[c++] Choice between vector::resize() and vector::reserve()

I am pre-allocating some memory to my a vector member variable. Below code is minimal part

class A {
  vector<string> t_Names;
public:
  A () : t_Names(1000) {}
};

Now at some point of time, if the t_Names.size() equals 1000. I am intending to increase the size by 100. Then if it reaches 1100, again increase by 100 and so on.

My question is, what to choose between vector::resize() and vector::reserve(). Is there any better choice in this kind of scenario ?

Edit: I have sort of precise estimate for the t_Names. I estimate it to be around 700 to 800. However in certain (seldom) situations, it can grow more than 1000.

reserve when you do not want the objects to be initialized when reserved. also, you may prefer to logically differentiate and track its count versus its use count when you resize. so there is a behavioral difference in the interface - the vector will represent the same number of elements when reserved, and will be 100 elements larger when resized in your scenario.

Is there any better choice in this kind of scenario?

it depends entirely on your aims when fighting the default behavior. some people will favor customized allocators -- but we really need a better idea of what it is you are attempting to solve in your program to advise you well.

fwiw, many vector implementations will simply double the allocated element count when they must grow - are you trying to minimize peak allocation sizes or are you trying to reserve enough space for some lock free program or something else?

resize() not only allocates memory, it also creates as many instances as the desired size which you pass to resize() as argument. But reserve() only allocates memory, it doesn't create instances. That is,

std::vector<int> v1;
v1.resize(1000); //allocation + instance creation
cout <<(v1.size() == 1000)<< endl;   //prints 1
cout <<(v1.capacity()==1000)<< endl; //prints 1

std::vector<int> v2;
v2.reserve(1000); //only allocation
cout <<(v2.size() == 1000)<< endl;   //prints 0
cout <<(v2.capacity()==1000)<< endl; //prints 1

Output (online demo):

1
1
0
1

So resize() may not be desirable, if you don't want the default-created objects. It will be slow as well. Besides, if you push_back() new elements to it, the size() of the vector will further increase by allocating new memory (which also means moving the existing elements to the newly allocated memory space). If you have used reserve() at the start to ensure there is already enough allocated memory, the size() of the vector will increase when you push_back() to it, but it will not allocate new memory again until it runs out of the space you reserved for it.

From your description, it looks like that you want to "reserve" the allocated storage space of vector t_Names.

Take note that resize initialize the newly allocated vector where reserve just allocates but does not construct. Hence, 'reserve' is much faster than 'resize'

You can refer to the documentation regarding the difference of resize and reserve