Does git fetch --tags include git fetch

Question

A nice and simple question - is the function of "git fetch" a strict sub-set of git fetch --tags?

I.e. if I run git fetch --tags, is there ever a reason to immediately run git fetch straight afterward?

What about git pull and git pull --tags? Same situation?

User · Answer

Note  this answer is only valid for git v1 8 and older   Most of this has been said in the other answers and comments  but here s a concise explanation    git fetch fetches all branch heads  or all specified by the remote fetch config option   all commits necessary for them  and all tags which are reachable from these branches  In most cases  all tags are reachable in this way  git fetch --tags fetches all tags  all commits necessary for them  It will not update branch heads  even if they are reachable from the tags which were fetched    Summary  If you really want to be totally up to date  using only fetch  you must do both    It s also not  twice as slow  unless you mean in terms of typing on the command-line  in which case aliases solve your problem  There is essentially no overhead in making the two requests  since they are asking for different information

User · Answer

git fetch upstream --tags   works just fine  it will only get new tags and will not get any other code base

User · Answer

In most situations  git fetch should do what you want  which is  get anything new from the remote repository and put it in your local copy without merging to your local branches    git fetch --tags does exactly that  except that it doesn t get anything except new tags   In that sense  git fetch --tags is in no way a superset of git fetch   It is in fact exactly the opposite   git pull  of course  is nothing but a wrapper for a git fetch  lt thisrefspec gt   git merge   It s recommended that you get used to doing manual git fetching and git mergeing before you make the jump to git pull simply because it helps you understand what git pull is doing in the first place   That being said  the relationship is exactly the same as with git fetch   git pull is the superset of git pull --tags

User · Answer

The general problem here is that git fetch will fetch  refs heads   refs remotes  remote     If any of these commits have tags  those tags will also be fetched   However if there are tags not reachable by any branch on the remote  they will not be fetched   The --tags option switches the refspec to  refs tags   refs tags     You could ask git fetch to grab both  I m pretty sure to just do a git fetch  amp  amp  git fetch -t you d use the following command   git fetch origin   refs heads   refs remotes origin      refs tags   refs tags      And if you wanted to make this the default for this repo  you can add a second refspec to the default fetch   git config --local --add remote origin fetch   refs tags   refs tags      This will add a second fetch   line in the  git config for this remote     I spent a while looking for the way to handle this for a project   This is what I came up with   git fetch -fup origin   refs   refs      In my case I wanted these features   Grab all heads and tags from the remote so use refspec refs   refs   Overwrite local branches and tags with non-fast-forward   before the refspec Overwrite currently checked out branch if needed -u Delete branches and tags not present in remote -p And force to be sure -f

User · Answer

Note  starting with git 1 9 2 0  Q1 2014   git fetch --tags fetches tags in addition to what are fetched by the same command line without the option   See commit c5a84e9 by Michael Haggerty  mhagger       Previously  fetch s  --tags  option was considered equivalent to specifying the refspec     refs tags   refs tags         on the command line    in particular  it caused the remote  lt name gt  refspec configuration to be ignored       But it is not very useful to fetch tags without also fetching other references  whereas it is quite useful to be able to fetch tags in addition to other references    So change the semantics of this option to do the latter       If a user wants to fetch only tags  then it is still possible to specifying an explicit refspec   git fetch  lt remote gt   refs tags   refs tags          Please note that the documentation prior to 1 8 0 3 was ambiguous about this aspect of  fetch --tags  behavior    Commit f0cb2f1  2012-12-14  fetch --tags made the documentation match the old behavior    This commit changes the documentation to match the new behavior  see Documentation fetch-options txt        Request that all tags be fetched from the remote in addition to whatever else is being fetched      Since Git 2 5  Q2 2015  git pull --tags is more robust   See commit 19d122b by Paul Tan  pyokagan   13 May 2015   Merged by Junio C Hamano -- gitster -- in commit cc77b99  22 May 2015      pull  remove --tags error in no merge candidates case      Since 441ed41   git pull --tags   error out with a better message     2007-12-28  Git 1 5 4    git pull --tags would print a different error message if   git-fetch did not return any merge candidates   It doesn t make sense to pull all tags  you probably meant         git fetch --tags       This is because at that time  git-fetch --tags would override any   configured refspecs  and thus there would be no merge candidates  The error message was thus introduced to prevent confusion       However  since c5a84e9  fetch --tags  fetch tags in addition to   other stuff  2013-10-30  Git 1 9 0    git fetch --tags would fetch tags in addition   to any configured refspecs    Hence  if any no merge candidates situation occurs  it is not because --tags was set  As such  this special error message is now irrelevant       To prevent confusion  remove this error message      With Git 2 11   Q4 2016  git fetch is quicker   See commit 5827a03  13 Oct 2016  by Jeff King  peff    Merged by Junio C Hamano -- gitster -- in commit 9fcd144  26 Oct 2016        fetch  use  quick  has sha1 file for tag following      When fetching from a remote that has many tags that are irrelevant to branches we are following  we used to waste way too many cycles when checking if the object pointed at by a tag  that we are not going to fetch   exists in our repository too carefully       This patch teaches fetch to use HAS SHA1 QUICK to sacrifice   accuracy for speed  in cases where we might be racy with a   simultaneous repack       Here are results from the included perf script  which sets up a situation similar to the one described above    Test            HEAD                HEAD ---------------------------------------------------------- 5550 4  fetch   11 21 10 42 0 78    0 08 0 04 0 02  -99 3    That applies only for a situation where         You have a lot of packs on the client side to make reprepare packed git   expensive  the most expensive part is finding duplicates in an unsorted list  which is currently quadratic     You need a large number of tag refs on the server side that are candidates for auto-following  i e   that the  client doesn t have      Each one triggers a re-read of the pack directory    Under normal circumstances  the client would auto-follow those tags and after one large fetch   2  would no longer be true    But if those tags point to history which is disconnected from what the client otherwise fetches  then it will never auto-follow  and those candidates will impact it on every fetch         Git 2 21  Feb  2019  seems to have introduced a regression when the config remote origin fetch is not the default one    refs heads   refs remotes origin      fatal  multiple updates for ref  refs tags v1 0 0  not allowed     Git 2 24  Q4 2019  adds another optimization   See commit b7e2d8b  15 Sep 2019  by Masaya Suzuki  draftcode    Merged by Junio C Hamano -- gitster -- in commit 1d8b0df  07 Oct 2019        fetch  use oidset to keep the want OIDs for faster lookup      During git fetch  the client checks if the advertised tags  OIDs are already in the fetch request s want OID set    This check is done in a linear scan    For a repository that has a lot of refs  repeating this scan takes 15  minutes         In order to speed this up  create a oid set for other refs  OIDs

User · Answer

I m going to answer this myself   I ve determined that there is a difference   git fetch --tags  might bring in all the tags  but it doesn t bring in any new commits   Turns out one has to do this to be totally  up to date   i e  replicated a  git pull  without the merge     git fetch --tags   git fetch   This is a shame  because it s twice as slow  If only  git fetch  had an option to do what it normally does and bring in all the tags

[git] Does "git fetch --tags" include "git fetch"?

The answer is

Examples related to git

Examples related to pull

Examples related to git-tag

Examples related to git-fetch

Tags