The for
attribute associates the label with a control element, as defined in the description of label
in the HTML 4.01 spec. This implies, among other things, that when the label
element receives focus (e.g. by being clicked on), it passes the focus on to its associated control. The association between a label and a control may also be used by speech-based user agents, which may give the user a way to ask what the associated label is, when dealing with a control. (The association may not be as obvious as in visual rendering.)
In the first example in the question (without the for
), the use of label
markup has no logical or functional implication – it’s useless, unless you do something with it in CSS or JavaScript.
HTML specifications do not make it mandatory to associate labels with controls, but Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.0 do. This is described in the technical document H44: Using label elements to associate text labels with form controls, which also explains that the implicit association (by nesting e.g. input
inside label
) is not as widely supported as the explicit association via for
and id
attributes,