[sql] Function vs. Stored Procedure in SQL Server

I've been learning Functions and Stored Procedure for quite a while but I don't know why and when I should use a function or a stored procedure. They look same to me, maybe because I am kinda newbie about that.

Can some one tell me why?

To decide on when to use what the following points might help-

1. Stored procedures can't return a table variable where as function can do that.

2. You can use stored procedures to alter the server environment parameters where as using functions you can't.

cheers

Here's a practical reason to prefer functions over stored procedures. If you have a stored procedure that needs the results of another stored procedure, you have to use an insert-exec statement. This means that you have to create a temp table and use an exec statement to insert the results of the stored procedure into the temp table. It's messy. One problem with this is that insert-execs cannot be nested.

If you're stuck with stored procedures that call other stored procedures, you may run into this. If the nested stored procedure simply returns a dataset, it can be replaced with a table-valued function and you'll no longer get this error.

(this is yet another reason we should keep business logic out of the database)

Differences between stored procedures and user-defined functions:

• Stored procedures cannot be used in Select statements.
• Stored procedures support Deferred Name Resolution.
• Stored procedures are generally used for performing business logic.
• Stored procedures can return any datatype.
• Stored procedures can accept greater numbers of input parameter than user defined functions. Stored procedures can have up to 21,000 input parameters.
• Stored procedures can execute Dynamic SQL.
• Stored procedures support error handling.
• Non-deterministic functions can be used in stored procedures.

• User-defined functions can be used in Select statements.
• User-defined functions do not support Deferred Name Resolution.
• User-defined functions are generally used for computations.
• User-defined functions should return a value.
• User-defined functions cannot return Images.
• User-defined functions accept smaller numbers of input parameters than stored procedures. UDFs can have up to 1,023 input parameters.
• Temporary tables cannot be used in user-defined functions.
• User-defined functions cannot execute Dynamic SQL.
• User-defined functions do not support error handling. RAISEERROR OR @@ERROR are not allowed in UDFs.
• Non-deterministic functions cannot be used in UDFs. For example, GETDATE() cannot be used in UDFs.

Write a user-defined function when you want to compute and return a value for use in other SQL statements; write a stored procedure when you want instead is to group a possibly-complex set of SQL statements. These are two pretty different use cases, after all!

In SQL Server, functions and stored procedure are two different types of entities.

Function: In SQL Server database, the functions are used to perform some actions and the action returns a result immediately. Functions are two types:

1. System defined

2. User defined

Stored Procedures: In SQL Server, the stored procedures are stored in server and it can be return zero, single and multiple values. Stored Procedures are two types:

1. System Stored Procedures
2. User Defined Procedures

SQL Server functions, like cursors, are meant to be used as your last weapon! They do have performance issues and therefore using a table-valued function should be avoided as much as possible. Talking about performance is talking about a table with more than 1,000,000 records hosted on a server on a middle-class hardware; otherwise you don't need to worry about the performance hit caused by the functions.

1. Never use a function to return a result-set to an external code (like ADO.Net)
2. Use views/stored procs combination as much as possible. you can recover from future grow-performance issues using the suggestions DTA (Database Tuning Adviser) would give you (like indexed views and statistics) --sometimes!

for further reference see: http://databases.aspfaq.com/database/should-i-use-a-view-a-stored-procedure-or-a-user-defined-function.html

a User Defined Function is an important tool available to a sql server programmer. You can use it inline in a SQL statement like so

SELECT a, lookupValue(b), c FROM customers 

where lookupValue will be an UDF. This kind of functionality is not possible when using a stored procedure. At the same time you cannot do certain things inside a UDF. The basic thing to remember here is that UDF's:

• cannot create permanent changes
• cannot change data

a stored procedure can do those things.

For me the inline usage of a UDF is the most important usage of a UDF.

User Defined Function.

1. Function must return a value.
2. Will allow only Select statements, it will not allow us to use DML statements.
3. It will allow only input parameters, doesn't support output parameters.
4. It will not allow us to use try-catch blocks.
5. Transactions are not allowed within functions.
6. We can use only table variables, it will not allow using temporary tables.
7. Stored Procedures can't be called from a function.
8. Functions can be called from a select statement.
9. A UDF can be used in join clause as a result set.

Stored Procedure

1. Stored Procedure may or not return values.
2. Can have select statements as well as DML statements such as insert, update, delete and so on
3. It can have both input and output parameters.
4. For exception handling we can use try catch blocks.
5. Can use transactions within Stored Procedures.
6. Can use both table variables as well as temporary table in it.
7. Stored Procedures can call functions.
8. Procedures can't be called from Select/Where/Having and so on statements. Execute/Exec statement can be used to call/execute Stored Procedure.
9. Procedures can't be used in Join clause

Mssql stored procedure vs function:

Basic Difference

Function must return a value but in Stored Procedure it is optional( Procedure can return zero or n values).

Functions can have only input parameters for it whereas Procedures can have input/output parameters .

Function takes one input parameter it is mandatory but Stored Procedure may take o to n input parameters..

Functions can be called from Procedure whereas Procedures cannot be called from Function.

Advance Difference

Procedure allows SELECT as well as DML(INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE) statement in it whereas Function allows only SELECT statement in it.

Procedures can not be utilized in a SELECT statement whereas Function can be embedded in a SELECT statement.

Stored Procedures cannot be used in the SQL statements anywhere in the WHERE/HAVING/SELECT section whereas Function can be.

Functions that return tables can be treated as another rowset. This can be used in JOINs with other tables.

Inline Function can be though of as views that take parameters and can be used in JOINs and other Rowset operations.

Exception can be handled by try-catch block in a Procedure whereas try-catch block cannot be used in a Function.

We can go for Transaction Management in Procedure whereas we can't go in Function.

source

Functions and stored procedures serve separate purposes. Although it's not the best analogy, functions can be viewed literally as any other function you'd use in any programming language, but stored procs are more like individual programs or a batch script.

Functions normally have an output and optionally inputs. The output can then be used as the input to another function (a SQL Server built-in such as DATEDIFF, LEN, etc) or as a predicate to a SQL Query - e.g., SELECT a, b, dbo.MyFunction(c) FROM table or SELECT a, b, c FROM table WHERE a = dbo.MyFunc(c).

Stored procs are used to bind SQL queries together in a transaction, and interface with the outside world. Frameworks such as ADO.NET, etc. can't call a function directly, but they can call a stored proc directly.

Functions do have a hidden danger though: they can be misused and cause rather nasty performance issues: consider this query:

SELECT * FROM dbo.MyTable WHERE col1 = dbo.MyFunction(col2)

Where MyFunction is declared as:

CREATE FUNCTION MyFunction (@someValue INTEGER) RETURNS INTEGER
AS
BEGIN
   DECLARE @retval INTEGER

   SELECT localValue 
      FROM dbo.localToNationalMapTable
      WHERE nationalValue = @someValue

   RETURN @retval
END

What happens here is that the function MyFunction is called for every row in the table MyTable. If MyTable has 1000 rows, then that's another 1000 ad-hoc queries against the database. Similarly, if the function is called when specified in the column spec, then the function will be called for each row returned by the SELECT.

So you do need to be careful writing functions. If you do SELECT from a table in a function, you need to ask yourself whether it can be better performed with a JOIN in the parent stored proc or some other SQL construct (such as CASE ... WHEN ... ELSE ... END).

Stored procedure:

• Is like a miniature program in SQL Server.
• Can be as simple as a select statement, or as complex as a long script that adds, deletes, updates, and/or reads data from multiple tables in a database.
• (Can implement loops and cursors, which both allow you to work with smaller results or row by row operations on data.)
• Should be called using EXEC or EXECUTE statement.
• Returns table variables, but we can't use OUT parameter.
• Supports transactions.

Function:

• Can not be used to update, delete, or add records to the database.
• Simply returns a single value or a table value.

• Can only be used to select records. However, it can be called very easily from within standard SQL, such as:

  SELECT dbo.functionname('Parameter1')
  

  or

  SELECT Name, dbo.Functionname('Parameter1') FROM sysObjects
  

• For simple reusable select operations, functions can simplify code. Just be wary of using JOIN clauses in your functions. If your function has a JOIN clause and you call it from another select statement that returns multiple results, that function call will JOIN those tables together for each line returned in the result set. So though they can be helpful in simplifying some logic, they can also be a performance bottleneck if they're not used properly.

• Returns the values using OUT parameter.
• Does not support transactions.

              STORE PROCEDURE                 FUNCTION (USER DEFINED FUNCTION)    
 * Procedure can return 0, single or   | * Function can return only single value   
   multiple values.                    |
                                       |
 * Procedure can have input, output    | * Function  can have only input 
   parameters.                         |   parameters.         
                                       |
 * Procedure cannot be called from     | * Functions can be called from 
   function.                           |   procedure.
                                       |
 * Procedure allows select as well as  | * Function allows only select statement 
   DML statement in it.                |   in it.
                                       |
 * Exception can be handled by         | * Try-catch block cannot be used in a 
   try-catch block in a procedure.     |   function.
                                       |
 * We can go for transaction management| * We can not go for transaction 
   in procedure.                       |   management in function.
                                       |
 * Procedure cannot be utilized in a   | * Function can be embedded in a select 
   select statement                    |   statement.
                                       |
 * Procedure can affect the state      | * Function can not affect the state 
   of database means it can perform    |   of database means it can not    
   CRUD operation on database.         |   perform CRUD operation on 
                                       |   database. 
                                       |
 * Procedure can use temporary tables. | * Function can not use 
                                       |   temporary tables. 
                                       |
 * Procedure can alter the server      | * Function can not alter the  
   environment parameters.             |   environment parameters.
                                       |   
 * Procedure can use when we want      | * Function can use when we want
   instead is to group a possibly-     |   to compute and return a value
   complex set of SQL statements.      |   for use in other SQL 
                                       |   statements.

Generally using stored procedures is better for perfomances. For example in previous versions of SQL Server if you put the function in JOIN condition the cardinality estimate is 1 (before SQL 2012) and 100 (after SQL 2012 and before of SQL 2017) and the engine can generate a bad execution plan.

Also if you put it in WHERE clause the SQL Engine can generate a bad execution plan.

With SQL 2017 Microsoft introduced the feature called interleaved execution in order to produce a more accurate estimate but the stored procedure remains the best solution.

For more details look the following article of Joe Sack https://techcommunity.microsoft.com/t5/sql-server/introducing-interleaved-execution-for-multi-statement-table/ba-p/385417

The difference between SP and UDF is listed below:

I realize this is a very old question, but I don't see one crucial aspect mentioned in any of the answers: inlining into query plan.

Functions can be...

1. Scalar:

   CREATE FUNCTION ... RETURNS scalar_type AS BEGIN ... END

2. Multi-statement table-valued:

   CREATE FUNCTION ... RETURNS @r TABLE(...) AS BEGIN ... END

3. Inline table-valued:

   CREATE FUNCTION ... RETURNS TABLE AS RETURN SELECT ...

The third kind (inline table-valued) are treated by the query optimizer essentially as (parametrized) views, which means that referencing the function from your query is similar to copy-pasting the function's SQL body (without actually copy-pasting), leading to the following benefits:

• The query planner can optimize the inline function's execution just as it would any other sub-query (e.g. eliminate unused columns, push predicates down, pick different JOIN strategies etc.).
• Combining several inline function doesn't require materializing the result from the first one before feeding it to the next.

The above can lead to potentially significant performance savings, especially when combining multiple levels of functions.

NOTE: Looks like SQL Server 2019 will introduce some form of scalar function inlining as well.

Stored Procedures are used as scripts. They run a series of commands for you and you can schedule them to run at certain times. Usually runs multiples DML statements like INSERT, UPDATE, DELETE, etc. or even SELECT.

Functions are used as methods. You pass it something and it returns a result. Should be small and fast - does it on the fly. Usually used in a SELECT statement.

Start with functions that return a single value. The nice thing is you can put frequently used code into a function and return them as a column in a result set.

Then, you might use a function for a parameterized list of cities. dbo.GetCitiesIn("NY") That returns a table that can be used as a join.

It's a way of organizing code. Knowing when something is reusable and when it is a waste of time is something only gained through trial and error and experience.

Also, functions are a good idea in SQL Server. They are faster and can be quite powerful. Inline and direct selects. Careful not to overuse.

• Functions can be used in a select statement where as procedures cannot.

• Stored procedure takes both input and output parameters but Functions takes only input parameters.

• Functions cannot return values of type text, ntext, image & timestamps where as procedures can.

• Functions can be used as user defined datatypes in create table but procedures cannot.

***Eg:-create table <tablename>(name varchar(10),salary getsal(name))

Here getsal is a user defined function which returns a salary type, when table is created no storage is allotted for salary type, and getsal function is also not executed, But when we are fetching some values from this table, getsal function get’s executed and the return Type is returned as the result set.

• It is mandatory for Function to return a value while it is not for stored procedure.
• Select statements only accepted in UDF while DML statements not required.
• Stored procedure accepts any statements as well as DML statements.
• UDF only allows inputs and not outputs.
• Stored procedure allows for both inputs and outputs.
• Catch blocks cannot be used in UDF but can be used in stored procedure.
• No transactions allowed in functions in UDF but in stored procedure they are allowed.
• Only table variables can be used in UDF and not temporary tables.
• Stored procedure allows for both table variables and temporary tables.
• UDF does not allow stored procedures to be called from functions while stored procedures allow calling of functions.
• UDF is used in join clause while stored procedures cannot be used in join clause.
• Stored procedure will always allow for return to zero. UDF, on the contrary, has values that must come - back to a predetermined point.