition tells you that  this must be nonsense    surely it must result in some kind of syntax-error or something    How on earth    could you  in effect   pull a function from  the middle of  wherever-it s-at   such that you could  still   actually have read write access to the context of  wherever-it-was-at     When you finally realize that such a thing is possible  then     sure     anyone s after-the-fact reaction would be   whoa-a-a-a       kew-el-l-l-l           But there will be a  big counter-intuitive hurdle  to overcome  first   Intuition gives you plenty of utterly-plausible expectations that such a thing would be  of course  absolutely nonsensical and therefore quite impossible    Like I said   it s voodoo

User · Answer

Here s the most Zen answer I can give   What would you expect this code to do  Tell me in a comment before you run it  I m curious   function foo       var i   1    return function         console log i            var bar   foo    bar    bar    bar     var baz   foo    baz    baz    baz      Now open the console in your browser  Ctrl   Shift   I or F12  hopefully  and paste the code in and hit Enter   If this code printed what you expect  JavaScript newbies - ignore the  undefined  at the end   then you already have wordless understanding   In words  the variable i is part of the inner function instance s closure   I put it this way because  once I understood that this code is putting instances of foo   s inner function in bar and baz and then calling them via those variables  nothing else surprised me   But if I m wrong and the console output surprised you  let me know

User · Answer

The best way is to explain these concepts incrementally   Variables  console log x      undefined   Here  undefined is JavaScript s way of saying  I have no idea what x means       Variables are like tags    You can say  tag x points to value 42   var x   42  console log x      42   Now JavaScript knows what x means      You can also re-assign a variable    Make tag x point to a different value   x   43  console log x      43   Now x means something else   Scope     When you make a function  the function has its own  box  for variables    function A       var x   42     console log x       undefined   From outside the box  you cannot see what s inside the box   But from inside the box  you can see what s outside that box   var x   42   function A       console log x         42      Inside function A  you have  scope access  to x    Now if you have two boxes side-by-side   function A       var x   42     function B       console log x         undefined      Inside function B  you have no access to variables inside function A    But if you put define function B inside function A   function A        var x   42     function B         console log x              42   You now have  scope access    Functions  In JavaScript  you run a function by calling it   function A       console log 42       Like this   A        42   Functions as Values  In JavaScript  you can point a tag to a function  just like pointing to a number   var a   function       console log 42           Variable a now means a function  you can run it    a       42   You can also pass this variable around   setTimeout a  1000     In a second  1000 milliseconds   the function a points to is called      42   Closure Scope  Now when you define functions  those functions have access to their outer scopes   When you pass functions around as values  it would be troublesome if that access is lost      In JavaScript  functions keep their access to outer scope variables    Even when they are passed around to be run somewhere else    var a   function        var text    Hello      var b   function         console log text          inside function  b   you have access to  text             but you want to run  b  later  rather than right away   setTimeout b  1000        What happens now       Hello     Or consider this   var c   var a   function        var text    Hello      var b   function         console log text          inside function  b   you have access to  text          c   b         now we are out side of function  a     call  a  so the code inside  a  runs a         now  c  has a value that is a function    because what happened when  a  ran     when you run  c  c         Hello        You can still access variables in the closure scope    Even though a has finished running  and now you are running c outside of a   What just happened here is called  closure  in JavaScript

User · Answer

Taking the question seriously  we should find out what a typical 6-year-old is capable of cognitively  though admittedly  one who is interested in JavaScript is not so typical     On  Childhood Development  5 to 7 Years  it says      Your child will be able to follow two-step directions  For example  if you say to your child   Go to the kitchen and get me a trash bag  they will be able to remember that direction    We can use this example to explain closures  as follows      The kitchen is a closure that has a local variable  called trashBags   There is a function inside the kitchen called getTrashBag that gets one trash bag and returns it    We can code this in JavaScript like this    x000D   x000D  function makeKitchen     x000D    var trashBags     A    B    C       only 3 at first x000D   x000D    return   x000D      getTrashBag  function     x000D        return trashBags pop    x000D        x000D       x000D    x000D   x000D  var kitchen   makeKitchen    x000D   x000D  console log kitchen getTrashBag        returns trash bag C x000D  console log kitchen getTrashBag        returns trash bag B x000D  console log kitchen getTrashBag        returns trash bag A x000D   x000D   x000D    Further points that explain why closures are interesting    Each time makeKitchen   is called  a new closure is created with its own separate trashBags  The trashBags variable is local to the inside of each kitchen and is not accessible outside  but the inner function on the getTrashBag property does have access to it    Every function call creates a closure  but there would be no need to keep the closure around unless an inner function  which has access to the inside of the closure  can be called from outside the closure   Returning the object with the getTrashBag function does that here

User · Answer

Closures are hard to explain because they are used to make some behaviour work that everybody intuitively expects to work anyway  I find the best way to explain them  and the way that I learned what they do  is to imagine the situation without them   x000D   x000D  const makePlus   function x        return function y    return x   y        const plus5   makePlus 5   console log plus5 3    x000D   x000D   x000D   What would happen here if JavaScript didn t know closures  Just replace the call in the last line by its method body  which is basically what function calls do  and you get  console log x   3    Now  where s the definition of x  We didn t define it in the current scope  The only solution is to let plus5 carry its scope  or rather  its parent s scope  around  This way  x is well-defined and it is bound to the value 5

User · Answer

I think it is valuable to take a step back  and examine a more general notion of a  closure  -- the so-called  join operator    In mathematics  a  join  operator is a function on a partially ordered set which returns the smallest object greater than or equal to its arguments   In symbols  join  a b    d such that d    a and d    b  but there does not exist an e such that d   e    a or d   e    b   So the join gives you the smallest thing  bigger  than the parts   Now  note that JavaScript scopes are a partially ordered structure   So that there is a sensible notion of a join   In particular  a join of scopes is the smallest scope bigger than the original scopes   That scope is called the closure   So a closure for the variables a  b  c is the smallest scope  in the lattice of scopes for your program   that brings a  b  and c into scope

User · Answer

You re having a sleep over and you invite Dan  You tell Dan to bring one XBox controller   Dan invites Paul  Dan asks Paul to bring one controller  How many controllers were brought to the party   function sleepOver howManyControllersToBring         var numberOfDansControllers   howManyControllersToBring       return function danInvitedPaul numberOfPaulsControllers            var totalControllers   numberOfDansControllers   numberOfPaulsControllers          return totalControllers           var howManyControllersToBring   1   var inviteDan   sleepOver howManyControllersToBring       The only reason Paul was invited is because Dan was invited      So we set Paul s invitation   Dan s invitation   var danInvitedPaul   inviteDan howManyControllersToBring    alert  There were     danInvitedPaul     controllers brought to the party

User · Answer

Given the following function  function person name  age        var name   name      var age   age       function introduce            alert  My name is   name    and I m   age              return introduce     var a   person  Jack  12   var b   person  Matt  14     Everytime the function person is called a new closure is created  While variables a and b have the same introduce function  it is linked to different closures  And that closure will still exist even after the function person finishes execution     a      My name is Jack  and I m 12 b      My name is Matt  and I m 14   An abstract closures could be represented to something like this   closure a         name   Jack       age  12      call  function introduce            alert  My name is   name    and I m   age            closure b         name   Matt       age  14      call  function introduce            alert  My name is   name    and I m   age               Assuming you know how a class in another language work  I will make an analogy   Think like   JavaScript function as a constructor local variables as instance properties these properties are private inner functions as instance methods   Everytime a function is called   A new object containing all local variables will be created  Methods of this object have access to  properties  of that instance object

User · Answer

If you want to explain it to a six-year old child then you must find something very much simpler and NO code   Just tell the child that he is  open   which says that he is able to have relations with some others  his friends  At some point in time  he has determined friends  we can know the names of his friends   that is a closure  If you take a picture of him and his friends then he is  closed  relatively to his friendship ability  But in general  he is  open   During his whole life he will have many different sets of friends  One of these sets is a closure

User · Answer

Maybe you should consider an object-oriented structure instead of inner functions  For example       var calculate             number  0          init  function  num                this number   num                     add  function  val                this number    val                     rem  function  val                this number -  val                    And read the result from the calculate number variable  who needs  quot return quot  anyway      Addition First think about scope which defines what variable you have to access to  In Javascript      there are two kinds of scope Global Scope which include variable declared outside function or curly brace  let globalVariable    quot foo quot    one thing to keep in mind is once yo ve declared a globalVariable you can use it anywhere in your code even in function   Local Scope which include variable that are usable only in a specific part of your code    lets break it   function scope is when you declare a variable in a function  you can access the variable only within the function  function User        let name    quot foo quot       alert name         alert name    error    Block scope is when you declare a variable within a block then you can  access that variable only within a block    let user    quot foo quot   alert user     alert user     Uncaught ReferenceError  user is not defined at         A Closure  function User fname   return function lname    return fname    quot   quot  lname      let names   User  quot foo quot    alert names  quot bar quot        When you create a function within a function you ve created a closure  in our example above since the outer function is returned the inner function got access to outer function s scope

User · Answer

Version picture for this answer   Resolved   Just forget about scope every thing and remember  When a variable needed somewhere  javascript will not destroy it  The variable always point to newest value   Example 1     Example 2     Example 3

User · Answer

Can you explain closures to a 5-year-old   I still think Google s explanation works very well and is concise          When a function is defined in another function and it      has access to the outer function s context even after      the outer function returns      An important concept to learn in JavaScript      function outerFunction someNum        var someString    Hey        var content   document getElementById  content        function innerFunction             content innerHTML   someNum          someString          content   null     Internet Explorer memory leak for DOM reference           innerFunction       outerFunction 1       A C  question

User · Answer

A function is executed in the scope of the object function in which it is defined  The said function can access the variables defined in the object function where it has been defined while it is executing   And just take it literally     as the code is written  P

User · Answer

This is how a beginner wrapped one s head around Closures like a function is wrapped inside of a functions body also known as Closures   Definition from the book Speaking JavaScript  A closure is a function plus the connection to the scope in which the function was created  -Dr Axel Rauschmayer  So what could that look like  Here is an example  function newCounter       var counter   0     return function increment         counter    1          var counter1   newCounter    var counter2   newCounter     counter1       Number of events  1 counter1       Number of events  2 counter2       Number of events  1 counter1       Number of events  3   newCounter closes over increment  counter can be referenced to and accessed by increment   counter1 and counter2 will keep track of their own value   Simple but hopefully a clear perspective of what a closure is around all these great and advanced answers

User · Answer

An answer for a six-year-old  assuming he knows what a function is and what a variable is  and what data is    Functions can return data  One kind of data you can return from a function is another function  When that new function gets returned  all the variables and arguments used in the function that created it don t go away  Instead  that parent function  closes   In other words  nothing can look inside of it and see the variables it used except for the function it returned  That new function has a special ability to look back inside the function that created it and see the data inside of it   function the closure       var x   4    return function          return x     Here  we look back inside the closure for the value of x        var myFn   the closure    myFn        gt  4   Another really simple way to explain it is in terms of scope   Any time you create a smaller scope inside of a larger scope  the smaller scope will always be able to see what is in the larger scope

User · Answer

In JavaScript closures are awesome and unique  where variables or arguments are available to inner functions  and they will be alive even after the outer function has returned  Closures are used in most of the design patterns in JS function getFullName a  b      return a   b     function makeFullName fn       return function firstName         return function secondName           return fn firstName  secondName                 makeFullName getFullName   quot Stack quot    quot overflow quot       Stackoverflow

User · Answer

I know there are plenty of solutions already  but I guess that this small and simple script can be useful to demonstrate the concept      makeSequencer will return a  sequencer  function var makeSequencer   function         var  count   0     not accessible outside this function     var sequencer   function              return  count              return sequencer     var fnext   makeSequencer    var v0   fnext           v0   0  var v1   fnext           v1   1  var vz   fnext  count    vz   undefined

User · Answer

Even though many beautiful definitions of JavaScript closures exists on the Internet  I am trying to start explaining my six-year-old friend with my favourite definitions of closure which helped me to understand the closure much better   What is a Closure   A closure is an inner function that has access to the outer  enclosing  function   s variables   scope chain  The closure has three scope chains  it has access to its own scope  variables defined between its curly brackets   it has access to the outer function   s variables  and it has access to the global variables   A closure is the local variables for a function - kept alive after the function has returned   Closures are functions that refer to independent  free  variables  In other words  the function defined in the closure  remembers  the environment in which it was created in   Closures are an extension of the concept of scope  With closures  functions have access to variables that were available in the scope where the function was created   A closure is a stack-frame which is not deallocated when the function returns   As if a  stack-frame  were malloc ed instead of being on the stack    Languages such as Java provide the ability to declare methods private  meaning that they can only be called by other methods in the same class  JavaScript does not provide a native way of doing this  but it is possible to emulate private methods using closures   A  closure  is an expression  typically a function  that can have free variables together with an environment that binds those variables  that  closes  the expression    Closures are an abstraction mechanism that allow you to separate concerns very cleanly   Uses of Closures   Closures are useful in hiding the implementation of functionality while still revealing the interface   You can emulate the encapsulation concept in JavaScript using closures   Closures are used extensively in jQuery and Node js   While object literals are certainly easy to create and convenient for storing data  closures are often a better choice for creating static singleton namespaces in a large web application   Example of Closures   Assuming my 6-year-old friend get to know addition very recently in his primary school  I felt this example of adding the two numbers would be the simplest and apt for the six-year-old to learn the closure   Example 1  Closure is achieved here by returning a function   function makeAdder x        return function y            return x   y            var add5   makeAdder 5   var add10   makeAdder 10    console log add5 2        7 console log add10 2       12   Example 2  Closure is achieved here by returning an object literal   function makeAdder x        return           add  function y               return x   y                     var add5   makeAdder 5   console log add5 add 2     7  var add10   makeAdder 10   console log add10 add 2     12   Example 3  Closures in jQuery    function        var name  Closure is easy          div   click function               p   text name                 Useful Links    Closures  Mozilla Developer Network  Understand JavaScript Closures With Ease   Thanks to the above links which helps me to understand and explain closure better

User · Answer

The more I think about closure the more I see it as a 2-step process  init - action  init  pass first what s needed    action  in order to achieve something for later execution    To a 6-year old  I d emphasize on the practical aspect of closure   Daddy  Listen  Could you bring mum some milk  2   Tom  No problem  Daddy  Take a look at the map that Daddy has just made  mum is there and daddy is here  Daddy  But get ready first  And bring the map with you  1   it may come in handy Daddy  Then off you go  3   Ok  Tom  A piece of cake    Example  Bring some milk to mum   action   First get ready and bring the map   init    function getReady map        var cleverBoy    I examine the     map      return function what  who            return  I bring     what     to     who    because     cleverBoy    I can access the map         var offYouGo   getReady  daddy-map    offYouGo  milk    mum      Because if you bring with you a very important piece of information  the map   you re knowledgeable enough to execute other similar actions   offYouGo  potatoes    great mum      To a developer I d make a parallel between closures and OOP  The init phase is similar to passing arguments to a constructor in a traditional OO language  the action phase is ultimately the method you call to achieve what you want  And the method has access these init arguments using a mechanism called closure   See my another answer illustrating the parallelism between OO and closures   How to  quot properly quot  create a custom object in JavaScript

User · Answer

Perhaps a little beyond all but the most precocious of six-year-olds  but a few examples that helped make the concept of closure in JavaScript click for me   A closure is a function that has access to another function s scope  its variables and functions   The easiest way to create a closure is with a function within a function  the reason being that in JavaScript a function always has access to its containing function   s scope    x000D   x000D  function outerFunction     x000D      var outerVar    monkey   x000D       x000D      function innerFunction     x000D          alert outerVar   x000D        x000D       x000D      innerFunction    x000D    x000D   x000D  outerFunction    x000D   x000D   x000D    ALERT  monkey  In the above example  outerFunction is called which in turn calls innerFunction  Note how outerVar is available to innerFunction  evidenced by its correctly alerting the value of outerVar   Now consider the following    x000D   x000D  function outerFunction     x000D      var outerVar    monkey   x000D       x000D      function innerFunction     x000D          return outerVar  x000D        x000D       x000D      return innerFunction  x000D    x000D   x000D  var referenceToInnerFunction   outerFunction    x000D  alert referenceToInnerFunction     x000D   x000D   x000D    ALERT  monkey  referenceToInnerFunction is set to outerFunction    which simply returns a reference to innerFunction  When referenceToInnerFunction is called  it returns outerVar  Again  as above  this demonstrates that innerFunction has access to outerVar  a variable of outerFunction  Furthermore  it is interesting to note that it retains this access even after outerFunction has finished executing   And here is where things get really interesting  If we were to get rid of outerFunction  say set it to null  you might think that referenceToInnerFunction would loose its access to the value of outerVar  But this is not the case     x000D   x000D  function outerFunction     x000D      var outerVar    monkey   x000D       x000D      function innerFunction     x000D          return outerVar  x000D        x000D       x000D      return innerFunction  x000D    x000D   x000D  var referenceToInnerFunction   outerFunction    x000D  alert referenceToInnerFunction     x000D   x000D  outerFunction   null  x000D  alert referenceToInnerFunction     x000D   x000D   x000D    ALERT  monkey ALERT  monkey  But how is this so  How can referenceToInnerFunction still know the value of outerVar now that outerFunction has been set to null   The reason that referenceToInnerFunction can still access the value of outerVar is because when the closure was first created by placing innerFunction inside of outerFunction  innerFunction added a reference to outerFunction   s scope  its variables and functions  to its scope chain  What this means is that innerFunction has a pointer or reference to all of outerFunction   s variables  including outerVar  So even when outerFunction has finished executing  or even if it is deleted or set to null  the variables in its scope  like outerVar  stick around in memory because of the outstanding reference to them on the part of the innerFunction that has been returned to referenceToInnerFunction  To truly release outerVar and the rest of outerFunction   s variables from memory you would have to get rid of this outstanding reference to them  say by setting referenceToInnerFunction to null as well               Two other things about closures to note  First  the closure will always have access to the last values of its containing function    x000D   x000D  function outerFunction     x000D      var outerVar    monkey   x000D       x000D      function innerFunction     x000D          alert outerVar   x000D        x000D       x000D      outerVar    gorilla   x000D   x000D      innerFunction    x000D    x000D   x000D  outerFunction    x000D   x000D   x000D    ALERT  gorilla  Second  when a closure is created  it retains a reference to all of its enclosing function   s variables and functions  it doesn   t get to pick and choose  And but so  closures should be used sparingly  or at least carefully  as they can be memory intensive  a lot of variables can be kept in memory long after a containing function has finished executing

User · Answer

The word closure simply refers to being able to access objects  six-year-old  things  that are closed  six-year-old  private  within a function  six-year-old  box   Even if the function  six-year-old  box  is out of scope  six-year-old  sent far away

User · Answer

A closure is where an inner function has access to variables in its outer function  That s probably the simplest one-line explanation you can get for closures

User · Answer

Closures are simple You probably shouldn t tell a six-year old about closures  but if you do  you might say that closure gives an ability to gain access to a variable declared in some other function scope    x000D   x000D  function getA       var a             this action happens later       after the function returned      the  a  value   setTimeout function         a splice 0  0  1  2  3  4  5            return a     var a   getA    out  What is  a  length     out   a  length is     a length    setTimeout function       out  No wait         out   a  length is     a length     out  OK          x000D   lt pre id  output  gt  lt  pre gt    lt script gt    function out k        document getElementById  output   innerHTML      gt      k     n        lt  script gt  x000D   x000D   x000D

User · Answer

The author of Closures has explained closures pretty well  explaining the reason why we need them and also explaining LexicalEnvironment which is necessary to understanding closures   Here is the summary   What if a variable is accessed  but it isn   t local  Like here     In this case  the interpreter finds the variable in the outer LexicalEnvironment object   The process consists of two steps    First  when a function f is created  it is not created in an empty space  There is a current LexicalEnvironment object  In the case above  it   s window  a is undefined at the time of function creation       When a function is created  it gets a hidden property  named   Scope    which references the current LexicalEnvironment     If a variable is read  but can not be found anywhere  an error is generated   Nested functions  Functions can be nested one inside another  forming a chain of LexicalEnvironments which can also be called a scope chain     So  function g has access to g  a and f   Closures  A nested function may continue to live after the outer function has finished     Marking up LexicalEnvironments     As we see  this say is a property in the user object  so it continues to live after User completed   And if you remember  when this say is created  it  as every function  gets an internal reference this say   Scope   to the current LexicalEnvironment  So  the LexicalEnvironment of the current User execution stays in memory  All variables of User also are its properties  so they are also carefully kept  not junked as usually   The whole point is to ensure that if the inner function wants to access an outer variable in the future  it is able to do so   To summarize    The inner function keeps a reference to the outer LexicalEnvironment  The inner function may access variables from it any time even if the outer function is finished  The browser keeps the LexicalEnvironment and all its properties  variables  in memory until there is an inner function which references it    This is called a closure

User · Answer

Pinocchio  Closures in 1883  over a century before JavaScript   I think it can best be explained to a 6-year-old with a nice adventure    The part of the Adventures of Pinocchio where Pinocchio is being swallowed by an oversized dogfish      x000D   x000D  var tellStoryOfPinocchio   function original    x000D   x000D       Prepare for exciting things to happen x000D    var pinocchioFindsMisterGeppetto  x000D    var happyEnding  x000D   x000D       The story starts where Pinocchio searches for his  father  x000D    var pinocchio     x000D      name   Pinocchio   x000D      location   in the sea   x000D      noseLength  2 x000D       x000D   x000D       Is it a dog    is it a fish    x000D       The dogfish appears  however there is no such concept as the belly x000D       of the monster  there is just a monster    x000D    var terribleDogfish     x000D      swallowWhole  function snack    x000D           The swallowing of Pinocchio introduces a new environment  for the x000D           things happening inside it     x000D           The BELLY closure    with all of its guts and attributes x000D        var mysteriousLightLocation    at Gepetto  s ship   x000D   x000D           Yes  in my version of the story the monsters mouth is directly x000D           connected to its belly    This might explain the low ratings x000D           I had for biology    x000D        var mouthLocation    in the monsters mouth and then outside   x000D   x000D        var puppet   snack  x000D   x000D   x000D        puppet location    inside the belly   x000D        alert snack name     is swallowed by the terrible dogfish       x000D   x000D           Being inside the belly  Pinocchio can now experience new adventures inside it x000D        pinocchioFindsMisterGeppetto   function     x000D             The event of Pinocchio finding Mister Geppetto happens inside the x000D             belly and so it makes sence that it refers to the things inside x000D             the belly  closure  like the mysterious light and of course the x000D             hero Pinocchio himself  x000D          alert puppet name     sees a mysterious light  also in the belly of the dogfish  in the distance and swims to it to find Mister Geppetto  He survived on ship supplies for two years after being swallowed himself      x000D          puppet location   mysteriousLightLocation  x000D   x000D          alert puppet name     tells Mister Geppetto he missed him every single day      x000D          puppet noseLength    x000D          x000D   x000D        happyEnding   function     x000D             The escape of Pinocchio and Mister Geppetto happens inside the belly  x000D             it refers to Pinocchio and the mouth of the beast  x000D          alert  After finding Mister Gepetto      puppet name     and Mister Gepetto travel to the mouth of the monster     x000D          alert  The monster sleeps with its mouth open above the surface of the water  They escape through its mouth      x000D          puppet location   mouthLocation  x000D          if  original    x000D            alert puppet name     is eventually hanged for his innumerable faults      x000D            else   x000D            alert puppet name     is eventually turned into a real boy and they all lived happily ever after       x000D            x000D          x000D        x000D      x000D   x000D    alert  Once upon a time       x000D    alert  Fast forward to the moment that Pinocchio is searching for his   father         x000D    alert  Pinocchio is     pinocchio location         x000D    terribleDogfish swallowWhole pinocchio   x000D    alert  Pinocchio is     pinocchio location         x000D    pinocchioFindsMisterGeppetto    x000D    alert  Pinocchio is     pinocchio location         x000D    happyEnding    x000D    alert  Pinocchio is     pinocchio location         x000D   x000D    if  pinocchio noseLength  gt  2  x000D      console log  Hmmm    apparently a little white lie was told      x000D    x000D   x000D  tellStoryOfPinocchio false   x000D   x000D    x000D   x000D   x000D

User · Answer

As a father of a 6-year-old  currently teaching young children  and a relative novice to coding with no formal education so corrections will be required   I think the lesson would stick best through hands-on play  If the 6-year-old is ready to understand what a closure is  then they are old enough to have a go themselves  I d suggest pasting the code into jsfiddle net  explaining a bit  and leaving them alone to concoct a unique song  The explanatory text below is probably more appropriate for a 10 year old   function sing person         var firstPart    There was     person     who swallowed         var fly   function             var creature    a fly           var result    Perhaps she ll die           alert firstPart   creature     n    result               var spider   function             var creature    a spider           var result    that wiggled and jiggled and tickled inside her           alert firstPart   creature     n    result               var bird   function             var creature    a bird           var result    How absurd            alert firstPart   creature     n    result               var cat   function             var creature    a cat           var result    Imagine That            alert firstPart   creature     n    result               fly        spider        bird        cat       var person  an old lady    sing person     INSTRUCTIONS  DATA  Data is a collection of facts  It can be numbers  words  measurements  observations or even just descriptions of things  You can t touch it  smell it or taste it  You can write it down  speak it and hear it  You could use it to create touch smell and taste using a computer  It can be made useful by a computer using code   CODE  All the writing above is called code  It is written in JavaScript   JAVASCRIPT  JavaScript is a language  Like English or French or Chinese are languages  There are lots of languages that are understood by computers and other electronic processors  For JavaScript to be understood by a computer it needs an interpreter  Imagine if a teacher who only speaks Russian comes to teach your class at school  When the teacher says                the class would not understand  But luckily you have a Russian pupil in your class who tells everyone this means  everybody sit down  - so you all do  The class is like a computer and the Russian pupil is the interpreter  For JavaScript the most common interpreter is called a browser   BROWSER  When you connect to the Internet on a computer  tablet or phone to visit a website  you use a browser  Examples you may know are Internet Explorer  Chrome  Firefox and Safari  The browser can understand JavaScript and tell the computer what it needs to do  The JavaScript instructions are called functions   FUNCTION  A function in JavaScript is like a factory  It might be a little factory with only one machine inside  Or it might contain many other little factories  each with many machines doing different jobs  In a real life clothes factory you might have reams of cloth and bobbins of thread going in and T-shirts and jeans coming out  Our JavaScript factory only processes data  it can t sew  drill a hole or melt metal  In our JavaScript factory data goes in and data comes out   All this data stuff sounds a bit boring  but it is really very cool  we might have a function that tells a robot what to make for dinner  Let s say I invite you and your friend to my house  You like chicken legs best  I like sausages  your friend always wants what you want and my friend does not eat meat   I haven t got time to go shopping  so the function needs to know what we have in the fridge to make decisions  Each ingredient has a different cooking time and we want everything to be served hot by the robot at the same time  We need to provide the function with the data about what we like  the function could  talk  to the fridge  and the function could control the robot   A function normally has a name  parentheses and braces  Like this   function cookMeal          STUFF INSIDE THE FUNCTION          Note that         and    stop code being read by the browser   NAME  You can call a function just about whatever word you want  The example  cookMeal  is typical in joining two words together and giving the second one a capital letter at the beginning - but this is not necessary  It can t have a space in it  and it can t be a number on its own   PARENTHESES   Parentheses  or    are the letter box on the JavaScript function factory s door or a post box in the street for sending packets of information to the factory  Sometimes the postbox might be marked for example cookMeal you  me  yourFriend  myFriend  fridge  dinnerTime   in which case you know what data you have to give it   BRACES   Braces  which look like this    are the tinted windows of our factory  From inside the factory you can see out  but from the outside you can t see in   THE LONG CODE EXAMPLE ABOVE  Our code begins with the word function  so we know that it is one  Then the name of the function sing - that s my own description of what the function is about  Then parentheses     The parentheses are always there for a function  Sometimes they are empty  and sometimes they have something in  This one has a word in   person   After this there is a brace like this     This marks the start of the function sing    It has a partner which marks the end of sing   like this    function sing person        STUFF INSIDE THE FUNCTION         So this function might have something to do with singing  and might need some data about a person  It has instructions inside to do something with that data   Now  after the function sing    near the end of the code is the line  var person  an old lady     VARIABLE  The letters var stand for  variable   A variable is like an envelope  On the outside this envelope is marked  person   On the inside it contains a slip of paper with the information our function needs  some letters and spaces joined together like a piece of string  it s called a string  that make a phrase reading  an old lady   Our envelope could contain other kinds of things like numbers  called integers   instructions  called functions   lists  called arrays   Because this variable is written outside of all the braces     and because you can see out through the tinted windows when you are inside the braces  this variable can be seen from anywhere in the code  We call this a  global variable    GLOBAL VARIABLE  person is a global variable  meaning that if you change its value from  an old lady  to  a young man   the person will keep being a young man until you decide to change it again and that any other function in the code can see that it s a young man  Press the F12 button or look at the Options settings to open the developer console of a browser and type  person  to see what this value is  Type person  a young man  to change it and then type  person  again to see that it has changed   After this we have the line  sing person     This line is calling the function  as if it were calling a dog      Come on sing  Come and get person     When the browser has loaded the JavaScript code an reached this line  it will start the function  I put the line at the end to make sure that the browser has all the information it needs to run it   Functions define actions  - the main function is about singing  It contains a variable called firstPart which applies to the singing about the person that applies to each of the verses of the song   There was     person     who swallowed   If you type firstPart into the console  you won t get an answer because the variable is locked up in a function - the browser can t see inside the tinted windows of the braces   CLOSURES  The closures are the smaller functions that are inside the big sing   function  The little factories inside the big factory  They each have their own braces which mean that the variables inside them can t be seen from the outside  That s why the names of the variables  creature and result  can be repeated in the closures but with different values  If you type these variable names in the console window  you won t get its value because it s hidden by two layers of tinted windows   The closures all know what the sing   function s variable called firstPart is  because they can see out from their tinted windows   After the closures come the lines  fly    spider    bird    cat      The sing   function will call each of these functions in the order they are given  Then the sing   function s work will be done

User · Answer

How I d explain it to a six-year-old   You know how grown-ups can own a house  and they call it home  When a mom has a child  the child doesn t really own anything  right  But its parents own a house  so whenever someone asks the child  Where s your home    he she can answer  that house    and point to the house of its parents  A  Closure  is the ability of the child to always  even if abroad  be able to say it has a home  even though it s really the parent s who own the house

User · Answer

A closure is a pairing of   A function  and A reference to that function s outer scope  lexical environment   A lexical environment is part of every execution context  stack frame  and is a map between identifiers  ie  local variable names  and values  Every function in JavaScript maintains a reference to its outer lexical environment  This reference is used to configure the execution context created when a function is invoked  This reference enables code inside the function to  quot see quot  variables declared outside the function  regardless of when and where the function is called  If a function was called by a function  which in turn was called by another function  then a chain of references to outer lexical environments is created  This chain is called the scope chain  In the following code  inner forms a closure with the lexical environment of the execution context created when foo is invoked  closing over variable secret   x000D   x000D  function foo       const secret   Math trunc Math random   100    return function inner         console log  The secret number is   secret           const f   foo       secret  is not directly accessible from outside  foo  f      The only way to retrieve  secret   is to invoke  f  x000D   x000D   x000D   In other words  in JavaScript  functions carry a reference to a private  quot box of state quot   to which only they  and any other functions declared within the same lexical environment  have access  This box of the state is invisible to the caller of the function  delivering an excellent mechanism for data-hiding and encapsulation  And remember  functions in JavaScript can be passed around like variables  first-class functions   meaning these pairings of functionality and state can be passed around your program  similar to how you might pass an instance of a class around in C    If JavaScript did not have closures  then more states would have to be passed between functions explicitly  making parameter lists longer and code noisier  So  if you want a function to always have access to a private piece of state  you can use a closure     and frequently we do want to associate the state with a function  For example  in Java or C    when you add a private instance variable and a method to a class  you are associating state with functionality  In C and most other common languages  after a function returns  all the local variables are no longer accessible because the stack-frame is destroyed  In JavaScript  if you declare a function within another function  then the local variables of the outer function can remain accessible after returning from it  In this way  in the code above  secret remains available to the function object inner  after it has been returned from foo  Uses of Closures Closures are useful whenever you need a private state associated with a function  This is a very common scenario - and remember  JavaScript did not have a class syntax until 2015  and it still does not have a private field syntax  Closures meet this need  Private Instance Variables In the following code  the function toString closes over the details of the car   x000D   x000D  function Car manufacturer  model  year  color      return       toString           return    manufacturer    model     year     color                const car   new Car  Aston Martin   V8 Vantage   2012   Quantum Silver   console log car toString    x000D   x000D   x000D   Functional Programming In the following code  the function inner closes over both fn and args   x000D   x000D  function curry fn      const args        return function inner arg        if args length     fn length  return fn    args      args push arg      return inner        function add a  b      return a   b    const curriedAdd   curry add  console log curriedAdd 2  3        5 x000D   x000D   x000D   Event-Oriented Programming In the following code  function onClick closes over variable BACKGROUND COLOR   x000D   x000D  const     document querySelector bind document  const BACKGROUND COLOR    rgba 200 200 242 1    function onClick          body   style background   BACKGROUND COLOR       button   addEventListener  click   onClick  x000D   lt button gt Set background color lt  button gt  x000D   x000D   x000D   Modularization In the following example  all the implementation details are hidden inside an immediately executed function expression  The functions tick and toString close over the private state and functions they need to complete their work  Closures have enabled us to modularise and encapsulate our code   x000D   x000D  let namespace         function foo n      let numbers        function format n        return Math trunc n        function tick         numbers push Math random     100        function toString         return numbers map format        n counter         tick      toString       namespace    const counter   namespace counter counter tick   counter tick   console log counter toString    x000D   x000D   x000D   Examples Example 1 This example shows that the local variables are not copied in the closure  the closure maintains a reference to the original variables themselves  It is as though the stack-frame stays alive in memory even after the outer function exits   x000D   x000D  function foo       let x   42   let inner    function     console log x      x   x 1   return inner   var f   foo   f      logs 43 x000D   x000D   x000D   Example 2 In the following code  three methods log  increment  and update all close over the same lexical environment  And every time createObject is called  a new execution context  stack frame  is created and a completely new variable x  and a new set of functions  log etc   are created  that close over this new variable   x000D   x000D  function createObject       let x   42    return       log     console log x         increment     x          update value    x   value          const o   createObject   o increment   o log      43 o update 5  o log      5 const p   createObject   p log      42 x000D   x000D   x000D   Example 3 If you are using variables declared using var  be careful you understand which variable you are closing over  Variables declared using var are hoisted  This is much less of a problem in modern JavaScript due to the introduction of let and const  In the following code  each time around the loop  a new function inner is created  which closes over i  But because var i is hoisted outside the loop  all of these inner functions close over the same variable  meaning that the final value of i  3  is printed  three times   x000D   x000D  function foo       var result        for  var i   0  i  lt  3  i          result push function inner     console log i            return result    const result   foo      The following will print  3   three times    for  var i   0  i  lt  3  i        result i       x000D   x000D   x000D   Final points   Whenever a function is declared in JavaScript closure is created  Returning a function from inside another function is the classic example of closure  because the state inside the outer function is implicitly available to the returned inner function  even after the outer function has completed execution  Whenever you use eval   inside a function  a closure is used  The text you eval can reference local variables of the function  and in the non-strict mode  you can even create new local variables by using eval  var foo          When you use new Function       the Function constructor  inside a function  it does not close over its lexical environment  it closes over the global context instead  The new function cannot reference the local variables of the outer function  A closure in JavaScript is like keeping a reference  NOT a copy  to the scope at the point of function declaration  which in turn keeps a reference to its outer scope  and so on  all the way to the global object at the top of the scope chain  A closure is created when a function is declared  this closure is used to configure the execution context when the function is invoked  A new set of local variables is created every time a function is called   Links  Douglas Crockford s simulated private attributes and private methods for an object  using closures  A great explanation of how closures can cause memory leaks in IE if you are not careful  MDN documentation on JavaScript Closures

User · Answer

For a six-year-old   You and your family live in the mythical town of Ann Ville  You have a friend who lives next door  so you call them and ask them to come out and play  You dial      000001  jamiesHouse    After a month  you and your family move out of Ann Ville to the next town  but you and your friend still keep in touch  so now you have to dial the area code for the town that your friend lives in  before dialling their  proper  number      001 000001  annVille jamiesHouse    A year after that  your parents move to a whole new country  but you and your friend still keep in touch  so after bugging your parents to let you make international rate calls  you now dial      01 001 000001  myOldCountry annVille jamiesHouse    Strangely though  after moving to your new country  you and your family just so happen to move to a new town called Ann Ville    and you just so happen to make friends with some new person called Jamie    You give them a call        000001  jamiesHouse    Spooky     So spooky in fact  that you tell Jamie from your old country about it    You have a good laugh about it  So one day  you and your family take a holiday back to the old country  You visit your old town  Ann Ville   and go to visit Jamie       Really  Another Jamie  In Ann Ville  In your new country      Yeah    Let s call them          02 001 000001  myNewCountry annVille jamiesHouse    Opinions   What s more  I have a load of questions about the patience of a modern six-year-old

User · Answer

Closures allow JavaScript programmers to write better code  Creative  expressive  and concise  We frequently use closures in JavaScript  and  no matter our JavaScript experience  we undoubtedly encounter them time and again  Closures might appear complex but hopefully  after you read this  closures will be much more easily understood and thus more appealing for your everyday JavaScript programming tasks   You should be familiar with JavaScript variable scope before you read further because to understand closures you must understand JavaScript   s variable scope   What is a closure   A closure is an inner function that has access to the outer  enclosing  function   s variables   scope chain  The closure has three scope chains  it has access to its own scope  variables defined between its curly brackets   it has access to the outer function   s variables  and it has access to the global variables   The inner function has access not only to the outer function   s variables  but also to the outer function   s parameters  Note that the inner function cannot call the outer function   s arguments object  however  even though it can call the outer function   s parameters directly   You create a closure by adding a function inside another function   A Basic Example of Closures in JavaScript     x000D   x000D  function showName  firstName  lastName     x000D    var nameIntro    Your name is    x000D       this inner function has access to the outer function s variables  including the parameter x000D     function makeFullName                   x000D       return nameIntro   firstName         lastName           x000D      x000D    x000D     return makeFullName      x000D     x000D    x000D  showName   Michael    Jackson       Your name is Michael Jackson  x000D   x000D   x000D    Closures are used extensively in Node js  they are workhorses in Node js    asynchronous  non-blocking architecture  Closures are also frequently used in jQuery and just about every piece of JavaScript code you read   A Classic jQuery Example of Closures     x000D   x000D    function     x000D    x000D     var selections        x000D        niners   click function        this closure has access to the selections variable  x000D      selections push  this prop  name        update the selections variable in the outer function s scope  x000D        x000D       x000D   x000D   x000D    Closures    Rules and Side Effects  1  Closures have access to the outer function   s variable even after the outer function returns   One of the most important and ticklish features with closures is that the inner function still has access to the outer function   s variables even after the outer function has returned  Yep  you read that correctly  When functions in JavaScript execute  they use the same scope chain that was in effect when they were created  This means that even after the outer function has returned  the inner function still has access to the outer function   s variables  Therefore  you can call the inner function later in your program  This example demonstrates    x000D   x000D  function celebrityName  firstName    x000D      var nameIntro    This celebrity is    x000D         this inner function has access to the outer function s variables  including the parameter  x000D     function lastName  theLastName    x000D          return nameIntro   firstName         theLastName  x000D        x000D      return lastName  x000D    x000D    x000D   var mjName   celebrityName   Michael       At this juncture  the celebrityName outer function has returned   x000D    x000D      The closure  lastName  is called here after the outer function has returned above  x000D      Yet  the closure still has access to the outer function s variables and parameter  x000D  mjName   Jackson       This celebrity is Michael Jackson  x000D   x000D   x000D    2  Closures store references to the outer function   s variables   They do not store the actual value   Closures get more interesting when the value of the outer function   s variable changes before the closure is called  And this powerful feature can be harnessed in creative ways  such as this private variables example first demonstrated by Douglas Crockford     x000D   x000D  function celebrityID      x000D      var celebrityID   999  x000D         We are returning an object with some inner functions  x000D         All the inner functions have access to the outer function s variables  x000D      return   x000D          getID  function       x000D                 This inner function will return the UPDATED celebrityID variable  x000D                 It will return the current value of celebrityID  even after the changeTheID function changes it  x000D            return celebrityID  x000D             x000D          setID  function  theNewID     x000D                 This inner function will change the outer function s variable anytime  x000D              celebrityID   theNewID  x000D            x000D        x000D    x000D    x000D    x000D   var mjID   celebrityID        At this juncture  the celebrityID outer function has returned   x000D  mjID getID       999  x000D  mjID setID 567      Changes the outer function s variable  x000D  mjID getID       567  It returns the updated celebrityId variable  x000D   x000D   x000D    3  Closures Gone Awry  Because closures have access to the updated values of the outer function   s variables  they can also lead to bugs when the outer function   s variable changes with a for loop  Thus    x000D   x000D     This example is explained in detail below  just after this code box    x000D   function celebrityIDCreator  theCelebrities    x000D      var i  x000D      var uniqueID   100  x000D      for  i   0  i  lt  theCelebrities length  i      x000D        theCelebrities i   id     function       x000D          return uniqueID   i  x000D          x000D        x000D       x000D      return theCelebrities  x000D    x000D    x000D   var actionCelebs     name  Stallone   id 0    name  Cruise   id 0    name  Willis   id 0    x000D    x000D   var createIdForActionCelebs   celebrityIDCreator  actionCelebs   x000D    x000D   var stalloneID   createIdForActionCelebs  0        console log stalloneID id        103 x000D   x000D   x000D        More can be found here-   http   javascript info tutorial closures http   www javascriptkit com javatutors closures shtml

User · Answer

Closure are not difficult to understand  It depends only from the point of view   I personally like to use them in cases of daily life   function createCar         var rawMaterial       lots of object          function transformation rawMaterials                  lots of changement here           return transformedMaterial            var transformedMaterial   transformation rawMaterial       function assemblage transformedMaterial                  Assemblage of parts           return car            return assemblage transformedMaterial       We only need to go through certain steps in particular cases  As for the transformation of materials is only useful when you have the parts

User · Answer

A closure is something many JavaScript developers use all the time  but we take it for granted  How it works is not that complicated  Understanding how to use it purposefully is complex   At its simplest definition  as other answers have pointed out   a closure is basically a function defined inside another function  And that inner function has access to variables defined in the scope of the outer function  The most common practice that you ll see using closures is defining variables and functions in the global scope  and having access to those variables in the function scope of that function   var x   1  function myFN       alert x     1  as opposed to undefined       Or function a        var x   1     function b            alert x     1  as opposed to undefined          b        So what   A closure isn t that special to a JavaScript user until you think about what life would be like without them  In other languages  variables used in a function get cleaned up when that function returns  In the above  x would have been a  null pointer   and you d need to establish a getter and setter and start passing references  Doesn t sound like JavaScript right  Thank the mighty closure   Why should I care   You don t really have to be aware of closures to use them  But as others have also pointed out  they can be leveraged to create faux private variables  Until you get to needing private variables  just use them like you always have

User · Answer

I am not taking the 6-years-old thing into account    In a language like JavaScript  where you can pass functions as parameters to other functions  languages where functions are first class citizens   you will often find yourself doing something like   var name    Rafael    var sayName   function       console log name        You see  sayName doesn t have the definition for the name variable  but it does use the value of name that was defined outside of sayName  in a parent scope    Let s say you pass sayName as a parameter to another function  that will call sayName as a callback   functionThatTakesACallback sayName     Note that    sayName will be called from inside functionThatTakesACallback  assume that  since I haven t implemented functionThatTakesACallback in this example   When sayName is called  it will log the value of the name variable  functionThatTakesACallback doesn t define a name variable  well  it could  but it wouldn t matter  so assume it doesn t     So we have sayName being called inside functionThatTakesACallback and referring to a name variable that is not defined inside functionThatTakesACallback   What happens then  A ReferenceError  name is not defined   No  The value of name is captured inside a closure  You can think of this closure as context associated to a function  that holds the values that were available where that function was defined   So  Even though name is not in scope where the function sayName will be called  inside functionThatTakesACallback   sayName can access the value for name that is captured in the closure associated with sayName   --  From the book Eloquent JavaScript      A good mental model is to think of function values as containing both the code in their body and the environment in which they are created  When called  the function body sees its original environment  not the environment in which the call is made

User · Answer

Closures are simple   The following simple example covers all the main points of JavaScript closures    nbsp   Here is a factory that produces calculators that can add and multiply   function make calculator       var n   0     this calculator stores a single number n   return       add  function a          n    a        return n             multiply  function a          n    a        return n                first calculator   make calculator    second calculator   make calculator     first calculator add 3      returns 3 second calculator add 400      returns 400  first calculator multiply 11      returns 33 second calculator multiply 10      returns 4000   The key point  Each call to make calculator creates a new local variable n  which continues to be usable by that calculator s add and multiply functions long after make calculator returns   If you are familiar with stack frames  these calculators seem strange  How can they keep accessing n after make calculator returns   The answer is to imagine that JavaScript doesn t use  stack frames   but instead uses  heap frames   which can persist after the function call that made them returns   Inner functions like add and multiply  which access variables declared in an outer function    are called closures   That is pretty much all there is to closures         For example  it covers all the points in the  Closures for Dummies  article given in another answer  except example 6  which simply shows that variables can be used before they are declared  a nice fact to know but completely unrelated to closures  It also covers all the points in the accepted answer  except for the points  1  that functions copy their arguments into local variables  the named function arguments   and  2  that copying numbers creates a new number  but copying an object reference gives you another reference to the same object  These are also good to know but again completely unrelated to closures  It is also very similar to the example in this answer but a bit shorter and less abstract  It does not cover the point of this answer or this comment  which is that JavaScript makes it difficult to plug the current value of a loop variable into your inner function  The  plugging in  step can only be done with a helper function that encloses your inner function and is invoked on each loop iteration   Strictly speaking  the inner function accesses the helper function s copy of the variable  rather than having anything plugged in   Again  very useful when creating closures  but not part of what a closure is or how it works  There is additional confusion due to closures working differently in functional languages like ML  where variables are bound to values rather than to storage space  providing a constant stream of people who understand closures in a way  namely the  plugging in  way  that is simply incorrect for JavaScript  where variables are always bound to storage space  and never to values       Any outer function  if several are nested  or even in the global context  as this answer points out clearly

User · Answer

The following example is a simple illustration of a JavaScript closure  This is the closure function  which returns a function  with access to its local variable x   function outer x        return function inner y            return x y             Invoke the function like this   var add10   outer 10   add10 20      The result will be 30 add10 40      The result will be 50  var add20   outer 20   add20 20      The result will be 40 add20 40      The result will be 60

User · Answer

I found very clear chapter 8 section 6   Closures   of JavaScript  The Definitive Guide by David Flanagan  6th edition  O Reilly  2011  I ll try to paraphrase      When a function is invoked  a new object is created to hold the local variables for that invocation    A function s scope depends on its declaration location  not its execution location    Now  assume an inner function declared within an outer function and referring to variables of that outer function  Further assume the outer function returns the inner function  as a function  Now there is an external reference to whatever values were in the inner function s scope  which  by our assumptions  includes values from the outer function    JavaScript will preserve those values  as they have remained in scope of the current execution thanks to being passed out of the completed outer function  All functions are closures  but the closures of interest are the inner functions which  in our assumed scenario  preserve outer function values within their  enclosure   I hope I m using language correctly here  when they  the inner functions  are returned from outer functions  I know this doesn t meet the six-year-old requirement  but hopefully it is still helpful

User · Answer

A closure is a function having access to the parent scope  even after the parent function has closed    So basically a closure is a function of another function  We can say like a child function      A closure is an inner function that has access to the outer    enclosing  function   s variables   scope chain  The closure has three   scope chains  it has access to its own scope  variables defined   between its curly brackets   it has access to the outer function   s   variables  and it has access to the global variables       The inner function has access not only to the outer function   s   variables but also to the outer function   s parameters  Note that the   inner function cannot call the outer function   s arguments object    however  even though it can call the outer function   s parameters   directly       You create a closure by adding a function inside another function    Also  it s very useful method which is used in many famous frameworks including Angular  Node js and jQuery      Closures are used extensively in Node js  they are workhorses in   Node js    asynchronous  non-blocking architecture  Closures are also   frequently used in jQuery and just about every piece of JavaScript   code you read    But how the closures look like in a real-life coding  Look at this simple sample code   function showName firstName  lastName          var nameIntro    Your name is             this inner function has access to the outer function s variables  including the parameter       function makeFullName               return nameIntro   firstName         lastName                return makeFullName           console log showName  Michael    Jackson        Your name is Michael Jackson   Also  this is classic closure way in jQuery which every javascript and jQuery developers used it a lot     function         var selections               niners   click function        this closure has access to the selections variable         selections push this prop  name        update the selections variable in the outer function s scope               But why we use closures  when we use it in an actual programming  what are the practical use of closures  the below is a good explanation and example by MDN   Practical closures     Closures are useful because they let you associate some data  the   lexical environment  with a function that operates on that data  This   has obvious parallels to object oriented programming  where objects   allow us to associate some data  the object s properties  with one or   more methods       Consequently  you can use a closure anywhere that you might normally   use an object with only a single method       Situations where you might want to do this are particularly common on   the web  Much of the code we write in front-end JavaScript is   event-based     we define some behavior  then attach it to an event that   is triggered by the user  such as a click or a keypress   Our code is   generally attached as a callback  a single function which is executed   in response to the event       For instance  suppose we wish to add some buttons to a page that   adjust the text size  One way of doing this is to specify the   font-size of the body element in pixels  then set the size of the   other elements on the page  such as headers  using the relative em   unit    Read the code below and run the code to see how closure help us here to easily make separate functions for each sections    x000D   x000D    javascript x000D  function makeSizer size    x000D    return function     x000D      document body style fontSize   size    px   x000D       x000D    x000D   x000D  var size12   makeSizer 12   x000D  var size14   makeSizer 14   x000D  var size16   makeSizer 16   x000D   x000D  document getElementById  size-12   onclick   size12  x000D  document getElementById  size-14   onclick   size14  x000D  document getElementById  size-16   onclick   size16  x000D    css   x000D  body   x000D    font-family  Helvetica  Arial  sans-serif  x000D    font-size  12px  x000D    x000D   x000D  h1   x000D    font-size  1 5em  x000D    x000D   x000D  h2   x000D    font-size  1 2em  x000D    x000D   lt  --html gt  lt  -- gt  x000D   lt p gt Some paragraph text lt  p gt  x000D   lt h1 gt some heading 1 text lt  h1 gt  x000D   lt h2 gt some heading 2 text lt  h2 gt  x000D   x000D   lt a href     id  size-12  gt 12 lt  a gt  x000D   lt a href     id  size-14  gt 14 lt  a gt  x000D   lt a href     id  size-16  gt 16 lt  a gt  x000D   x000D   x000D    For further study about closures  I recommend you to visit this page by MDN  https   developer mozilla org en docs Web JavaScript Closures

User · Answer

A closure is simply when a function have access to its outside scope even after the scope s function has finished executing   Example    function multiplier n        function multiply x              return n x            return mutliply     var 10xmultiplier   multiplier 10   var x   10xmultiplier 5      x  50   we can see that even after multiplier has finished executing  the inner function multiply gets still access to the value of x which is 10 in this example   A very common use of closures is currying  the same example above  where we spice our function progressively with parameters instead of supplying all of the arguments at once   We can achieve this because Javascript  in addition to the prototypal OOP  allows as to program in a functional fashion where higher order functions can take other functions as arguments  fisrt class functions   functional programming in wikipedia  I highly recommend you to read this book by Kyle Simpson  2 one part of the book series is dedicated to closures and it is called scope and closures  you don t know js  free reading on github

User · Answer

A closure is a function having access to the parent scope  even after the parent function has closed    var add    function       var counter   0    return function         return counter    1             add    add    add       The counter is now 3   Example explained    The variable add is assigned the return value of a self-invoking function  The self-invoking function only runs once  It sets the counter to zero  0   and returns a function expression  This way add becomes a function  The  wonderful  part is that it can access the counter in the parent scope  This is called a JavaScript closure  It makes it possible for a function to have  private  variables  The counter is protected by the scope of the anonymous function  and can only be changed using the add function    Source

User · Answer

After a function is invoked  it goes out of scope  If that function contains something like a callback function  then that callback function is still in scope  If the callback function references some local variable in the immediate environment of the parent function  then naturally you d expect that variable to be inaccessible to the callback function and return undefined   Closures ensure that any property that is referenced by the callback function is available for use by that function  even when its parent function may have gone out of scope

User · Answer

Closures are a means through which inner functions can refer to the variables present in their outer enclosing function after their parent functions have already terminated      A function that generates a new function for adding numbers  function addGenerator  num            Return a simple function for adding two numbers        with the first number borrowed from the generator     return function  toAdd             return num   toAdd              addFive now contains a function that takes one argument     adds five to it  and returns the resulting number  var addFive   addGenerator  5       We can see here that the result of the addFive function is 9     when passed an argument of 4  alert  addFive  4      9

User · Answer

A closure is a block of code which meets three criteria    It can be passed around as a value and executed on demand by anyone who has that value  at which time it can refer to variables from the context in which it was created  that is  it is closed with respect to variable access  in the mathematical sense of the word  closed       The word  closure  actually has an imprecise meaning  and some people don t think that criterion  1 is part of the definition  I think it is    Closures are a mainstay of functional languages  but they are present in many other languages as well  for example  Java s anonymous inner classes   You can do cool stuff with them  they allow deferred execution and some elegant tricks of style   By  Paul Cantrell    http   innig net software ruby closures-in-ruby

User · Answer

A closure is a function that has access to information from the environment it was defined in   For some  the information is the value in the environment at the time of creation   For others  the information is the variables in the environment at the time of creation   If the lexical environment that the closure refers to belongs to a function that has exited  then  in the case of a closure referring to the variables in the environment  those lexical variables will continue to exist for reference by the closure   A closure can be thought of a special case of global variables -- with a private copy created just for the function   Or it can be thought of as a method where the environment is a specific instance of an object whose properties are the variables in the environment   The former  closure as environment  similar to the latter where the environment copy is a context variable passed to each function in the former  and the instance variables form a context variable in the latter   So a closure is a way to call a function without having to specify the context explicitly as a parameter or as the object in a method invocation   var closure   createclosure varForClosure   closure param1       closure has access to whatever createclosure gave it access to                       including the parameter storing varForClosure    vs  var contextvar   varForClosure     use a struct for storing more than one   contextclosure contextvar  param1     vs  var contextobj   new contextclass varForClosure   contextobj- gt objclosure param1     For maintainable code  I recommend the object oriented way   However for a quick and easy set of tasks  for example creating a callback   a closure can become natural and more clear  especially in the context of lamda or anonymous functions

User · Answer

A closure is created when the inner function is somehow made available to any scope outside the outer function   Example   var outer   function params     Outer function defines a variable called params     var inner   function       Inner function has access to the params variable of the outer function         return params            return inner    Return inner function exposing it to outer scope    myFunc   outer  myParams    myFunc      Returns  myParams

User · Answer

If you understand it well you can explain it simple  And the simplest way is abstracting it from the context  Code aside  even programming aside  A metaphor example will do it better   Let s imagine that a function is a room whose walls are of glass  but they are special glass  like the ones in an interrogation room  From outside they are opaque  from inside they are transparent  It can be rooms inside other rooms  and the only way of contact is a phone   If you call from the outside  you don t know what is in it  but you know that the people inside will do a task if you give them certain information  They can see outside  so they can ask you for stuff that are outside and make changes to that stuff  but you can t change what it is inside from the outside  you don t even see  know  what it is inside  The people inside that room you are calling see what it is outside  but not what it is inside the rooms in that room  so they interact with them the way you are doing from outside  The people inside the most inner rooms can see many things  but the people of the most outer room  don t even know about the most inner rooms  existence   For each call to an inner room  the people in that room keeps a record of the information about that specific call  and they are so good doing that that they never mistake one call stuff with other call stuff   Rooms are functions  visibility is scope  people doing task is statements  stuff are objects  phone calls are function calls  phone call information is arguments  call records are scope instances  the most outer room is the global object

User · Answer

To understand closures you have to get down to the program and literally execute as if you are the run time  Let s look at this simple piece of code     JavaScript runs the code in two phases    Compilation Phase       JavaScript is not a pure interpreted language Execution Phase   When JavaScript goes through the compilation phase it extract out the declarations of variables and functions  This is called hoisting  Functions encountered in this phase are saved as text blobs in memory also known as lambda  After compilation JavaScript enters the execution phase where it assigns all the values and runs the function  To run the function it prepares the execution context by assigning memory from the heap and repeating the compilation and execution phase for the function  This memory area is called scope of the function  There is a global scope when execution starts  Scopes are the key in understanding closures   In this example  in first go  variable a is defined and then f is defined in the compilation phase  All undeclared variables are saved in the global scope  In the execution phase f is called with an argument  f s scope is assigned and the compilation and execution phase is repeated for it   Arguments are also saved in this local scope for f  Whenever a local execution context or scope is created it contain a reference pointer to its parent scope  All variable access follows this lexical scope chain to find its value  If a variable is not found in the local scope it follows the chain and find it in its parent scope  This is also why a local variable overrides variables in the parent scope  The parent scope is called the  Closure  for local a scope or function   Here when g s scope is being set up it got a lexical pointer to its parents scope of f  The scope of f is the closure for g  In JavaScript  if there is some reference to functions  objects or scopes if you can reach them somehow  it will not get garbage collected  So when myG is running  it has a pointer to scope of f which is its closure  This area of memory will not get garbage collected even f has returned  This is a closure as far as the runtime is concerned   SO WHAT IS A CLOSURE    It is an implicit  permanent link between a function and its scope chain    A function definition s  lambda  hidden   scope   reference  Holds the scope chain  preventing garbage collection   It is used and copied as the  outer environment reference  anytime the function is run    IMPLICIT CLOSURE  var data    My Data    setTimeout function       console log data      Prints  My Data      3000     EXPLICIT CLOSURES  function makeAdder n      var inc   n    var sum   0    return function add         sum   sum   inc      return sum          var adder3   makeAdder 3     A very interesting talk on closures and more is Arindam Paul - JavaScript VM internals  EventLoop  Async and ScopeChains

User · Answer

Closure is when a function is closed in a way that it was defined in a namespace which is immutable by the time the function is called   In JavaScript  it happens when you    Define one function inside the other function The inner function is called after the outer function returned         name  is resolved in the namespace created for one invocation of bindMessage    the processor cannot enter this namespace by the time displayMessage is called function bindMessage name  div         function displayMessage             alert  This is     name                div  click displayMessage

User · Answer

I wrote a blog post a while back explaining closures  Here s what I said about closures in terms of why you d want one      Closures are a way to let a function   have persistent  private variables -   that is  variables that only one   function knows about  where it can   keep track of info from previous times   that it was run    In that sense  they let a function act a bit like an object with private attributes   Full post   So what are these closure thingys

User · Answer

This is an attempt to clear up several  possible  misunderstandings about closures that appear in some of the other answers    A closure is not only created when you return an inner function  In fact  the enclosing function does not need to return at all in order for its closure to be created  You might instead assign your inner function to a variable in an outer scope  or pass it as an argument to another function where it could be called immediately or any time later  Therefore  the closure of the enclosing function is probably created as soon as the enclosing function is called since any inner function has access to that closure whenever the inner function is called  before or after the enclosing function returns   A closure does not reference a copy of the old values of variables in its scope  The variables themselves are part of the closure  and so the value seen when accessing one of those variables is the latest value at the time it is accessed  This is why inner functions created inside of loops can be tricky  since each one has access to the same outer variables rather than grabbing a copy of the variables at the time the function is created or called  The  variables  in a closure include any named functions declared within the function  They also include arguments of the function  A closure also has access to its containing closure s variables  all the way up to the global scope  Closures use memory  but they don t cause memory leaks since JavaScript by itself cleans up its own circular structures that are not referenced  Internet nbsp Explorer memory leaks involving closures are created when it fails to disconnect DOM attribute values that reference closures  thus maintaining references to possibly circular structures

User · Answer

Example for the first point by dlaliberte      A closure is not only created when you return an inner function  In fact  the enclosing function does not need to return at all  You might instead assign your inner function to a variable in an outer scope  or pass it as an argument to another function where it could be used immediately  Therefore  the closure of the enclosing function probably already exists at the time that enclosing function was called since any inner function has access to it as soon as it is called    var i  function foo x        var tmp   3      i   function  y            console log x   y      tmp            foo 2   i 3

User · Answer

I like Kyle Simpson s definition of a closure        Closure is when a function is able to remember and access its lexical   scope even when that function is executing outside its lexical scope    Lexical scope is when an inner scope can access its outer scope   Here is a modified example he provides in his book series  You Don t Know JS  Scopes  amp  Closures     function foo       var a   2     function bar         console log  a          return bar     function test       var bz   foo      bz          prints 2  Here function bar referred by var bz is outside     its lexical scope but it can still access it test

User · Answer

Okay  talking with a 6-year old child  I would possibly use following associations      Imagine - you are playing with your little brothers and sisters in the entire house  and you are moving around with your toys and brought some of them into your older brother s room  After a while your brother returned from the school and went to his room  and he locked inside it  so now you could not access toys left there anymore in a direct way  But you could knock the door and ask your brother for that toys  This is called toy s closure  your brother made it up for you  and he is now into outer scope    Compare with a situation when a door was locked by draft and nobody inside  general function execution   and then some local fire occur and burn down the room  garbage collector D   and then a new room was build and now you may leave another toys there  new function instance   but never get the same toys which were left in the first room instance   For an advanced child I would put something like the following  It is not perfect  but it makes you feel about what it is   function playingInBrothersRoom  withToys         We closure toys which we played in the brother s room  When he come back and lock the door      your brother is supposed to be into the outer   scope   object now  Thanks god you could communicate with him    var closureToys   withToys              returnToy  countIt  toy     Just another closure helpers  for brother s inner use     var brotherGivesToyBack   function  toy           New request  There is not yet closureToys on brother s hand yet  Give him a time      returnToy   null      if  toy  amp  amp  closureToys length  gt  0       If we ask for a specific toy  the brother is going to search for it         for   countIt   closureToys length  countIt  countIt--            if  closureToys countIt - 1     toy              returnToy    Take your     closureToys splice countIt - 1  1       little boy              break                          returnToy   returnToy     Hey  I could not find any     toy     here  Look for it in another room              else if  closureToys length  gt  0       Otherwise  just give back everything he has in the room        returnToy    Behold      closureToys join                    closureToys                 else         returnToy    Hey  lil shrimp  I gave you everything              console log returnToy         return brotherGivesToyBack       You are playing in the house  including the brother s room  var toys     teddybear    car    jumpingrope        askBrotherForClosuredToy   playingInBrothersRoom toys       The door is locked  and the brother came from the school  You could not cheat and take it out directly  console log askBrotherForClosuredToy closureToys      Undefined     But you could ask your brother politely  to give it back  askBrotherForClosuredToy  teddybear       Hooray  here it is  teddybear askBrotherForClosuredToy  ball       The brother would not be able to find it  askBrotherForClosuredToy       The brother gives you all the rest askBrotherForClosuredToy       Nothing left in there   As you can see  the toys left in the room are still accessible via the brother and no matter if the room is locked  Here is a jsbin to play around with it

User · Answer

FOREWORD  this answer was written when the question was      Like the old Albert said    If you can t explain it to a six-year old  you really don t understand it yourself      Well I tried to explain JS closures to a 27 years old friend and completely failed       Can anybody consider that I am 6 and strangely interested in that subject     I m pretty sure I was one of the only people that attempted to take the initial question literally  Since then  the question has mutated several times  so my answer may now seem incredibly silly  amp  out of place  Hopefully the general idea of the story remains fun for some     I m a big fan of analogy and metaphor when explaining difficult concepts  so let me try my hand with a story   Once upon a time   There was a princess     function princess       She lived in a wonderful world full of adventures  She met her Prince Charming  rode around her world on a unicorn  battled dragons  encountered talking animals  and many other fantastical things       var adventures            function princeCharming                      var unicorn                          dragons                          squirrel    Hello                     But she would always have to return back to her dull world of chores and grown-ups       return     And she would often tell them of her latest amazing adventure as a princess           story  function                 return adventures adventures length - 1                        But all they would see is a little girl     var littleGirl   princess         telling stories about magic and fantasy   littleGirl story      And even though the grown-ups knew of real princesses  they would never believe in the unicorns or dragons because they could never see them  The grown-ups said that they only existed inside the little girl s imagination   But we know the real truth  that the little girl with the princess inside        is really a princess with a little girl inside

User · Answer

MDN explains it best I think      Closures are functions that refer to independent  free  variables  In other words  the function defined in the closure  remembers  the environment in which it was created    A closure always has an outer function and an inner function  The inner function is where all the work happens  and the outer function is just the environment that preserves the scope where the inner function was created  In this way  the inner function of a closure  remembers  the environment scope in which it was created  The most classic example is a counter function   var closure   function       var count   0    return function         count        console log count            var counter   closure     counter      returns 1 counter      returns 2 counter      returns 3   In the above code  count is preserved by the outer function  environment function   so that every time you call counter    the inner function  work function  can increment it

User · Answer

For a six-year-old      Do you know what objects are   Objects are things that have properties and do stuff   One of the most important things about closures is that they let you make objects in JavaScript  Objects in JavaScript are just functions and closures that lets JavaScript store the value of the property for the object once it has been created   Objects are very useful and keep everything nice and organised  Different objects can do different jobs and working together objects can do complicated things   It s lucky that JavaScript has closures for making objects  otherwise everything would become a messy nightmare

User · Answer

Meet the illustrated explanation  How do JavaScript closures work behind the scenes   The article explains how the scope objects  or LexicalEnvironments  are allocated and used in an intuitive way  Like  for this simple script    use strict    var foo   1  var bar   2   function myFunc         -- Define local-to-function variables   var a   1    var b   2    var foo   3       -- And then  call it  myFunc      When executing the top-level code  we have the following arrangement of scope objects     And when myFunc   is called  we have the following scope chain     Understanding of how scope objects are created  used and deleted is a key to having a big picture and to understand how do closures work under the hood   See the aforementioned article for all the details

User · Answer

Closure can be private and public variables or functions   var ClusureDemo   function           privare variables     var localVa1  localVa2         private functions     var setVaOne   function newVa            localVa1   newVa             setVaTwo   function newVa            localVa2   newVa             getVaOne   function             return localVa1             getVaTwo   function             return localVa2              return             public variables and functions         outVaOne   localVa1          outVaTwo   localVa2          setVaOne   setVaOne          setVaTwo   setVaTwo          getVaOne   getVaOne          getVaTwo   getVaTwo              Test Demo var app   new ClusureDemo    app outVaOne    Hello Variable One   app outVaTwo    Hello Variable Two   app setVaOne app outVaOne   app setVaTwo app outVaTwo    alert app getVaOne     alert app getVaTwo       Demo

User · Answer

The simplest  shortest  most-easy-to-understand answer  A closure is a block of code where each line can reference the same set of variables with the same variable names  If  quot this quot  means something different than it does somewhere else  then you know it is two different closures

User · Answer

I m sure  Einstein didn t say it with a direct expectation for us to pick any esoteric brainstormer thing and run over six-year-olds with futile attempts to get those  crazy   and what is even worse for them-boring  things to their childish minds    If I were six years old I wouldn t like to have such parents or wouldn t make friendship with such boring philanthropists  sorry     Anyway  for babies  closure is simply a hug  I guess  whatever way you try to explain    And when you hug a friend of yours then you both kind of share anything you guys have at the moment  It s a rite of passage  once you ve hugged somebody you re showing her trust and willingness to let her do with you a lot of things you don t allow and would hide from others  It s an act of friendship      I really don t know how to explain it to 5-6 years old babies  I neither think they will appreciate any JavaScript code snippets like   function Baby        this iTrustYou   true     Baby prototype hug   function  baby        var smiles   0       if  baby iTrustYou            return function                 smiles                alert smiles                        var    arman   new Baby  Arman       morgan   new Baby  Morgana     var hug   arman hug morgan   hug    hug      For children only   Closure is hug  Bug is fly  KISS is smooch

User · Answer

Wikipedia on closures      In computer science  a closure is a function together with a referencing environment for the nonlocal names  free variables  of that function    Technically  in JavaScript  every function is a closure  It always has an access to variables defined in the surrounding scope   Since scope-defining construction in JavaScript is a function  not a code block like in many other languages  what we usually mean by closure in JavaScript is a function working with nonlocal variables defined in already executed surrounding function   Closures are often used for creating functions with some hidden private data  but it s not always the case    var db    function            Create a hidden object  which will hold the data        it s inaccessible from the outside      var data               Make a function  which will provide some access to the data      return function key  val            if  val     undefined    return data key       Get         else   return data key    val      Set              We are calling the anonymous surrounding function         returning the above inner function  which is a closure         db  x         - gt  undefined db  x   1     Set x to 1 db  x         - gt  1    It s impossible to access the data object itself     We are able to get or set individual it    ems  The example above is using an anonymous function  which was executed once  But it does not have to be  It can be named  e g  mkdb  and executed later  generating a database function each time it is invoked  Every generated function will have its own hidden database object  Another usage example of closures is when we don t return a function  but an object containing multiple functions for different purposes  each of those function having access to the same data

User · Answer

Here is a simple real-time scenario  Just read it through  and you will understand how we have used closure here  see how seat number is changing    All other examples explained previously are also very good to understand the concept   function movieBooking movieName        var bookedSeatCount   0      return function name              bookedSeatCount           alert  name     -     movieName      Seat -     bookedSeatCount              var MI1   movieBooking  Mission Impossible 1     var MI2   movieBooking  Mission Impossible 2      MI1  Mayur       alert    Mayur - Mission Impossible 1  Seat - 1  MI1  Raju       alert    Raju - Mission Impossible 1  Seat - 2  MI2  Priyanka       alert    Raja - Mission Impossible 2  Seat - 1

User · Answer

The Straw Man I need to know how many times a button has been clicked and do something on every third click    Fairly Obvious Solution  x000D   x000D     Declare counter outside event handler s scope var counter   0  var element   document getElementById  button     element addEventListener  click   function          Increment outside counter   counter       if  counter     3           Do something every third time     console log  Third time s the charm             Reset counter     counter   0          x000D   lt button id  button  gt Click Me  lt  button gt  x000D   x000D   x000D   Now this will work  but it does encroach into the outer scope by adding a variable  whose sole purpose is to keep track of the count  In some situations  this would be preferable as your outer application might need access to this information  But in this case  we are only changing every third click s behavior  so it is preferable to enclose this functionality inside the event handler  Consider this option  x000D   x000D  var element   document getElementById  button     element addEventListener  click    function          init the count to 0   var count   0     return function e        lt - This function becomes the click handler     count          and will retain access to the above  count       if  count     3             Do something every third time       console log  Third time s the charm              Reset counter       count   0                    x000D   lt button id  button  gt Click Me  lt  button gt  x000D   x000D   x000D   Notice a few things here  In the above example  I am using the closure behavior of JavaScript  This behavior allows any function to have access to the scope in which it was created  indefinitely  To practically apply this  I immediately invoke a function that returns another function  and because the function I m returning has access to the internal count variable  because of the closure behavior explained above  this results in a private scope for usage by the resulting function    Not so simple  Let s dilute it down    A simple one-line closure                                    Immediately invoked                                                                                                                         Scope retained for use         Returned as the                               only by returned function        value of func                                                                                                      v             v            v        v                      v     v var func    function     var a    val   return function     alert a             All variables outside the returned function are available to the returned function  but they are not directly available to the returned function object    func        Alerts  quot val quot  func a      Undefined  Get it  So in our primary example  the count variable is contained within the closure and always available to the event handler  so it retains its state from click to click  Also  this private variable state is fully accessible  for both readings and assigning to its private scoped variables  There you go  you re now fully encapsulating this behavior  Full Blog Post  including jQuery considerations

User · Answer

A closure is basically creating two things   - a function - a private scope that only that function can access  It is like putting some coating around a function   So to a 6-years-old  it could be explained by giving an analogy  Let s say I build a robot  That robot can do many things  Among those things  I programmed it to count the number of birds he sees in the sky  Each time he has seen 25 birds  he should tell me how many birds he has seen since the beginning   I don t know how many birds he has seen unless he has told me  Only he knows  That s the private scope  That s basically the robot s memory  Let s say I gave him 4 nbsp GB   Telling me how many birds he has seen is the returned function  I also created that   That analogy is a bit sucky  but someone could improve it I guess

User · Answer

I believe in shorter explanations  so see the below image     function f1        Light Red Box  function f2        Red Small Box  Here we have two functions  f1   and f2    f2   is inner to f1    f1   has a variable  var x   10   When invoking the function f1    f2   can access the value of var x   10   Here is the code   function f1         var x 10       function f2             console log x             return f2    f1     f1   invoking here

User · Answer

I tend to learn better by GOOD BAD comparisons  I like to see working code followed by non-working code that someone is likely to encounter  I put together a jsFiddle that does a comparison and tries to boil down the differences to the simplest explanations I could come up with  Closures done right  console log  CLOSURES DONE RIGHT     var arr        function createClosure n        return function              return  n       n           for  var index   0  index  lt  10  index          arr index    createClosure index      for  var index in arr        console log arr index          In the above code createClosure n  is invoked in every iteration of the loop  Note that I named the variable n to highlight that it is a new variable created in a new function scope and is not the same variable as index which is bound to the outer scope   This creates a new scope and n is bound to that scope  this means we have 10 separate scopes  one for each iteration   createClosure n  returns a function that returns the n within that scope   Within each scope n is bound to whatever value it had when createClosure n  was invoked so the nested function that gets returned will always return the value of n that it had when createClosure n  was invoked    Closures done wrong  console log  CLOSURES DONE WRONG     function createClosureArray         var badArr            for  var index   0  index  lt  10  index              badArr index    function                  return  n       index                       return badArr     var badArr   createClosureArray     for  var index in badArr        console log badArr index          In the above code the loop was moved within the createClosureArray   function and the function now just returns the completed array  which at first glance seems more intuitive   What might not be obvious is that since createClosureArray   is only invoked once only one scope is created for this function instead of one for every iteration of the loop   Within this function a variable named index is defined  The loop runs and adds functions to the array that return index  Note that index is defined within the createClosureArray function which only ever gets invoked one time   Because there was only one scope within the createClosureArray   function  index is only bound to a value within that scope  In other words  each time the loop changes the value of index  it changes it for everything that references it within that scope   All of the functions added to the array return the SAME index variable from the parent scope where it was defined instead of 10 different ones from 10 different scopes like the first example  The end result is that all 10 functions return the same variable from the same scope   After the loop finished and index was done being modified the end value was 10  therefore every function added to the array returns the value of the single index variable which is now set to 10    Result  CLOSURES DONE RIGHT n   0 n   1 n   2 n   3 n   4 n   5 n   6 n   7 n   8 n   9 CLOSURES DONE WRONG n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10 n   10

User · Answer

A closure is a function within a function that has access to its  parent  function s variables and parameters   Example   function showPostCard Sender  Receiver         var PostCardMessage     Happy Spring    Love          function PreparePostCard             return  Dear     Receiver   PostCardMessage   Sender             return PreparePostCard      showPostCard  Granny    Olivia

User · Answer

The easiest use case I can think of to explain JavaScript closures is the Module Pattern  In the Module Pattern you define a function and call it immediately afterwards in what is called an Immediately Invoked Function Expression  IIFE   Everything that you write inside that function has private scope because it s defined inside the closure  thus allowing you to  simulate  privacy in JavaScript  Like so    var Closure    function             This is a closure        Any methods  variables and properties you define here are  private         and can t be accessed from outside the function         This is a private variable     var foo              This is a private method     var method   function                   If  on the other hand  you d like to make one or multiple variables or methods visible outside  the closure  you can return them inside an object literal  Like so   var Closure    function           This is a closure      Any methods  variables and properties you define here are  private       and can t be accessed from outside the function       This is a private variable   var foo            This is a private method   var method   function              The method will be accessible from outside the closure   return       method  method             Closure method      Hope it helps  Regards

User · Answer

I do not understand why the answers are so complex here  Here is a closure  var a   42   function b     return a     Yes  You probably use that many times a day    There is no reason to believe closures are a complex design hack to address specific problems  No  closures are just about using a variable that comes from a higher scope from the perspective of where the function was declared  not run   Now what it allows you to do can be more spectacular  see other answers

User · Answer

OK  6-year-old closures fan  Do you want to hear the simplest example of closure   Let s imagine the next situation  a driver is sitting in a car  That car is inside a plane  Plane is in the airport  The ability of driver to access things outside his car  but inside the plane  even if that plane leaves an airport  is a closure  That s it  When you turn 27  look at the more detailed explanation or at the example below   Here is how I can convert my plane story into the code    x000D   x000D  var plane   function defaultAirport    x000D   x000D    var lastAirportLeft   defaultAirport  x000D   x000D    var car     x000D      driver    x000D        startAccessPlaneInfo  function     x000D          setInterval function     x000D            console log  Last airport was     lastAirportLeft   x000D             2000   x000D          x000D        x000D       x000D    car driver startAccessPlaneInfo    x000D   x000D    return   x000D      leaveTheAirport  function airPortName    x000D        lastAirportLeft   airPortName  x000D        x000D      x000D     Boryspil International Airport    x000D   x000D  plane leaveTheAirport  John F  Kennedy    x000D   x000D   x000D

User · Answer

My perspective of Closures   Closures can be compared to a book  with a bookmark  on a bookshelf   Suppose you have read a book  and you like some page in the book   You put in a bookmark at that page to track it   Now once you finish reading the book  you do not need the book anymore  except  you want to have access to that page   You could have just cut out the page  but then you would loose the context on the story   So you put the book back in your bookshelf with the bookmark   This is similar to a closure   The book is the outer function  and the page is your inner function  which gets returned  from the outer function   The bookmark is the reference to your page  and the context of the story is the lexical scope  which you need to retain   The bookshelf is the function stack  which cannot be cleaned up of the old books  till you hold onto the page   Code Example   function book        var pages             array of pages in your book    var bookMarkedPage   20    bookmarked page number    function getPage           return pages bookMarkedPage           return getPage     var myBook   book        myPage   myBook getPage      When you run the book   function  you are allocating memory in the stack for the function to run in   But since it returns a function  the memory cannot be released  as the inner function has access to the variables from the context outside it  in this case  pages  and  bookMarkedPage    So effectively calling book   returns a reference to a closure  i e not only a function  but a reference to the book and it s context  i e  a reference to the function getPage  state of pages and bookMarkedPage variables   Some points to consider   Point 1  The bookshelf  just like the function stack has limited space  so use it wisely   Point 2  Think about the fact  whether you need to hold onto the entire book when you just want to track a single page   You can release part of the memory  by not storing all the pages in the book when the closure is returned   This is my perspective of Closures   Hope it helps  and if anyone thinks that this is not correct  please do let me know  as I am very interested to understand even more about scopes and closures

User · Answer

I d simply point them to the Mozilla Closures page  It s the best  most concise and simple explanation of closure basics and practical usage that I ve found  It is highly recommended to anyone learning JavaScript   And yes  I d even recommend it to a 6-year old -- if the 6-year old is learning about closures  then it s logical they re ready to comprehend the concise and simple explanation provided in the article

User · Answer

The children will always remember the secrets they have shared with their parents  even after their parents are   gone  This is what closures are for functions    The secrets for JavaScript functions are the private variables  var parent   function      var name    Mary      secret     Every time you call it  local variable  name  is created and given name  Mary   And every time the function exits the variable is lost and the name is forgotten   As you may guess  because the variables are re-created every time the function is called  and nobody else will know them  there must be a secret place where they are stored  It could be called Chamber of Secrets or stack or local scope but it doesn t really matter  We know they are there  somewhere  hidden in the memory   But  in JavaScript there is this very special thing that functions which are created inside other functions  can also know the local variables of their parents and keep them as long as they live   var parent   function       var name    Mary     var child   function childName           I can also see that  name  is  Mary          So  as long as we are in the parent -function  it can create one or more child functions which do share the secret variables from the secret place   But the sad thing is  if the child is also a private variable of its parent function  it would also die when the parent ends  and the secrets would die with them   So to live  the child has to leave before it s too late  var parent   function       var name    Mary     var child   function childName        return  My name is     childName      child of     name         return child     child leaves the parent - gt    var child   parent        lt  - and here it is outside    And now  even though Mary is  no longer running   the memory of her is not lost and her child will always remember her name and other secrets they shared during their time together   So  if you call the child  Alice   she will respond  child  Alice     gt   My name is Alice  child of Mary    That s all there is to tell

User · Answer

I put together an interactive JavaScript tutorial to explain how closures work  What s a Closure   Here s one of the examples   var create   function  x        var f   function              return x     We can refer to x here             return f         create  takes one argument  creates a function  var g   create 42      g is a function that takes no arguments now  var y   g       y is 42 here

User · Answer

A function in JavaScript is not just a reference to a set of instructions  as in C language   but it also includes a hidden data structure which is composed of references to all nonlocal variables it uses  captured variables   Such two-piece functions are called closures  Every function in JavaScript can be considered a closure   Closures are functions with a state  It is somewhat similar to  this  in the sense that  this  also provides state for a function but function and  this  are separate objects   this  is just a fancy parameter  and the only way to bind it permanently to a function is to create a closure   While  this  and function always live separately  a function cannot be separated from its closure and the language provides no means to access captured variables   Because all these external variables referenced by a lexically nested function are actually local variables in the chain of its lexically enclosing functions  global variables can be assumed to be local variables of some root function   and every single execution of a function creates new instances of its local variables  it follows that every execution of a function returning  or otherwise transferring it out  such as registering it as a callback  a nested function creates a new closure  with its own potentially unique set of referenced nonlocal variables which represent its execution context    Also  it must be understood that local variables in JavaScript are created not on the stack frame  but on the heap and destroyed only when no one is referencing them  When a function returns  references to its local variables are decremented  but they can still be non-null if during the current execution they became part of a closure and are still referenced by its lexically nested functions  which can happen only if the references to these nested functions were returned or otherwise transferred to some external code    An example   function foo  initValue         This variable is not destroyed when the foo function exits       It is  captured  by the two nested functions returned below     var value   initValue        Note that the two returned functions are created right now       If the foo function is called again  it will return      new functions referencing a different  value  variable     return          getValue  function      return value            setValue  function  newValue    value   newValue            function bar            foo sets its local variable  value  to 5 and returns an object with       two functions still referencing that local variable     var obj   foo 5          Extracting functions just to show that no  this  is involved here     var getValue   obj getValue      var setValue   obj setValue       alert getValue       Displays 5     setValue 10       alert getValue       Displays 10        At this point getValue and setValue functions are destroyed        in reality they are destroyed at the next iteration of the garbage collector         The local variable  value  in the foo is no longer referenced by       anything and is destroyed too     bar

User · Answer

Every function in JavaScript maintains a link to its outer lexical environment  A lexical environment is a map of all the names  eg  variables  parameters  within a scope  with their values   So  whenever you see the function keyword  code inside that function has access to variables declared outside the function    x000D   x000D  function foo x    x000D    var tmp   3  x000D   x000D    function bar y    x000D      console log x   y      tmp       will log 16 x000D      x000D   x000D    bar 10   x000D    x000D   x000D  foo 2   x000D   x000D   x000D    This will log 16 because function bar closes over the parameter x and the variable tmp  both of which exist in the lexical environment of outer function foo   Function bar  together with its link with the lexical environment of function foo is a closure    A function doesn t have to return in order to create a closure  Simply by virtue of its declaration  every function closes over its enclosing lexical environment  forming a closure    x000D   x000D  function foo x    x000D    var tmp   3  x000D   x000D    return function  y    x000D      console log x   y      tmp       will also log 16 x000D      x000D    x000D   x000D  var bar   foo 2   x000D  bar 10      16 x000D  bar 10      17 x000D   x000D   x000D    The above function will also log 16  because the code inside bar can still refer to argument x and variable tmp  even though they are no longer directly in scope   However  since tmp is still hanging around inside bar s closure  it is available to be incremented  It will be incremented each time you call bar   The simplest example of a closure is this    x000D   x000D  var a   10  x000D   x000D  function test     x000D    console log a      will output 10 x000D    console log b      will output 6 x000D    x000D  var b   6  x000D  test    x000D   x000D   x000D    When a JavaScript function is invoked  a new execution context ec is created  Together with the function arguments and the target object  this execution context also receives a link to the lexical environment of the calling execution context  meaning the variables declared in the outer lexical environment  in the above example  both a and b  are available from ec   Every function creates a closure because every function has a link to its outer lexical environment    Note that variables themselves are visible from within a closure  not copies

User · Answer

Closures are a somewhat advanced  and often misunderstood feature of the JavaScript language  Simply put  closures are objects that contain a function and a reference to the environment in which the function was created  However  in order to fully understand closures  there are two other features of the JavaScript language that must first be understood-first-class functions and inner functions   First-Class Functions  In programming languages  functions are considered to be first-class citizens if they can be manipulated like any other data type  For example  first-class functions can be constructed at runtime and assigned to variables   They can also be passed to  and returned by other functions  In addition to meeting the previously mentioned criteria  JavaScript functions also have their own properties and methods  The following example shows some of the capabilities of first-class functions  In the example  two functions are created and assigned to the variables    foo    and    bar     The function stored in    foo    displays a dialog box  while    bar    simply returns whatever argument is passed to it  The last line of the example does several things  First  the function stored in    bar    is called with    foo    as its argument     bar    then returns the    foo    function reference  Finally  the returned    foo    reference is called  causing    Hello World     to be displayed   var foo   function       alert  Hello World         var bar   function arg      return arg      bar foo       Inner Functions  Inner functions  also referred to as nested functions  are functions that are defined inside of another function  referred to as the outer function   Each time the outer function is called  an instance of the inner function is created  The following example shows how inner functions are used  In this case  add   is the outer function  Inside of add    the doAdd   inner function is defined and called   function add value1  value2      function doAdd operand1  operand2        return operand1   operand2         return doAdd value1  value2      var foo   add 1  2      foo equals 3   One important characteristic of inner functions is that they have implicit access to the outer function   s scope  This means that the inner function can use the variables  arguments  etc  of the outer function  In the previous example  the    value1    and    value2    arguments of add   were passed to doAdd   as the    operand1    and    operand2    arguments  However  this is unnecessary because doAdd   has direct access to    value1    and    value2     The previous example has been rewritten below to show how doAdd   can use    value1    and    value2      function add value1  value2      function doAdd         return value1   value2         return doAdd       var foo   add 1  2      foo equals 3      Creating Closures      A closure is created when an inner function is made accessible from   outside of the function that created it  This typically occurs when an   outer function returns an inner function   When this happens  the   inner function maintains a reference to the environment in which it   was created   This means that it remembers all of the variables  and   their values  that were in scope at the time  The following example   shows how a closure is created and used    function add value1      return function doAdd value2        return value1   value2          var increment   add 1   var foo   increment 2      foo equals 3   There are a number of things to note about this example   The add   function returns its inner function doAdd    By returning a reference to an inner function  a closure is created     value1    is a local variable of add    and a non-local variable of doAdd    Non-local variables refer to variables that are neither in the local nor the global scope      value2    is a local variable of doAdd    When add 1  is called  a closure is created and stored in    increment     In the closure   s referencing environment     value1    is bound to the value one   Variables that are bound are also said to be closed over  This is where the name closure comes from  When increment 2  is called  the closure is entered  This means that doAdd   is called  with the    value1    variable holding the value one  The closure can essentially be thought of as creating the following function   function increment value2      return 1   value2         When to Use Closures      Closures can be used to accomplish many things  They are very useful   for things like configuring callback functions with parameters  This   section covers two scenarios where closures can make your life as a   developer much simpler    Working With Timers  Closures are useful when used in conjunction with the setTimeout   and setInterval   functions  To be more specific  closures allow you to pass arguments to the callback functions of setTimeout   and setInterval    For example  the following code prints the string    some message    once per second by calling showMessage      lt  DOCTYPE html gt   lt html lang  en  gt   lt head gt     lt title gt Closures lt  title gt     lt meta charset  UTF-8    gt     lt script gt      window addEventListener  load   function           window setInterval showMessage  1000   some message lt br   gt                  function showMessage message          document getElementById  message   innerHTML    message           lt  script gt   lt  head gt   lt body gt     lt span id  message  gt  lt  span gt   lt  body gt   lt  html gt    Unfortunately  Internet Explorer does not support passing callback arguments via setInterval    Instead of displaying    some message     Internet Explorer displays    undefined     since no value is actually passed to showMessage     To work around this issue  a closure can be created which binds the    message    argument to the desired value  The closure can then be used as the callback function for setInterval    To illustrate this concept  the JavaScript code from the previous example has been rewritten below to use a closure   window addEventListener  load   function       var showMessage   getClosure  some message lt br   gt        window setInterval showMessage  1000        function getClosure message      function showMessage         document getElementById  message   innerHTML    message         return showMessage      Emulating Private Data  Many object-oriented languages support the concept of private member data  However  JavaScript is not a pure object-oriented language and does not support private data  But  it is possible to emulate private data using closures  Recall that a closure contains a reference to the environment in which it was originally created-which is now out of scope  Since the variables in the referencing environment are only accessible from the closure function  they are essentially private data   The following example shows a constructor for a simple Person class  When each Person is created  it is given a name via the    name    argument   Internally  the Person stores its name in the     name    variable  Following good object-oriented programming practices  the method getName   is also provided for retrieving the name   function Person name      this  name   name     this getName   function         return this  name           There is still one major problem with the Person class  Because JavaScript does not support private data  there is nothing stopping somebody else from coming along and changing the name  For example  the following code creates a Person named Colin  and then changes its name to Tom   var person   new Person  Colin     person  name    Tom      person getName   now returns  Tom    Personally  I wouldn   t like it if just anyone could come along and legally change my name  In order to stop this from happening  a closure can be used to make the     name    variable private  The Person constructor has been rewritten below using a closure  Note that     name    is now a local variable of the Person constructor instead of an object property  A closure is formed because the outer function  Person   exposes an inner function by creating the public getName   method   function Person name      var  name   name     this getName   function         return  name           Now  when getName   is called  it is guaranteed to return the value that was originally passed to the constructor  It is still possible for someone to add a new     name    property to the object  but the internal workings of the object will not be affected as long as they refer to the variable bound by the closure   The following code shows that the     name    variable is  indeed  private   var person   new Person  Colin     person  name    Tom      person  name is  Tom  but person getName   returns  Colin       When Not to Use Closures      It is important to understand how closures work and when to use them    It is equally important to understand when they are not the right tool   for the job at hand  Overusing closures can cause scripts to execute   slowly and consume unnecessary memory  And because closures are so   simple to create  it is possible to misuse them without even knowing   it   This section covers several scenarios where closures should be   used with caution    In Loops  Creating closures within loops can have misleading results  An example of this is shown below  In this example  three buttons are created  When    button1    is clicked  an alert should be displayed that says    Clicked button 1      Similar messages should be shown for    button2    and    button3      However  when this code is run  all of the buttons show    Clicked button 4     This is because  by the time one of the buttons is clicked  the loop has finished executing  and the loop variable has reached its final value of four    lt  DOCTYPE html gt   lt html lang  en  gt   lt head gt     lt title gt Closures lt  title gt     lt meta charset  UTF-8    gt     lt script gt      window addEventListener  load   function           for  var i   1  i  lt  4  i              var button   document getElementById  button    i            button addEventListener  click   function               alert  Clicked button     i                                  lt  script gt   lt  head gt   lt body gt     lt input type  button  id  button1  value  One    gt     lt input type  button  id  button2  value  Two    gt     lt input type  button  id  button3  value  Three    gt   lt  body gt   lt  html gt    To solve this problem  the closure must be decoupled from the actual loop variable  This can be done by calling a new function  which in turn creates a new referencing environment  The following example shows how this is done  The loop variable is passed to the getHandler   function  getHandler   then returns a closure that is independent of the original    for    loop   function getHandler i      return function handler         alert  Clicked button     i          window addEventListener  load   function       for  var i   1  i  lt  4  i          var button   document getElementById  button    i       button addEventListener  click   getHandler i                 Unnecessary Use in Constructors      Constructor functions are another common source of closure misuse    We   ve seen how closures can be used to emulate private data  However    it is overkill to implement methods as closures if they don   t actually   access the private data  The following example revisits the Person   class  but this time adds a sayHello   method which doesn   t use the   private data    function Person name      var  name   name     this getName   function         return  name          this sayHello   function         alert  Hello                 Each time a Person is instantiated  time is spent creating the   sayHello   method  If many Person objects are created  this becomes a   waste of time   A better approach would be to add sayHello   to the   Person prototype  By adding to the prototype  all Person objects can   share the same method   This saves time in the constructor by not   having to create a closure for each instance  The previous example is   rewritten below with the extraneous closure moved into the prototype    function Person name      var  name   name     this getName   function         return  name          Person prototype sayHello   function       alert  Hello          Things to Remember   Closures contain a function and a reference to the environment in which the function was created  A closure is formed when an outer function exposes an inner function  Closures can be used to easily pass parameters to callback functions  Private data can be emulated by using closures   This is common in object-oriented programming and namespace design  Closures should be not overused in constructors   Adding to the prototype is a better idea    Link

User · Answer

Functions containing no free variables are called pure functions  Functions containing one or more free variables are called closures  var pure   function pure x     return x       only own environment is used    var foo    quot bar quot   var closure   function closure      return foo      foo is free variable from the outer environment    src  https   leanpub com javascriptallongesix read leanpub-auto-if-functions-without-free-variables-are-pure-are-closures-impure

User · Answer

Let s start from here  As defined on MDN  Closures are functions that refer to independent  free  variables  variables that are used locally  but defined in an enclosing scope   In other words  these functions  remember  the environment in which they were created   Lexical scoping Consider the following   function init       var name    Mozilla      name is a local variable created by init   function displayName        displayName   is the inner function  a closure     alert name      use variable declared in the parent function           displayName          init      init   creates a local variable called name and a function called displayName    The displayName   function is an inner function that is defined inside init   and is only available within the body of the  init   function  The displayName   function has no local variables of its own  However  because inner functions have access to the variables of outer functions  displayName   can access the variable name declared in the parent function  init     function init         var name    Mozilla      name is a local variable created by init     function displayName        displayName   is the inner function  a closure         alert  name      displayName   uses variable declared in the parent function               displayName          init      Run the code and notice that the alert   statement within the displayName   function successfully displays the value of the name variable  which is declared in its parent function  This is an example of lexical scoping  which describes how a parser resolves variable names when functions are nested  The word  lexical  refers to the fact that lexical scoping uses the location where a variable is declared within the source code to determine where that variable is available  Nested functions have access to variables declared in their outer scope   Closure Now consider the following example   function makeFunc       var name    Mozilla     function displayName         alert name         return displayName     var myFunc   makeFunc    myFunc      Running this code has exactly the same effect as the previous example of the init   function above  this time  the string  Mozilla  will be displayed in a JavaScript alert box  What s different     and interesting     is that the displayName   inner function is returned from the outer function before being executed   At first glance  it may seem unintuitive that this code still works  In some programming languages  the local variables within a function exist only for the duration of that function s execution  Once makeFunc   has finished executing  you might expect that the name variable would no longer be accessible  However  because the code still works as expected  this is obviously not the case in JavaScript   The reason is that functions in JavaScript form closures  A closure is the combination of a function and the lexical environment within which that function was declared  This environment consists of any local variables that were in-scope at the time that the closure was created  In this case  myFunc is a reference to the instance of the function displayName created when makeFunc is run  The instance of displayName maintains a reference to its lexical environment  within which the variable name exists  For this reason  when myFunc is invoked  the variable name remains available for use and  Mozilla  is passed to alert   Here s a slightly more interesting example     a makeAdder function   function makeAdder x      return function y        return x   y          var add5   makeAdder 5   var add10   makeAdder 10    console log add5 2        7 console log add10 2       12   In this example  we have defined a function makeAdder x   which takes a single argument  x  and returns a new function  The function it returns takes a single argument  y  and returns the sum of x and y   In essence  makeAdder is a function factory     it creates functions which can add a specific value to their argument  In the above example we use our function factory to create two new functions     one that adds 5 to its argument  and one that adds 10   add5 and add10 are both closures  They share the same function body definition  but store different lexical environments  In add5 s lexical environment  x is 5  while in the lexical environment for add10  x is 10   Practical closures  Closures are useful because they let you associate some data  the lexical environment  with a function that operates on that data  This has obvious parallels to object oriented programming  where objects allow us to associate some data  the object s properties  with one or more methods   Consequently  you can use a closure anywhere that you might normally use an object with only a single method   Situations where you might want to do this are particularly common on the web  Much of the code we write in front-end JavaScript is event-based     we define some behavior  then attach it to an event that is triggered by the user  such as a click or a keypress   Our code is generally attached as a callback  a single function which is executed in response to the event   For instance  suppose we wish to add some buttons to a page that adjust the text size  One way of doing this is to specify the font-size of the body element in pixels  then set the size of the other elements on the page  such as headers  using the relative em unit   body     font-family  Helvetica  Arial  sans-serif    font-size  12px     h1     font-size  1 5em     h2     font-size  1 2em      Our interactive text size buttons can change the font-size property of the body element  and the adjustments will be picked up by other elements on the page thanks to the relative units  Here s the JavaScript   function makeSizer size      return function         document body style fontSize   size    px           var size12   makeSizer 12   var size14   makeSizer 14   var size16   makeSizer 16     size12  size14  and size16 are now functions which will resize the body text to 12  14  and 16 pixels  respectively  We can attach them to buttons  in this case links  as follows   document getElementById  size-12   onclick   size12  document getElementById  size-14   onclick   size14  document getElementById  size-16   onclick   size16    lt a href     id  size-12  gt 12 lt  a gt   lt a href     id  size-14  gt 14 lt  a gt   lt a href     id  size-16  gt 16 lt  a gt    function makeSizer size      return function         document body style fontSize   size    px           var size12   makeSizer 12   var size14   makeSizer 14   var size16   makeSizer 16    document getElementById  size-12   onclick   size12  document getElementById  size-14   onclick   size14  document getElementById  size-16   onclick   size16    for reading more about closures  visit the link on MDN

User · Answer

Imagine there is a very large park in your town where you see a magician called Mr  Coder starting baseball games in different corners of the park using his magic wand  called JavaScript   Naturally each baseball game has the exact same rules and each game has its own score board   Naturally  the scores of one baseball game are completely separate from the other games   A closure is the special way Mr Coder keeps the scoring of all his magical baseball games separate

User · Answer

There once was a caveman   function caveman     who had a very special rock   var rock    diamond     You could not get the rock yourself because it was in the caveman s private cave  Only the caveman knew how to find and get the rock   return       getRock  function             return rock               Luckily  he was a friendly caveman  and if you were willing to wait for his return  he would gladly get it for you   var friend   caveman    var rock   friend getRock      Pretty smart caveman

User · Answer

From a personal blog post   By default  JavaScript knows two types of scopes  global and local   var a   1   function b x        var c   2      return x   c      In the above code  variable a and function b are available from anywhere in the code  that is  globally   Variable c is only available within the b function scope  that is  local   Most software developers won t be happy with this lack of scope flexibility  especially in large programs   JavaScript closures help solving that issue by tying a function with a context   function a x        return function b y            return x   y            Here  function a returns a function called b  Since b is defined within a  it automatically has access to whatever is defined in a  that is  x in this example  This is why b can return x   y without declaring x   var c   a 3     Variable c is assigned the result of a call to a with parameter 3  That is  an instance of function b where x   3  In other words  c is now a function equivalent to   var c   function b y        return 3   y      Function b remembers that x   3 in its context  Therefore   var d   c 4     will assign the value 3   4 to d  that is 7   Remark  If someone modifies the value of x  say x   22  after the instance of function b has been created  this will be reflected in b too  Hence a later call to c 4  would return 22   4  that is 26   Closures can also be used to limit the scope of variables and methods declared globally    function          var f    Some message       alert f           The above is a closure where the function has no name  no argument and is called immediately  The highlighted code  which declares a global variable f  limits the scopes of f to the closure   Now  there is a common JavaScript caveat where closures can help   var a   new Array     for  var i 0  i lt 2  i          a i   function x    return x   i         From the above  most would assume that array a would be initialized as follows   a 0    function  x    return x   0     a 1    function  x    return x   1     a 2    function  x    return x   2       In reality  this is how a is initialized  since the last value of i in the context is 2   a 0    function  x    return x   2     a 1    function  x    return x   2     a 2    function  x    return x   2       The solution is   var a   new Array     for  var i 0  i lt 2  i          a i   function tmp            return function  x    return x   tmp            i       The argument variable tmp holds a local copy of the changing value of i when creating function instances

User · Answer

I have read all of these before in the past  and they are all very informative  Some come very close to getting the simple explanation and then get complex or remain abstract  defeating the purpose and failing to show a very simple real world use    Though combing through all the examples and explanations you get a good idea of what closures are and aren t via comments and code  I was still unsatisfied with a very simple illustration that helped me get a closures usefulness without getting so complex  My wife wants to learn coding and I figured I needed to be able to show here not only what  but why  and and how   I am not sure a six year old will get this  but I think it might be a little closer to demonstrating a simple case in a real world way that might acually be useful and that is easily understandable   One of the best  or closest to simplest  is the retelling of Morris  Closures for Dummies example   Taking the  SayHi2Bob  concept just one step further demonstrates the two basic things you can glean from reading all the answers    Closures have access to the containing function s variables  Closures persist in their own memory space  and thus are useful for all kinds of oop-y instantiation stuff    Proving and demonstrating this to myself  I made a little fiddle   http   jsfiddle net 9ZMyr 2   function sayHello name      var text    Hello     name     Local variable   console log text     var sayAlert   function            alert text         return sayAlert     sayHello        This will write  Hello undefined  to the console  in Chrome anyway    but will not alert though since it returns a function handle to nothing    Since no handle or reference is created  I imagine a good js engine would  destroy dispose of the internal sayAlert function once it completes         Create a handle reference instance of sayHello   using the name  Bob  sayHelloBob   sayHello  Bob    sayHelloBob        Create another handle or reference to sayHello with a different name sayHelloGerry   sayHello  Gerry    sayHelloGerry        Now calling them again demonstrates that each handle or reference contains its own  unique local variable memory space  They remain in memory  forever    or until your computer browser explode     sayHelloBob    sayHelloGerry      This demonstrates both of the basic concepts you should get about closures    In simple terms to explain the why this is useful  I have a base function to which I can make references or handles that contain unique data which persists within that memory reference  I don t have to rewrite the function for each time I want to say someone s name  I have encapsulated that routine and made it reusable   To me this leads to at least the basic concepts of constructors  oop practices  singletons vs instantiated instances with their own data  etc  etc   If you start a neophyte with this  then you can move on to more complex object property member based calls  and hopefully the concepts carry

User · Answer

JavaScript functions can access their    Arguments Locals  that is  their local variables and local functions  Environment  which includes    globals  including the DOM anything in outer functions    If a function accesses its environment  then the function is a closure   Note that outer functions are not required  though they do offer benefits I don t discuss here  By accessing data in its environment  a closure keeps that data alive  In the subcase of outer inner functions  an outer function can create local data and eventually exit  and yet  if any inner function s  survive after the outer function exits  then the inner function s  keep the outer function s local data alive   Example of a closure that uses the global environment   Imagine that the Stack Overflow Vote-Up and Vote-Down button events are implemented as closures  voteUp click and voteDown click  that have access to external variables isVotedUp and isVotedDown  which are defined globally   For simplicity s sake  I am referring to StackOverflow s Question Vote buttons  not the array of Answer Vote buttons    When the user clicks the VoteUp button  the voteUp click function checks whether isVotedDown    true to determine whether to vote up or merely cancel a down vote  Function voteUp click is a closure because it is accessing its environment   var isVotedUp   false  var isVotedDown   false   function voteUp click       if  isVotedUp      return    else if  isVotedDown      SetDownVote false     else     SetUpVote true      function voteDown click       if  isVotedDown      return    else if  isVotedUp      SetUpVote false     else     SetDownVote true      function SetUpVote status      isVotedUp   status       Do some CSS stuff to Vote-Up button    function SetDownVote status      isVotedDown   status       Do some CSS stuff to Vote-Down button     All four of these functions are closures as they all access their environment

User · Answer

Considering the question is about explaining it simply as if to a 6-year-old  my answer would be    When you declare a function in JavaScript it has forever access to all the variables and functions that were available in the line before that function declaration  The function and all the outer variables and functions that it has access to is what we call a closure

User · Answer

This answer is a summary of this youtube video Javascript Closures  So full credits to that video   Closures are nothing but Stateful functions which maintain states of their private variables    Normally when you make a call to a function as shown in the below figure  The variables are created on a stack   running RAM memory  used and then disallocated     But now there are situations where we want to maintain this state of the function thats where Javascript closures comes to use  A closure is a function inside function with a return call as shown in the below code     So the closure code for the counter function above looks something as shown below Its a function inside function with a return statement   function Counter                var counter   0              var Increment   function                     counter                   alert counter                           return                  Increment                         So now if you make a call the counter will increment in other words the function call maintains states   var x   Counter       get the reference of the closure x Increment       Displays 1 x Increment       Display 2   Maintains the private variables    But now the biggest question whats the use of such stateful function  Stateful functions are building blocks to implement OOP concept like abstraction  encapsulation and creating self contained modules   So whatever you want encapsulated you can put it as private and things to be exposed to public should be put in return statement  Also these components are self contained isolated objects so they do not pollute global variables   A object which follows OOP principles is self contained   follows abstraction   follows encapsulation and so  With out closures in Javascript this is difficult to implement

User · Answer

TLDR  A closure is a link between a function and its outer lexical  ie  as-written  environment  such that the identifiers  variables  parameters  function declarations etc  defined within that environment are visible from within the function  regardless of when or from where the function is invoked   Details  In the terminology of the ECMAScript specification  a closure can be said to be implemented by the   Environment   reference of every function-object  which points to the lexical environment within which the function is defined   When a function is invoked via the internal   Call   method  the   Environment   reference on the function-object is copied into the outer environment reference of the environment record of the newly-created execution context  stack frame    In the following example  function f closes over the lexical environment of the global execution context   function f        In the following example  function h closes over the lexical environment of function g  which  in turn  closes over the lexical environment of the global execution context   function g         function h          If an inner function is returned by an outer  then the outer lexical environment will persist after the outer function has returned  This is because the outer lexical environment needs to be available if the inner function is eventually invoked   In the following example  function j closes over the lexical environment of function i  meaning that variable x is visible from inside function j  long after function i has completed execution    x000D   x000D  function i     x000D      var x    mochacchino  x000D      return function j     x000D          console log  Printing the value of x  from within function j     x  x000D        x000D     x000D   x000D  const k   i   x000D  setTimeout k  500     invoke k  which is j  after 500ms x000D   x000D   x000D    In a closure  the variables in the outer lexical environment themselves are available  not copies    x000D   x000D  function l     x000D    var y    vanilla   x000D   x000D    return   x000D      setY  function value    x000D        y   value  x000D         x000D      logY  function value    x000D        console log  The value of y is     y   x000D        x000D      x000D    x000D   x000D  const o   l   x000D  o logY      The value of y is  vanilla x000D  o setY  chocolate   x000D  o logY      The value of y is  chocolate x000D   x000D   x000D    The chain of lexical environments  linked between execution contexts via outer environment references  forms a scope chain and defines the identifiers visible from any given function   Please note that in an attempt to improve clarity and accuracy  this answer has been substantially changed from the original

[javascript] How do JavaScript closures work?

Examples related to javascript

Examples related to function

Examples related to variables

Examples related to scope

Examples related to closures