What just hit me, coming from Ruby, is that a so-called class method and a so-called instance method is just a function with semantic meaning applied to its first parameter, which is silently passed when the function is called as a method of an object (i.e. obj.meth()).
Normally that object must be an instance but the @classmethod method decorator changes the rules to pass a class. You can call a class method on an instance (it's just a function) - the first argument will be its class.
Because it's just a function, it can only be declared once in any given scope (i.e. class definition). If follows therefore, as a surprise to a Rubyist, that you can't have a class method and an instance method with the same name.
Consider this:
class Foo():
def foo(x):
print(x)
You can call foo on an instance
Foo().foo()
<__main__.Foo instance at 0x7f4dd3e3bc20>
But not on a class:
Foo.foo()
Traceback (most recent call last):
File "<stdin>", line 1, in <module>
TypeError: unbound method foo() must be called with Foo instance as first argument (got nothing instead)
Now add @classmethod:
class Foo():
@classmethod
def foo(x):
print(x)
Calling on an instance now passes its class:
Foo().foo()
__main__.Foo
as does calling on a class:
Foo.foo()
__main__.Foo
It's only convention that dictates that we use self for that first argument on an instance method and cls on a class method. I used neither here to illustrate that it's just an argument. In Ruby, self is a keyword.
Contrast with Ruby:
class Foo
def foo()
puts "instance method #{self}"
end
def self.foo()
puts "class method #{self}"
end
end
Foo.foo()
class method Foo
Foo.new.foo()
instance method #<Foo:0x000000020fe018>
The Python class method is just a decorated function and you can use the same techniques to create your own decorators. A decorated method wraps the real method (in the case of @classmethod it passes the additional class argument). The underlying method is still there, hidden but still accessible.
footnote: I wrote this after a name clash between a class and instance method piqued my curiosity. I am far from a Python expert and would like comments if any of this is wrong.