What s the difference between implementation and compile in Gradle

Question

After updating to Android Studio 3 0 and creating a new project  I noticed that in build gradle there is a new way to add new dependencies instead of compile there is implementation and instead of testCompile there is testImplementation   Example    implementation  com android support appcompat-v7 25 0 0   testImplementation  junit junit 4 12    instead of   compile  com android support appcompat-v7 25 0 0   testCompile  junit junit 4 12    What s the difference between them and what should I be using

User · Answer

implementation  mostly we use implementation configuration  It hides the internal dependency of the module to its consumer to avoid accidental use of any transitive dependency  hence faster compilation and less recompilation   api  must be used very carefully  since it leaks the to consumer   s compile classpath  hence misusing of api could lead to dependency pollution   compileOnly  when we don   t need any dependency at runtime  since compileOnly dependency won   t become the part of the final build  we will get a smaller build size   runtimeOnly  when we want to change or swap the behaviour of the library at runtime  in final build     I have created a post with an in-depth understanding of each one with Working Example  source code https   medium com  gauraw negi how-gradle-dependency-configurations-work-underhood-e934906752e5

User · Answer

Just by looking at the image from the help pages  it makes a lot of sense  So you have the blue boxes compileClasspath and runtimeClassPath  The compileClasspath is what is required to make a successful build when running gradle build  The libraries that will be present on the classpath when compiling will be all libraries that are configured in your gradle build using either compileOnly or implementation  Then we have the runtimeClasspath and those are all packages that you added using either implementation or runtimeOnly  All those libraries will be added to the final build file  jar  that you deploy on the server  As you also see in the image  if you want a library to be both used for compilation but you also want it added to the build file  then implementation should be used  An example of runtimeOnly can be a database driver  An example of compileOnly can be servlet-api  An example of implementation can be spring-core

User · Answer

This answer will demonstrate the difference between implementation  api  and compile on a project      Let s say I have a project with three Gradle modules    app  an Android application  myandroidlibrary  an Android library  myjavalibrary  a Java library    app has myandroidlibrary as dependencies  myandroidlibrary has myjavalibrary  as dependencies     myjavalibrary has a MySecret class  public class MySecret        public static String getSecret             return  Money             myandroidlibrary has MyAndroidComponent class that manipulate value from MySecret class   public class MyAndroidComponent        private static String component   MySecret getSecret         public static String getComponent             return  My component      component                Lastly  app is only interested in the value from myandroidlibrary  TextView tvHelloWorld   findViewById R id tv hello world   tvHelloWorld setText MyAndroidComponent getComponent         Now  let s talk about dependencies     app need to consume  myandroidlibrary  so in app build gradle use implementation    Note  You can use api compile too  But hold that thought for a moment    dependencies       implementation project   myandroidlibrary               What do you think myandroidlibrary build gradle should look like  Which scope we should use   We have three options   dependencies          Option  1     implementation project   myjavalibrary           Option  2     compile project   myjavalibrary                Option  3     api project   myjavalibrary                       What s the difference between them and what should I be using    Compile or Api  option  2 or  3    If you re using compile or api  Our Android Application now able to access myandroidcomponent dependency  which is a MySecret class   TextView textView   findViewById R id text view   textView setText MyAndroidComponent getComponent        You can access MySecret textView setText MySecret getSecret       Implementation  option  1     If you re using implementation configuration  MySecret is not exposed   TextView textView   findViewById R id text view   textView setText MyAndroidComponent getComponent        You can NOT access MySecret textView setText MySecret getSecret        Won t even compile     So  which configuration you should choose  That really depends on your requirement    If you want to expose dependencies use api or compile    If you don t want to expose dependencies  hiding your internal module  then use implementation   Note   This is just a gist of Gradle configurations  refer to Table 49 1  Java Library plugin - configurations used to declare dependencies for more detailed explanation   The sample project for this answer is available on https   github com aldoKelvianto ImplementationVsCompile

User · Answer

tl dr Just replace   compile with implementation  if you don t need transitivity  or api  if you need transitivity  testCompile with testImplementation debugCompile with debugImplementation androidTestCompile with androidTestImplementation compileOnly is still valid  It was added in 3 0 to replace provided and not compile   provided introduced when Gradle didn t have a configuration name for that use-case and named it after Maven s provided scope    It is one of the breaking changes coming with Android Gradle plugin 3 0 that Google announced at IO17  The compile configuration is now deprecated and should be replaced by implementation or api From the Gradle documentation   dependencies       api  commons-httpclient commons-httpclient 3 1      implementation  org apache commons commons-lang3 3 5     Dependencies appearing in the api configurations will be transitively exposed to consumers of the library  and as such will appear on the compile classpath of consumers  Dependencies found in the implementation configuration will  on the other hand  not be exposed to consumers  and therefore not leak into the consumers  compile classpath  This comes with several benefits   dependencies do not leak into the compile classpath of consumers anymore  so you will never accidentally depend on a transitive dependency faster compilation thanks to reduced classpath size less recompilations when implementation dependencies change  consumers would not need to be recompiled cleaner publishing  when used in conjunction with the new maven-publish plugin  Java libraries produce POM files that distinguish exactly between what is required to compile against the library and what is required to use the library at runtime  in other words  don t mix what is needed to compile the library itself and what is needed to compile against the library    The compile configuration still exists  but should not be used as it will not offer the guarantees that the api and implementation configurations provide    Note  if you are only using a library in your app module -the common case- you won t notice any difference  you will only see the difference if you have a complex project with modules depending on each other  or you are creating a library

User · Answer

Brief Solution  The better approach is to replace all compile dependencies with implementation dependencies  And only where you leak a module   s interface  you should use api  That should cause a lot less recompilation   dependencies            implementation fileTree dir   libs   include      jar               implementation  com android support appcompat-v7 25 4 0           implementation  com android support constraint constraint-layout 1 0 2                             testImplementation  junit junit 4 12           androidTestImplementation  com android support test espresso espresso-core 2 2 2                  exclude group   com android support   module   support-annotations                   Explain More  Before Android Gradle plugin 3 0   we had a big problem which is one code change causes all modules to be recompiled  The root cause for this is that Gradle doesn   t know if you leak the interface of a module through another one or not  After Android Gradle plugin 3 0  the latest Android Gradle plugin now requires you to explicitly define if you leak a module   s interface  Based on that it can make the right choice on what it should recompile  As such the compile dependency has been deprecated and replaced by two new ones   api  you leak the interface of this module through your own interface  meaning exactly the same as the old compile dependency  implementation  you only use this module internally and does not leak it through your interface   So now you can explicitly tell Gradle to recompile a module if the interface of a used module changes or not  Courtesy of Jeroen Mols blog

User · Answer

Since version 5 6 3 Gradle documentation provides simple rules of thumb to identify whether an old compile dependency  or a new one  should be replaced with an implementation or an api dependency    Prefer the implementation configuration over api when possible  This keeps the dependencies off of the consumer   s compilation classpath  In addition  the consumers will immediately fail to compile if any implementation types accidentally leak into the public API  So when should you use the api configuration  An API dependency is one that contains at least one type that is exposed in the library binary interface  often referred to as its ABI  Application Binary Interface   This includes  but is not limited to   types used in super classes or interfaces types used in public method parameters  including generic parameter types  where public is something that is visible to compilers  I e    public  protected and package private members in the Java world  types used in public fields public annotation types  By contrast  any type that is used in the following list is irrelevant to the ABI  and therefore should be declared as an implementation dependency   types exclusively used in method bodies types exclusively used in private members types exclusively found in internal classes  future versions of Gradle will let you declare which packages belong to the public API

User · Answer

-------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    Name                 Role                   Consumable    Resolveable    Description                                -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    api                  Declaring                   no            no        This is where you should declare                                 API                                                 dependencies which are transitively                              dependencies                                        exported to consumers  for compile         -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    implementation       Declaring                   no            no        This is where you should                                         implementation                                      declare dependencies which are                                   dependencies                                        purely internal and not                                                                                              meant to be exposed to consumers           -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    compileOnly          Declaring compile          yes            yes       This is where you should                                         only                                                declare dependencies                                             dependencies                                        which are only required                                                                                              at compile time  but should                                                                                          not leak into the runtime                                                                                            This typically includes dependencies                                                                                 which are shaded when found at runtime     -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    runtimeOnly          Declaring                   no            no        This is where you should                                         runtime                                             declare dependencies which                                       dependencies                                        are only required at runtime                                                                                         and not at compile time                    -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    testImplementation   Test dependencies           no            no        This is where you                                                                                                    should declare dependencies                                                                                          which are used to compile tests            -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    testCompileOnly      Declaring test             yes            yes       This is where you should                                         compile only                                        declare dependencies                                             dependencies                                        which are only required                                                                                              at test compile time                                                                                                 but should not leak into the runtime                                                                                 This typically includes dependencies                                                                                 which are shaded when found at runtime     -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------    testRuntimeOnly      Declaring test              no            no        This is where you should                                         runtime dependencies                                declare dependencies which                                                                                           are only required at test                                                                                            runtime  and not at test compile time      -------------------- ---------------------- ------------- -------------- -----------------------------------------

User · Answer

The brief difference in layman s term is    If you are working on an interface or module that provides support to other modules by exposing the members of the stated dependency you should be using  api   If you are making an application or module that is going to implement or use the stated dependency internally  use  implementation    compile  worked same as  api   however  if you are only implementing or using any library   implementation  will work better and save you resources    read the answer by  aldok for a comprehensive example

User · Answer

Compile configuration was deprecated and should be replaced by implementation or api   You can read the docs at https   docs gradle org current userguide java library plugin html sec java library separation   The brief part being-     The key difference between the standard Java plugin and the Java   Library plugin is that the latter introduces the concept of an API   exposed to consumers  A library is a Java component meant to be   consumed by other components  It s a very common use case in   multi-project builds  but also as soon as you have external   dependencies       The plugin exposes two configurations that can be used to declare   dependencies  api and implementation  The api configuration should be   used to declare dependencies which are exported by the library API    whereas the implementation configuration should be used to declare   dependencies which are internal to the component    For further explanation refer to this image

User · Answer

Gradle 3 0 introduced next changes   compile - gt  api api keyword is the same as deprecated compile which expose this dependency for all levels  compile - gt  implementation Is preferable way because has some advantages  implementation expose dependency only for one level up at build time  the dependency is available at runtime   As a result you have a faster build no need to recompile consumers which are higher then 1 level up   provided - gt  compileOnly This dependency is available only in compile time the dependency is not available at runtime   This dependency can not be transitive and be  aar  It can be used with compile time annotation processor and allows you to reduce a final output file  compile - gt  annotationProcessor Very similar to compileOnly but also guarantees that transitive dependency are not visible for consumer  apk - gt  runtimeOnly Dependency is not available in compile time but available at runtime     POM dependency type

[gradle] What's the difference between implementation and compile in Gradle?

Examples related to gradle

Examples related to build.gradle

Examples related to dependency-management

Examples related to gradle-plugin

Examples related to transitive-dependency