Try the following:
=IF(OR(E2="in play",E2="pre play",E2="complete",E2="suspended"),
IF(E2="in play",IF(F2="closed",3,IF(F2="suspended",2,IF(ISBLANK(F2),1,-2))),
IF(E2="pre play",IF(ISBLANK(F2),-1,-2),IF(E2="completed",IF(F2="closed",2,-2),
IF(E2="suspended",IF(ISBLANK(F2),3,-2))))),-2)