How do browser cookie domains work

Question

Due to weird domain subdomain cookie issues that I m getting  I d like to know how browsers handle cookies  If they do it in different ways  it would also be nice to know the differences   In other words - when a browser receives a cookie  that cookie MAY have a domain and a path attached to it  Or not  in which case the browser probably substitutes some defaults for them  Question 1  what are they   Later  when the browser is about to make a request  it checks its cookies and filters out the ones it should send for that request  It does so by matching them against the requests path and domain  Question 2  what are the matching rules   Added   The reason I m asking this is because I m interested in some edge cases  Like    Will a cookie for  example com be available for www example com  Will a cookie for  example com be available for example com  Will a cookie for example com be available for www example com  Will a cookie for example com be available for anotherexample com  Will www example com be able to set cookie for example com  Will www example com be able to set cookie for www2 example com  Will www example com be able to set cookie for  com  Etc    Added 2   Also  could someone suggest how I should set a cookie so that    It can be set by either www example com or example com  It is accessible by both www example com and example com

User · Answer

The last  third to be exactly  RFC for this issue is RFC-6265  Obsoletes RFC-2965 that in turn obsoletes RFC-2109    According to it if the server omits the Domain attribute  the user agent will return the cookie only to the origin server  the server on which a given resource resides   But it s also warning that some existing user agents treat an absent Domain attribute as if the Domain attribute were present and contained the current host name  For example  if example com returns a Set-Cookie header without a Domain attribute  these user agents will erroneously send the cookie to www example com as well    When the Domain attribute have been specified  it will be treated as complete domain name  if there is the leading dot in attribute it will be ignored   Server should match the domain specified in attribute  have exactly the same domain name or to be a subdomain of it  to get this cookie  More accurately it specified here   So  for example    cookie attribute Domain  example com is equivalent to Domain example com cookies with such Domain attributes will be available for example com and www example com cookies with such Domain attributes will be not available for  another-example com specifying cookie attribute like Domain www example com will close the way for www4 example com   PS  trailing comma in Domain attribute will cause the user agent to ignore the attribute

User · Answer

For an extensive coverage review the contents of RFC2965   Of course that doesn t necessarily mean that all browsers behave exactly the same way   However in general the rule for default Path if none specified in the cookie is the path in the URL from which the Set-Cookie header arrived   Similarly the default for the Domain is the full host name in the URL from which the Set-Cookie arrived   Matching rules for the domain require the cookie Domain to match the host to which the request is being made   The cookie can specify a wider domain match by include    in the domain attribute of Set-Cookie  this one area that browsers may vary    Matching the path  assuming the domain matches  is a simple matter that the requested path must be inside the path specified on the cookie   Typically session cookies are set with path   or path  applicationName  so the cookie is available to all requests into the application    Response to Added    Will a cookie for  example com be available for www example com   Yes Will a cookie for  example com be available for example com   Don t Know Will a cookie for example com be available for www example com  Shouldn t but      Will a cookie for example com be available for anotherexample com   No Will www example com be able to set cookie for example com   Yes Will www example com be able to set cookie for www2 example com   No   Except via  example com  Will www example com be able to set cookie for  com   No   Can t set a cookie this high up the namespace nor can you set one for something like  co uk       I m unable to test this right now but I have an inkling that at least IE7 6 would treat the path  example com as if it were  example com

User · Answer

Although there is the RFC 2965  Set-Cookie2  had already obsoleted RFC 2109  that should define the cookie nowadays  most browsers don   t fully support that but just comply to the original specification by Netscape   There is a distinction between the Domain attribute value and the effective domain  the former is taken from the Set-Cookie header field and the latter is the interpretation of that attribute value  According to the RFC 2965  the following should apply    If the Set-Cookie header field does not have a Domain attribute  the effective domain is the domain of the request  If there is a Domain attribute present  its value will be used as effective domain  if the value does not start with a   it will be added by the client     Having the effective domain it must also domain-match the current requested domain for being set  otherwise the cookie will be revised  The same rule applies for choosing the cookies to be sent in a request     Mapping this knowledge onto your questions  the following should apply    Cookie with Domain  example com will be available for www example com Cookie with Domain  example com will be available for example com Cookie with Domain example com will be converted to  example com and thus will also be available for www example com Cookie with Domain example com will not be available for anotherexample com www example com will be able to set cookie for example com www example com will not be able to set cookie for www2 example com www example com will not be able to set cookie for  com   And to set and read a cookie for by www example com and example com  set it for  www example com and  example com respectively  But the first   www example com  will only be accessible for other domains below that domain  e g  foo www example com or bar www example com  where  example com can also be accessed by any other domain below example com  e g  foo example com or bar example com

User · Answer

I tested all the cases in the latest Chrome  Firefox  Safari in 2019   Response to Added    Will a cookie for  example com be available for www example com  YES Will a cookie for  example com be available for example com  YES Will a cookie for example com be available for www example com  NO  Domain without wildcard only matches itself   Will a cookie for example com be available for anotherexample com  NO Will www example com be able to set cookie for example com  NO  it will be able to set cookie for   example com   but not  example com   Will www example com be able to set cookie for www2 example com  NO  But it can set cookie for  example com  which www2 example com can access  Will www example com be able to set cookie for  com  NO

User · Answer

There are rules that determine whether a browser will accept the Set-header response header  server-side cookie writing   a slightly different rules interpretations for cookie set using Javascript  I haven t tested VBScript    Then there are rules that determine whether the browser will send a cookie along with the page request   There are differences between the major browser engines how domain matches are handled  and how parameters in path values are interpreted  You can find some empirical evidence in the article How Different Browsers Handle Cookies Differently

User · Answer

The previous answers are a little outdated   RFC 6265 was published in 2011  based on the browser consensus at that time  Since then  there has been some complication with public suffix domains  I ve written an article explaining the current situation - http   bayou io draft cookie domain html  To summarize  rules to follow regarding cookie domain    The origin domain of a cookie is the domain of the originating request  If the origin domain is an IP  the cookie s domain attribute must not be set  If a cookie s domain attribute is not set  the cookie is only applicable to its origin domain  If a cookie s domain attribute is set    the cookie is applicable to that domain and all its subdomains  the cookie s domain must be the same as  or a parent of  the origin domain the cookie s domain must not be a TLD  a public suffix  or a parent of a public suffix     It can be derived that a cookie is always applicable to its origin domain   The cookie domain should not have a leading dot  as in  foo com - simply use foo com  As an example     x y z com can set a cookie domain to itself or parents - x y z com  y z com  z com  But not com  which is a public suffix  a cookie with domain y z com is applicable to y z com  x y z com  a x y z com etc    Examples of public suffixes - com  edu  uk  co uk  blogspot com  compute amazonaws com

User · Answer

I was surprised to read section 3 3 2 about rejecting cookies   http   tools ietf org html rfc2965  That says that a browser should reject a cookie from x y z com with domain  z com  because  x y  contains a dot  So  unless I am misinterpreting the RFC and or the questions above  there could be questions added   Will a cookie for  example com be available for www yyy example com  No   Will a cookie set by origin server www yyy example com  with domain  example com  have it s value sent by the user agent to xxx example com  No

User · Answer

Will www example com be able to set cookie for  com    No  but example com fr may be able to set a cookie for example2 com fr  Firefox protects against this by maintaining a list of TLDs  http   securitylabs websense com content Blogs 3108 aspx  Apparently Internet Explorer doesn t allow two-letter domains to set cookies  which I suppose explains why o2 ie simply redirects to o2online ie  I d often wondered that

User · Answer

The RFCs are known not to reflect reality   Better check draft-ietf-httpstate-cookie  work in progress

[http] How do browser cookie domains work?

Examples related to http

Examples related to cookies

Examples related to path

Examples related to dns

Examples related to rules