What you have should work, unless ${STATUS}
is empty. It would probably be better to do:
if ! [ "${STATUS}" -eq 200 ] 2> /dev/null && [ "${STRING}" != "${VALUE}" ]; then
or
if [ "${STATUS}" != 200 ] && [ "${STRING}" != "${VALUE}" ]; then
It's hard to say, since you haven't shown us exactly what is going wrong with your script.
Personal opinion: never use [[
. It suppresses important error messages and is not portable to different shells.