Difference between on-heap and off-heap

Question

Ehcache talks about on-heap and off-heap memory  What is the difference  What JVM args are used to configure them

User · Answer

In short picture  pic credits  Detailed picture  pic credits

User · Answer

The heap is the place in memory where your dynamically allocated objects live  If you used new then it s on the heap  That s as opposed to stack space  which is where the function stack lives  If you have a local variable then that reference is on the stack  Java s heap is subject to garbage collection and the objects are usable directly   EHCache s off-heap storage takes your regular object off the heap  serializes it  and stores it as bytes in a chunk of memory that EHCache manages  It s like storing it to disk but it s still in RAM  The objects are not directly usable in this state  they have to be deserialized first  Also not subject to garbage collection

User · Answer

Not 100   however  it sounds like the heap is an object or set of allocated space  on RAM  that is built into the functionality of the code either Java itself or more likely functionality from ehcache itself  and the off-heap Ram is there own system as well  however  it sounds like this is one magnitude slower as it is not as organized  meaning it may not use a heap  meaning one long set of space of ram   and instead uses different address spaces likely making it slightly less efficient   Then of course the next tier lower is hard-drive space itself   I don t use ehcache  so you may not want to trust me  but that what is what I gathered from their documentation

User · Answer

from http   code google com p fast-serialization wiki QuickStartHeapOff  What is Heap-Offloading    Usually all non-temporary objects you allocate are managed by java s garbage collector  Although the VM does a decent job doing garbage collection  at a certain point the VM has to do a so called  Full GC   A full GC involves scanning the complete allocated Heap  which means GC pauses slowdowns are proportional to an applications heap size  So don t trust any person telling you  Memory is Cheap   In java memory consumtion hurts performance  Additionally you may get notable pauses using heap sizes   1 Gb  This can be nasty if you have any near-real-time stuff going on  in a cluster or grid a java process might get unresponsive and get dropped from the cluster   However todays server applications  frequently built on top of bloaty frameworks  -    easily require heaps far beyond 4Gb   One solution to these memory requirements  is to  offload  parts of the objects to the non-java heap  directly allocated from the OS   Fortunately java nio provides classes to directly allocate read and write  unmanaged  chunks of memory  even memory mapped files    So one can allocate large amounts of  unmanaged  memory and use this to save objects there  In order to save arbitrary objects into unmanaged memory  the most viable solution is the use of Serialization  This means the application serializes objects into the offheap memory  later on the object can be read using deserialization   The heap size managed by the java VM can be kept small  so GC pauses are in the millis  everybody is happy  job done   It is clear  that the performance of such an off heap buffer depends mostly on the performance of the serialization implementation  Good news  for some reason FST-serialization is pretty fast  -    Sample usage scenarios    Session cache in a server application  Use a memory mapped file to store gigabytes of  inactive  user sessions  Once the user logs into your application  you can quickly access user-related data without having to deal with a database  Caching of computational results  queries  html pages       only applicable if computation is slower than deserializing the result object ofc   very simple and fast persistance using memory mapped files   Edit  For some scenarios one might choose more sophisticated Garbage Collection algorithms such as ConcurrentMarkAndSweep or G1 to support larger heaps  but this also has its limits beyond 16GB heaps   There is also a commercial JVM with improved  pauseless  GC  Azul  available

User · Answer

The on-heap store refers to objects that will be present in the Java heap  and also subject to GC   On the other hand  the off-heap store refers to  serialized  objects that are managed by EHCache  but stored outside the heap  and also not subject to GC   As the off-heap store continues to be managed in memory  it is slightly slower than the on-heap store  but still faster than the disk store   The internal details involved in management and usage of the off-heap store aren t very evident in the link posted in the question  so it would be wise to check out the details of Terracotta BigMemory  which is used to manage the off-disk store  BigMemory  the off-heap store  is to be used to avoid the overhead of GC on a heap that is several Megabytes or Gigabytes large  BigMemory uses the memory address space of the JVM process  via direct ByteBuffers that are not subject to GC unlike other native Java objects

User · Answer

The JVM doesn t know anything about off-heap memory  Ehcache implements an on-disk cache as well as an in-memory cache

[java] Difference between "on-heap" and "off-heap"

In short picture

Detailed picture

Examples related to java

Examples related to memory

Examples related to heap

Examples related to ehcache