[excel] Extracting the top 5 maximum values in excel

To my mind the case for a PT (as @Nathan Fisher) is a 'no brainer', but I would add a column to facilitate ordering by rank (up or down):

SO18528624 first example

OPS is entered as VALUES (Sum of) twice so I have renamed the column labels to make clearer which is which. The PT is in a different sheet from the data but could be in the same sheet.

Rank is set with a right click on a data point selected in that column and Show Values As... and Rank Largest to Smallest (there are other options) with the Base field as Player and the filter is a Value Filters, Top 10... one:

SO18528624 second example

Once in a PT the power of that feature can very easily be applied to view the data in many other ways, with no change of formula (there isn't one!).

In the case of a tie for the last position included in the filter both results are included (Top 5 would show six or more results). A tie for top rank between just two players would show as 1 1 3 4 5 for Top 5.