[xml] Can we import XML file into another XML file?

Can we import an XML file into another XML file?

I mean is there any import tag in XML that takes XML path as parameter and imports XML (for which path is provided).

This question is related to xml file import merge

The answer is


Mads Hansen's solution is good but to succeed in reading the external file in .NET 4 took some time to figure out using hints in the comments about resolvers, ProhibitDTD and so on.

This is how it's done:

        XmlReaderSettings settings = new XmlReaderSettings();
        settings.DtdProcessing = DtdProcessing.Parse;
        XmlUrlResolver resolver = new XmlUrlResolver();
        resolver.Credentials = System.Net.CredentialCache.DefaultCredentials;
        settings.XmlResolver = resolver;
        var reader = XmlReader.Create("logfile.xml", settings);
        XmlDocument doc = new XmlDocument();
        doc.Load(reader);
        foreach (XmlElement element in doc.SelectNodes("//event"))
        {
            var ch = element.ChildNodes;
            var count = ch.Count;
        }

logfile.xml:

<?xml version="1.0"?>
<!DOCTYPE logfile [
<!ENTITY events    
 SYSTEM "events.txt">
]>
<logfile>
&events;
</logfile>

events.txt:

<event>
    <item1>item1</item1>
    <item2>item2</item2>
</event>

The other answers cover the 2 most common approaches, Xinclude and XML external entities. Microsoft has a really great writeup on why one should prefer Xinclude, as well as several example implementations. I've quoted the comparison below:

Per http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa302291.aspx

Why XInclude?

The first question one may ask is "Why use XInclude instead of XML external entities?" The answer is that XML external entities have a number of well-known limitations and inconvenient implications, which effectively prevent them from being a general-purpose inclusion facility. Specifically:

  • An XML external entity cannot be a full-blown independent XML document—neither standalone XML declaration nor Doctype declaration is allowed. That effectively means an XML external entity itself cannot include other external entities.
  • An XML external entity must be well formed XML (not so bad at first glance, but imagine you want to include sample C# code into your XML document).
  • Failure to load an external entity is a fatal error; any recovery is strictly forbidden.
  • Only the whole external entity may be included, there is no way to include only a portion of a document. -External entities must be declared in a DTD or an internal subset. This opens a Pandora's Box full of implications, such as the fact that the document element must be named in Doctype declaration and that validating readers may require that the full content model of the document be defined in DTD among others.

The deficiencies of using XML external entities as an inclusion mechanism have been known for some time and in fact spawned the submission of the XML Inclusion Proposal to the W3C in 1999 by Microsoft and IBM. The proposal defined a processing model and syntax for a general-purpose XML inclusion facility.

Four years later, version 1.0 of the XML Inclusions, also known as Xinclude, is a Candidate Recommendation, which means that the W3C believes that it has been widely reviewed and satisfies the basic technical problems it set out to solve, but is not yet a full recommendation.

Another good site which provides a variety of example implementations is https://www.xml.com/pub/a/2002/07/31/xinclude.html. Below is a common use case example from their site:

<book xmlns:xi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XInclude">

  <title>The Wit and Wisdom of George W. Bush</title>

  <xi:include href="malapropisms.xml"/>

  <xi:include href="mispronunciations.xml"/>

  <xi:include href="madeupwords.xml"/>

</book>


Examples related to xml

strange error in my Animation Drawable How do I POST XML data to a webservice with Postman? PHP XML Extension: Not installed How to add a Hint in spinner in XML Generating Request/Response XML from a WSDL Manifest Merger failed with multiple errors in Android Studio How to set menu to Toolbar in Android How to add colored border on cardview? Android: ScrollView vs NestedScrollView WARNING: Exception encountered during context initialization - cancelling refresh attempt

Examples related to file

Gradle - Move a folder from ABC to XYZ Difference between opening a file in binary vs text Angular: How to download a file from HttpClient? Python error message io.UnsupportedOperation: not readable java.io.FileNotFoundException: class path resource cannot be opened because it does not exist Writing JSON object to a JSON file with fs.writeFileSync How to read/write files in .Net Core? How to write to a CSV line by line? Writing a dictionary to a text file? What are the pros and cons of parquet format compared to other formats?

Examples related to import

Import functions from another js file. Javascript The difference between "require(x)" and "import x" pytest cannot import module while python can How to import an Excel file into SQL Server? When should I use curly braces for ES6 import? How to import a JSON file in ECMAScript 6? Python: Importing urllib.quote importing external ".txt" file in python beyond top level package error in relative import Reading tab-delimited file with Pandas - works on Windows, but not on Mac

Examples related to merge

Pandas Merging 101 Python: pandas merge multiple dataframes Git merge with force overwrite Merge two dataframes by index Visual Studio Code how to resolve merge conflicts with git? merge one local branch into another local branch Merging dataframes on index with pandas Git merge is not possible because I have unmerged files Git merge develop into feature branch outputs "Already up-to-date" while it's not How merge two objects array in angularjs?