Maximum size for a SQL Server Query IN clause Is there a Better Approach

Question

Possible Duplicate    T-SQL WHERE col IN   hellip       What is the maximum size for a SQL Server query     of characters   Max size for an IN clause  I think I saw something about Oracle having a 1000 item limit but you could get around this with ANDing 2 INs together  Similar issue in SQL Server   UPDATE So what would be the best approach if I need to take say 1000 GUIDs from another system  Non Relational Database  and do a  JOIN in code  against the SQL Server  Is it to submit the list of 1000 GUIDs to an IN clause  Or is there another technique that works more efficiently   I haven t tested this but I wonder if I could submit the GUIDs as an XML doc  For example    lt guids gt       lt guid gt 809674df-1c22-46eb-bf9a-33dc78beb44a lt  guid gt       lt guid gt 257f537f-9c6b-4f14-a90c-ee613b4287f3 lt  guid gt   lt  guids gt    and then do some kind of XQuery JOIN against the Doc and the Table  Less efficient than 1000 item IN clause

User · Answer

Per batch  65536   Network Packet Size which is 4k so 256 MB  However  IN will stop way before that but it s not precise   You end up with memory errors but I can t recall the exact error  A huge IN will be inefficient anyway   Edit  Remus reminded me  the error is about  stack size

User · Answer

The SQL Server Maximums are disclosed http   msdn microsoft com en-us library ms143432 aspx  this is the 2008 version   A SQL Query can be a varchar max  but is shown as limited to 65 536   Network Packet size  but even then what is most likely to trip you up is the 2100 parameters per query  If SQL chooses to parameterize the literal values in the in clause  I would think you would hit that limit first  but I havn t tested it   Edit   Test it  even under forced parameteriztion it survived - I knocked up a quick test and had it executing with 30k items within the In clause   SQL Server 2005   At 100k items  it took some time then dropped with      Msg 8623  Level 16  State 1  Line 1   The query processor ran out of internal resources and could not produce a query plan  This is a rare event and only expected for extremely complex queries or queries that reference a very large number of tables or partitions  Please simplify the query  If you believe you have received this message in error  contact Customer Support Services for more information    So 30k is possible  but just because you can do it - does not mean you should     Edit   Continued due to additional question   50k worked  but 60k dropped out  so somewhere in there on my test rig btw   In terms of how to do that join of the values without using a large in clause  personally I would create a temp table  insert the values into that temp table  index it and then use it in a join  giving it the best opportunities to optimse the joins   Generating the index on the temp table will create stats for it  which will help the optimiser as a general rule  although 1000 GUIDs will not exactly find stats too useful

User · Answer

Can you load the GUIDs into a scratch table then do a          WHERE var IN SELECT guid FROM  scratchtable

User · Answer

Every SQL batch has to fit in the Batch Size Limit  65 536   Network Packet Size   Other than that  your query is limited by runtime conditions  It will usually run out of stack size because x IN  a b c  is nothing but x a OR x b OR x c which creates an expression tree similar to x a OR  x b OR  x c    so it gets very deep with a large number of OR  SQL 7 would hit a SO at about 10k values in the IN  but nowdays stacks are much deeper  because of x64   so it can go pretty deep   Update  You already found Erland s article on the topic of passing lists arrays to SQL Server  With SQL 2008 you also have Table Valued Parameters which allow you to pass an entire DataTable as a single table type parameter and join on it    XML and XPath is another viable solution   SELECT     FROM Table JOIN      SELECT x value N    N uniqueidentifier   as guid    FROM  values nodes N  guids guid   t x   as guids  ON Table guid   guids guid

[sql] Maximum size for a SQL Server Query? IN clause? Is there a Better Approach

Examples related to sql

Examples related to sql-server

Examples related to tsql

Examples related to limits