As long as your List is a concrete class, you can simply call the contains() method as long as you have implemented your equals() method on MyItem.
// given
// some input ... you to complete
// when
List<MyItems> results = service.getMyItems();
// then
assertTrue(results.contains(new MyItem("foo")));
assertTrue(results.contains(new MyItem("bar")));
Assumes you have implemented a constructor that accepts the values you want to assert on. I realise this isn't on a single line, but it's useful to know which value is missing rather than checking both at once.