Use this : -- SQL Server 2008 or later
SELECT U.*
FROM USERS AS U
Inner Join (
SELECT
EMail, [Status]
FROM
(
Values
('email1', 'Exist'),
('email2', 'Exist'),
('email3', 'Not Exist'),
('email4', 'Exist')
)AS TempTableName (EMail, [Status])
Where TempTableName.EMail IN ('email1','email2','email3')
) As TMP ON U.EMail = TMP.EMail