[networking] TCP vs UDP on video stream

One of the biggest problems with delivering live events on Internet is 'scale', and TCP doesn’t scale well. For example when you are beaming a live football match -as opposed to an on demand movie playback- the number of people watching can easily be 1000 times more. In such a scenario using TCP is a death sentence for the CDNs (content delivery networks).

There are a couple of main reasons why TCP doesn't scale well:

  1. One of the largest tradeoffs of TCP is the variability of throughput achievable between the sender and the receiver. When streaming video over the Internet the video packets must traverse multiple routers over the Internet, each of these routers is connected with different speed connections. The TCP algorithm starts with TCP window off small, then grows until packet loss is detected, the packet loss is considered a sign of congestion and TCP responds to it by drastically reducing the window size to avoid congestion. Thus in turn reducing the effective throughput immediately. Now imagine a network with TCP transmission using 6-7 router hops to the client (a very normal scenario), if any of the intermediate router looses any packet, the TCP for that link will reduce the transmission rate. In-fact The traffic flow between routers follow an hourglass kind of a shape; always gong up and down in-between one of the intermediate routers. Rendering the effective through put much lower compared to best-effort UDP.

  2. As you may already know TCP is an acknowledgement-based protocol. Lets for example say a sender is 50ms away (i.e. latency btw two points). This would mean time it takes for a packet to be sent to a receiver and receiver to send an acknowledgement would be 100ms; thus maximum throughput possible as compared to UDP based transmission is already halved.

  3. The TCP doesn’t support multicasting or the new emerging standard of multicasting AMT. Which means the CDNs don’t have the opportunity to reduce network traffic by replicating the packets -when many clients are watching the same content. That itself is a big enough reason for CDNs (like Akamai or Level3) to not go with TCP for live streams.

Examples related to networking

Access HTTP response as string in Go Communication between multiple docker-compose projects Can't access 127.0.0.1 How do I delete virtual interface in Linux? ConnectivityManager getNetworkInfo(int) deprecated Bridged networking not working in Virtualbox under Windows 10 Difference between PACKETS and FRAMES How to communicate between Docker containers via "hostname" java.net.ConnectException: failed to connect to /192.168.253.3 (port 2468): connect failed: ECONNREFUSED (Connection refused) wget: unable to resolve host address `http'

Examples related to video

How to handle "Uncaught (in promise) DOMException: play() failed because the user didn't interact with the document first." on Desktop with Chrome 66? How to make a movie out of images in python HTML5 Video autoplay on iPhone How do we download a blob url video Twitter - How to embed native video from someone else's tweet into a New Tweet or a DM How to embed new Youtube's live video permanent URL? How to disable auto-play for local video in iframe Writing an mp4 video using python opencv How to extract 1 screenshot for a video with ffmpeg at a given time? Bootstrap 3 - Responsive mp4-video

Examples related to tcp

What does "app.run(host='0.0.0.0') " mean in Flask What is the difference between HTTP 1.1 and HTTP 2.0? Sending a file over TCP sockets in Python Telnet is not recognized as internal or external command How to open port in Linux adb connection over tcp not working now Understanding [TCP ACKed unseen segment] [TCP Previous segment not captured] How do I debug error ECONNRESET in Node.js? Differences between TCP sockets and web sockets, one more time Is SMTP based on TCP or UDP?

Examples related to udp

How do I publish a UDP Port on Docker? Simple UDP example to send and receive data from same socket Is SMTP based on TCP or UDP? What does it mean to bind a multicast (UDP) socket? Sending and receiving UDP packets? How to send only one UDP packet with netcat? How is TeamViewer so fast? TCP vs UDP on video stream Difference between TCP and UDP? What are examples of TCP and UDP in real life?

Examples related to video-streaming

What steps are needed to stream RTSP from FFmpeg? How to process images of a video, frame by frame, in video streaming using OpenCV and Python How to play .mp4 video in videoview in android? HTML5 Video Autoplay not working correctly Live-stream video from one android phone to another over WiFi Recording video feed from an IP camera over a network Play infinitely looping video on-load in HTML5 TCP vs UDP on video stream HTML5 live streaming Video streaming over websockets using JavaScript