[vb.net] Declaring and initializing a string array in VB.NET

I was trying to return an array of strings from a function and got surprised by an error.

I would have expected this to work, but it produces an error:

Public Function TestError() As String()
    Return {"foo", "bar"}
End Function

This works:

Public Function TestOK() As String()
    Dim ar As String() = {"foo", "bar"}
    Return ar
End Function

As does:

Public Function TestOK() As String()
    Return New String() {"foo", "bar"}
End Function

I guess I'm unclear on the meaning of the {}'s - is there a way to implicitly return a string array without explicitly creating and initializing it?

This question is related to vb.net arrays data-structures

The answer is


Array initializer support for type inference were changed in Visual Basic 10 vs Visual Basic 9.

In previous version of VB it was required to put empty parens to signify an array. Also, it would define the array as object array unless otherwise was stated:

' Integer array
Dim i as Integer() = {1, 2, 3, 4} 

' Object array
Dim o() = {1, 2, 3} 

Check more info:

Visual Basic 2010 Breaking Changes

Collection and Array Initializers in Visual Basic 2010


Public Function TestError() As String()
     Return {"foo", "bar"}
End Function

Works fine for me and should work for you, but you may need allow using implicit declarations in your project. I believe this is turning off Options strict in the Compile section of the program settings.

Since you are using VS 2008 (VB.NET 9.0) you have to declare create the new instance

New String() {"foo", "Bar"}


I believe you need to specify "Option Infer On" for this to work.

Option Infer allows the compiler to make a guess at what is being represented by your code, thus it will guess that {"stuff"} is an array of strings. With "Option Infer Off", {"stuff"} won't have any type assigned to it, ever, and so it will always fail, without a type specifier.

Option Infer is, I think On by default in new projects, but Off by default when you migrate from earlier frameworks up to 3.5.

Opinion incoming:

Also, you mention that you've got "Option Explicit Off". Please don't do this.

Setting "Option Explicit Off" means that you don't ever have to declare variables. This means that the following code will silently and invisibly create the variable "Y":

Dim X as Integer
Y = 3

This is horrible, mad, and wrong. It creates variables when you make typos. I keep hoping that they'll remove it from the language.


Examples related to vb.net

How to get parameter value for date/time column from empty MaskedTextBox HTTP 415 unsupported media type error when calling Web API 2 endpoint variable is not declared it may be inaccessible due to its protection level Differences Between vbLf, vbCrLf & vbCr Constants Simple working Example of json.net in VB.net How to open up a form from another form in VB.NET? Delete a row in DataGridView Control in VB.NET How to get cell value from DataGridView in VB.Net? Set default format of datetimepicker as dd-MM-yyyy How to configure SMTP settings in web.config

Examples related to arrays

PHP array value passes to next row Use NSInteger as array index How do I show a message in the foreach loop? Objects are not valid as a React child. If you meant to render a collection of children, use an array instead Iterating over arrays in Python 3 Best way to "push" into C# array Sort Array of object by object field in Angular 6 Checking for duplicate strings in JavaScript array what does numpy ndarray shape do? How to round a numpy array?

Examples related to data-structures

Program to find largest and second largest number in array golang why don't we have a set datastructure How to initialize a vector with fixed length in R C compiling - "undefined reference to"? List of all unique characters in a string? Binary Search Tree - Java Implementation How to clone object in C++ ? Or Is there another solution? How to check queue length in Python Difference between "Complete binary tree", "strict binary tree","full binary Tree"? Write code to convert given number into words (eg 1234 as input should output one thousand two hundred and thirty four)