[c#] How to fix System.NullReferenceException: Object reference not set to an instance of an object

If the problem is 100% here

EffectSelectorForm effectSelectorForm = new EffectSelectorForm(Effects);

There's only one possible explanation: property/variable "Effects" is not initialized properly... Debug your code to see what you pass to your objects.

EDIT after several hours

There were some problems:

  • MEF attribute [Import] didn't work as expected, so we replaced it for the time being with a manually populated List<>. While the collection was null, it was causing exceptions later in the code, when the method tried to get the type of the selected item and there was none.

  • several event handlers weren't wired up to control events

Some problems are still present, but I believe OP's original problem has been fixed. Other problems are not related to this one.