--SQL Server 2005+
CREATE TABLE dbo.Students
(
StudentId INT
, Name VARCHAR(50)
, CONSTRAINT PK_Students PRIMARY KEY (StudentId)
);
CREATE TABLE dbo.Subjects
(
SubjectId INT
, Name VARCHAR(50)
, CONSTRAINT PK_Subjects PRIMARY KEY (SubjectId)
);
CREATE TABLE dbo.Schedules
(
StudentId INT
, SubjectId INT
, CONSTRAINT PK__Schedule PRIMARY KEY (StudentId, SubjectId)
, CONSTRAINT FK_Schedule_Students FOREIGN KEY (StudentId) REFERENCES dbo.Students (StudentId)
, CONSTRAINT FK_Schedule_Subjects FOREIGN KEY (SubjectId) REFERENCES dbo.Subjects (SubjectId)
);
INSERT dbo.Students (StudentId, Name) VALUES
(1, 'Mary')
, (2, 'John')
, (3, 'Sam')
, (4, 'Alaina')
, (5, 'Edward')
;
INSERT dbo.Subjects (SubjectId, Name) VALUES
(1, 'Physics')
, (2, 'Geography')
, (3, 'French')
, (4, 'Gymnastics')
;
INSERT dbo.Schedules (StudentId, SubjectId) VALUES
(1, 1) --Mary, Physics
, (2, 1) --John, Physics
, (3, 1) --Sam, Physics
, (4, 2) --Alaina, Geography
, (5, 2) --Edward, Geography
;
SELECT
sub.SubjectId
, sub.Name AS [SubjectName]
, ISNULL( x.Students, '') AS Students
FROM
dbo.Subjects sub
OUTER APPLY
(
SELECT
CASE ROW_NUMBER() OVER (ORDER BY stu.Name) WHEN 1 THEN '' ELSE ', ' END
+ stu.Name
FROM
dbo.Students stu
INNER JOIN dbo.Schedules sch
ON stu.StudentId = sch.StudentId
WHERE
sch.SubjectId = sub.SubjectId
ORDER BY
stu.Name
FOR XML PATH('')
) x (Students)
;