[java] How to use ArgumentCaptor for stubbing?

In Mockito documentation and javadocs it says

It is recommended to use ArgumentCaptor with verification but not with stubbing.

but I don't understand how ArgumentCaptor can be used for stubbing. Can someone explain the above statement and show how ArgumentCaptor can be used for stubbing or provide a link that shows how it can be done?

This question is related to java unit-testing junit mockito

The answer is


Hypothetically, if search landed you on this question then you probably want this:

doReturn(someReturn).when(someObject).doSomething(argThat(argument -> argument.getName().equals("Bob")));

Why? Because like me you value time and you are not going to implement .equals just for the sake of the single test scenario.

And 99 % of tests fall apart with null returned from Mock and in a reasonable design you would avoid return null at all costs, use Optional or move to Kotlin. This implies that verify does not need to be used that often and ArgumentCaptors are just too tedious to write.


The line

when(someObject.doSomething(argumentCaptor.capture())).thenReturn(true);

would do the same as

when(someObject.doSomething(Matchers.any())).thenReturn(true);

So, using argumentCaptor.capture() when stubbing has no added value. Using Matchers.any() shows better what really happens and therefor is better for readability. With argumentCaptor.capture(), you can't read what arguments are really matched. And instead of using any(), you can use more specific matchers when you have more information (class of the expected argument), to improve your test.

And another problem: If using argumentCaptor.capture() when stubbing it becomes unclear how many values you should expect to be captured after verification. We want to capture a value during verification, not during stubbing because at that point there is no value to capture yet. So what does the argument captors capture method capture during stubbing? It capture anything because there is nothing to be captured yet. I consider it to be undefined behavior and I don't want to use undefined behavior.


Examples related to java

Under what circumstances can I call findViewById with an Options Menu / Action Bar item? How much should a function trust another function How to implement a simple scenario the OO way Two constructors How do I get some variable from another class in Java? this in equals method How to split a string in two and store it in a field How to do perspective fixing? String index out of range: 4 My eclipse won't open, i download the bundle pack it keeps saying error log

Examples related to unit-testing

Deprecated Gradle features were used in this build, making it incompatible with Gradle 5.0 How to test the type of a thrown exception in Jest Unit Tests not discovered in Visual Studio 2017 Class Not Found: Empty Test Suite in IntelliJ Angular 2 Unit Tests: Cannot find name 'describe' Enzyme - How to access and set <input> value? Mocking HttpClient in unit tests Example of Mockito's argumentCaptor How to write unit testing for Angular / TypeScript for private methods with Jasmine Why is the Visual Studio 2015/2017/2019 Test Runner not discovering my xUnit v2 tests

Examples related to junit

Eclipse No tests found using JUnit 5 caused by NoClassDefFoundError for LauncherFactory How to resolve Unneccessary Stubbing exception JUnit 5: How to assert an exception is thrown? How do I mock a REST template exchange? Class Not Found: Empty Test Suite in IntelliJ Unable to find a @SpringBootConfiguration when doing a JpaTest Failed to load ApplicationContext (with annotation) Example of Mockito's argumentCaptor Mockito - NullpointerException when stubbing Method Spring jUnit Testing properties file

Examples related to mockito

How to resolve Unneccessary Stubbing exception How do I mock a REST template exchange? Mockito : doAnswer Vs thenReturn Example of Mockito's argumentCaptor Mockito: Mock private field initialization Mockito - NullpointerException when stubbing Method Usages of doThrow() doAnswer() doNothing() and doReturn() in mockito Java verify void method calls n times with Mockito Unfinished Stubbing Detected in Mockito How do I mock an autowired @Value field in Spring with Mockito?