Android - how do I investigate an ANR

Question

Is there a way of finding out where my app threw an ANR  Application Not Responding   I took a look at the traces txt file in  data and I see a trace for my application  This is what I see in the trace   DALVIK THREADS   main  prio 5 tid 3 TIMED WAIT     group  main  sCount 1 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x400143a8     sysTid 691 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle -1091117924   at java lang Object wait Native Method    - waiting on  lt 0x1cd570 gt   a android os MessageQueue    at java lang Object wait Object java 195    at android os MessageQueue next MessageQueue java 144    at android os Looper loop Looper java 110    at android app ActivityThread main ActivityThread java 3742    at java lang reflect Method invokeNative Native Method    at java lang reflect Method invoke Method java 515    at com android internal os ZygoteInit MethodAndArgsCaller run ZygoteInit java 739    at com android internal os ZygoteInit main ZygoteInit java 497    at dalvik system NativeStart main Native Method    Binder Thread  3  prio 5 tid 15 NATIVE     group  main  sCount 1 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x434e7758     sysTid 734 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle 1733632   at dalvik system NativeStart run Native Method    Binder Thread  2  prio 5 tid 13 NATIVE     group  main  sCount 1 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x433af808     sysTid 696 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle 1369840   at dalvik system NativeStart run Native Method    Binder Thread  1  prio 5 tid 11 NATIVE     group  main  sCount 1 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x433aca10     sysTid 695 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle 1367448   at dalvik system NativeStart run Native Method    JDWP  daemon prio 5 tid 9 VMWAIT     group  system  sCount 1 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x433ac2a0     sysTid 694 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle 1367136   at dalvik system NativeStart run Native Method    Signal Catcher  daemon prio 5 tid 7 RUNNABLE     group  system  sCount 0 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x433ac1e8     sysTid 693 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle 1366712   at dalvik system NativeStart run Native Method    HeapWorker  daemon prio 5 tid 5 VMWAIT     group  system  sCount 1 dsCount 0 s 0 obj 0x4253ef88     sysTid 692 nice 0 sched 0 0 handle 1366472   at dalvik system NativeStart run Native Method   ----- end 691 -----   How can I find out where the problem is  The methods in the trace are all SDK methods   Thanks

User · Answer

You are wondering which task hold a UI Thread. Trace file gives you a hint to find the task. you need investigate a state of each thread

State of thread

running - executing application code
sleeping - called Thread.sleep()
monitor - waiting to acquire a monitor lock
wait - in Object.wait()
native - executing native code
vmwait - waiting on a VM resource
zombie - thread is in the process of dying
init - thread is initializing (you shouldn't see this)
starting - thread is about to start (you shouldn't see this either)

Focus on SUSPENDED, MONITOR state. Monitor state indicates which thread is investigated and SUSPENDED state of the thread is probably main reason for deadlock.

Basic investigate steps

Find "waiting to lock"
- you can find monitor state "Binder Thread #15" prio=5 tid=75 MONITOR
- you are lucky if find "waiting to lock"
- example : waiting to lock <0xblahblah> (a com.foo.A) held by threadid=74
You can notice that "tid=74" hold a task now. So go to tid=74
tid=74 maybe SUSPENDED state! find main reason!

trace does not always contain "waiting to lock". in this case it is hard to find main reason.

User · Answer

What Triggers ANR   Generally  the system displays an ANR if an application cannot respond to user input    In any situation in which your app performs a potentially lengthy operation  you should not perform the work on the UI thread  but instead create a worker thread and do most of the work there  This keeps the UI thread  which drives the user interface event loop  running and prevents the system from concluding that your code has frozen    How to Avoid ANRs  Android applications normally run entirely on a single thread by default the  UI thread  or  main thread    This means anything your application is doing in the UI thread that takes a long time to complete can trigger the ANR dialog because your application is not giving itself a chance to handle the input event or intent broadcasts   Therefore  any method that runs in the UI thread should do as little work as possible on that thread  In particular  activities should do as little as possible to set up in key life-cycle methods such as onCreate   and onResume    Potentially long running operations such as network or database operations  or computationally expensive calculations such as resizing bitmaps should be done in a worker thread  or in the case of databases operations  via an asynchronous request    Code  Worker thread with the AsyncTask class  private class DownloadFilesTask extends AsyncTask lt URL  Integer  Long gt           Do the long-running work in here     protected Long doInBackground URL    urls            int count   urls length          long totalSize   0          for  int i   0  i  lt  count  i                  totalSize    Downloader downloadFile urls i                publishProgress  int    i    float  count    100                   Escape early if cancel   is called             if  isCancelled    break                    return totalSize                This is called each time you call publishProgress       protected void onProgressUpdate Integer    progress            setProgressPercent progress 0                  This is called when doInBackground   is finished     protected void onPostExecute Long result            showNotification  Downloaded     result     bytes              Code  Execute Worker thread  To execute this worker thread  simply create an instance and call execute     new DownloadFilesTask   execute url1  url2  url3     Source  http   developer android com training articles perf-anr html

User · Answer

Basic on  Horyun Lee answer  I wrote a small python script to help to investigate ANR from traces txt   The ANRs will output as graphics by graphviz if you have installed grapvhviz on your system       anr py --format png   traces txt   A png will output like below if there are ANRs detected in file traces txt  It s more intuitive     The sample traces txt file used above was get from here

User · Answer

Consider using the ANR-Watchdog library to accurately track and capture ANR stack traces in a high level of detail  You can then send them to your crash reporting library  I recommend using setReportMainThreadOnly   in this scenario  You can either make the app throw a non-fatal exception of the freeze point  or make the app force quit when the ANR happens   Note that the standard ANR reports sent to your Google Play Developer console are often not accurate enough to pinpoint the exact problem  That s why a third-party library is needed

User · Answer

my issue with ANR   after much work i found out that a thread was calling a resource that did not exist in the layout  instead of returning an exception   i got ANR

User · Answer

You can enable StrictMode in API level 9 and above      StrictMode is most commonly used to catch accidental disk or network   access on the application s main thread  where UI operations are   received and animations take place  By keeping your application s main thread   responsive  you also prevent ANR dialogs from being shown to users    public void onCreate         StrictMode setVmPolicy new StrictMode VmPolicy Builder                               detectAll                               penaltyLog                               penaltyDeath                               build         super onCreate           using penaltyLog   you can watch the output of adb logcat while you   use your application to see the violations as they happen

User · Answer

I ve been learning android for the last few months  so I m far from an expert  but I ve been really disappointed with the documentation on ANRs   Most of the advice seems to be geared towards avoiding them or fixing them by blindly looking through your code  which is great  but I couldn t find anything on analyzing the trace   There are three things you really need to look for with ANR logs   1  Deadlocks  When a thread is in the WAIT state  you can look through the details to find who it s  heldby    Most of the time  it ll be held by itself  but if it s held by another thread  that s likely to be a danger sign  Go look at that thread and see what it s held by  You might find a loop  which is a clear sign that something has gone wrong  This is pretty rare  but it s the first point because when it happens  it s a nightmare  2  Main thread Waiting  If your main thread is in the WAIT state  check if it s held by another thread  This shouldn t happen  because your UI thread shouldn t be held by a background thread   Both of these scenarios  mean you need to rework your code significantly   3  Heavy operations on the main thread  This is the most common cause of ANRs  but sometimes one of the harder to find and fix  Look at the main thread details  Scroll down the stack trace and until you see classes you recognize  from your app   Look at the methods in the trace and figure out if you re making network calls  db calls  etc  in these places   Finally  and I apologize for shamelessly plugging my own code  you can use the python log analyzer I wrote at https   github com HarshEvilGeek Android-Log-Analyzer This will go through your log files  open ANR files  find deadlocks  find waiting main threads  find uncaught exceptions in your agent logs and print it all out on the screen in a relatively easy to read manner  Read the ReadMe file  which I m about to add  to learn how to use it  It s helped me a ton in the last week

User · Answer

You need to look for  waiting to lock  in  data anr traces txt file    for more details  Engineer for High Performance with Tools from Android  amp  Play  Google I O  17

User · Answer

Whenever you re analyzing timing issues  debugging often does not help  as freezing the app at a breakpoint will make the problem go away   Your best bet is to insert lots of logging calls  Log XXX    into the app s different threads and callbacks and see where the delay is at  If you need a stacktrace  create a new Exception  just instantiate one  and log it

User · Answer

An ANR happens when some long operation takes place in the  main  thread  This is the event loop thread  and if it is busy  Android cannot process any further GUI events in the application  and thus throws up an ANR dialog   Now  in the trace you posted  the main thread seems to be doing fine  there is no problem  It is idling in the MessageQueue  waiting for another message to come in  In your case the ANR was likely a longer operation  rather than something that blocked the thread permanently  so the event thread recovered after the operation finished  and your trace went through after the ANR   Detecting where ANRs happen is easy if it is a permanent block  deadlock acquiring some locks for instance   but harder if it s just a temporary delay  First  go over your code and look for vunerable spots and long running operations  Examples may include using sockets  locks  thread sleeps  and other blocking operations from within the event thread  You should make sure these all happen in separate threads  If nothing seems the problem  use DDMS and enable the thread view  This shows all the threads in your application similar to the trace you have  Reproduce the ANR  and refresh the main thread at the same time  That should show you precisely whats going on at the time of the ANR

[android] Android - how do I investigate an ANR?

State of thread

Basic investigate steps

Examples related to android

Examples related to performance

Examples related to android-anr-dialog