Expanding on Adam Rackis's answer - we can make the extension method generic simply like this:
public static TResult GetPropertyValue<TResult>(this object t, string propertyName)
{
object val = t.GetType().GetProperties().Single(pi => pi.Name == propertyName).GetValue(t, null);
return (TResult)val;
}
You can throw some error handling around that too if you like.