Volatile vs Static in Java

Question

Is it correct to say that static means one copy of the value for all objects and volatile means one copy of the value for all threads    Anyway a static variable value is also going to be one value for all threads  then why should we go for volatile

User · Answer

Difference Between Static and Volatile    Static Variable   If two Threads suppose t1 and t2  are accessing the same object and updating a variable which is declared as static   then  it means t1 and t2 can make their own local copy  of the same object including static variables  in their respective cache  so update made by t1 to the static variable in its local cache wont reflect  in the static variable for t2 cache    Static variables are used in the context of Object where update made by one object would reflect in all the other objects of the same class but not in  the context of Thread where update of one thread to the static variable will reflect the changes immediately to all the threads  in their local cache    Volatile variable  If two Threads suppose t1 and t2  are accessing the same object and updating a variable which is declared as volatile   then  it means t1 and t2 can make their own local cache  of the Object except the variable which is declared as a volatile   So the volatile variable will have only one main copy which will be updated by different threads and update made by one thread to the volatile variable will immediately reflect to the other Thread

User · Answer

In simple terms    static   static variables are associated with the class  rather than with any object  Every instance of the class shares a class variable  which is in one fixed location in memory volatile  This keyword is applicable to both class and instance variables        Using volatile variables reduces the risk of memory consistency errors  because any write to a volatile variable establishes a happens-before relationship with subsequent reads of that same variable  This means that changes to a volatile variable are always visible to other threads   Have a look at this article by Javin Paul  to understand volatile variables in a better way     In absence of volatile keyword  the value of variable in each thread s stack may be different  By making the variable as volatile  all threads will get same value in their working memory and memory consistency errors have been avoided   Here the term variable can be either static  class  variable or instance  object  variable   Regarding your query       Anyway a static variable value is also going to be one value for all threads  then why should we go for volatile    If I need instance variable in my application  I can t use static variable  Even in case of static variable  consistency is not guaranteed due to Thread cache as shown in the diagram   Using volatile variables reduces the risk of memory consistency errors  because any write to a volatile variable establishes a happens-before relationship with subsequent reads of that same variable  This means that changes to a volatile variable are always visible to other threads       What s more  it also means that when a thread reads a volatile variable  it sees not just the latest change to the volatile  but also the side effects of the code that led up the change    memory consistency errors are still possible with volatile variables  To avoid side effects  you have to use synchronized variables  But there is a better solution in java    Using simple atomic variable access is more efficient than accessing these variables through synchronized code  Some of the classes in the java util concurrent package provide atomic methods that do not rely on synchronization   Refer to this high level concurrency control article for more details    Especially have a look at Atomic variables   Related SE questions   Volatile Vs Atomic  Volatile boolean vs AtomicBoolean  Difference between volatile and synchronized in Java

User · Answer

I think static and volatile have no relation at all  I suggest you read java tutorial to understand Atomic Access  and why use atomic access  understand what is interleaved  you will find answer

User · Answer

Declaring a static variable in Java  means that there will be only one copy  no matter how many objects of the class are created  The variable will be accessible even with no Objects created at all  However  threads may have locally cached values of it   When a variable is volatile and not static  there will be one variable for each Object  So  on the surface it seems there is no difference from a normal variable but totally different from static  However  even with Object fields  a thread may cache a variable value locally   This means that if two threads update a variable of the same Object concurrently  and the variable is not declared volatile  there could be a case in which one of the thread has in cache an old value   Even if you access a static value through multiple threads  each thread can have its local cached copy  To avoid this you can declare the variable as static volatile and this will force the thread to read each time the global value   However  volatile is not a substitute for proper synchronisation  For instance   private static volatile int counter   0   private void concurrentMethodWrong       counter   counter   5      do something   counter   counter - 5      Executing concurrentMethodWrong concurrently many times may lead to a final value of counter different from zero  To solve the problem  you have to implement a lock   private static final Object counterLock   new Object     private static volatile int counter   0   private void concurrentMethodRight       synchronized  counterLock        counter   counter   5          do something   synchronized  counterLock        counter   counter - 5          Or use the AtomicInteger class

User · Answer

volatile variable value access will be direct from main memory  It should be used only in multi-threading environment  static variable will be loaded one time  If its used in single thread environment  even if the copy of the variable will be updated and there will be no harm accessing it as there is only one thread   Now if static variable is used in multi-threading environment then there will be issues if one expects desired result from it  As each thread has their own copy then any increment or decrement on static variable from one thread may not reflect in another thread   if one expects desired results from static variable then use volatile with static in multi-threading then everything will be resolved

User · Answer

In addition to other answers  I would like to add one image for it pic makes easy to understand      static variables may be cached for individual threads  In multi-threaded environment if one thread modifies its cached data  that may not reflect for other threads as they have a copy of it   volatile declaration makes sure that threads won t cache the data and uses the shared copy only    image source

User · Answer

Not sure static variables are cached in thread local memory or NOT  But when I executed two threads T1 T2  accessing same object obj  and when update made by T1 thread to static variable it got reflected in T2

User · Answer

If we declare a variable as static  there will be only one copy of the variable  So  whenever different threads access that variable  there will be only one final value for the variable since there is only one memory location allocated for the variable    If a variable is declared as volatile  all threads will have their own copy of the variable but the value is taken from the main memory So  the value of the variable in all the threads will be the same   So  in both cases  the main point is that the value of the variable is same across all threads

[java] Volatile vs Static in Java

Examples related to java

Examples related to multithreading

Examples related to concurrency

Examples related to static

Examples related to volatile