While using TOP or a sub-query both work, I would break the problem into steps:
Find target record
SELECT MIN( date ) AS date, id
FROM myTable
WHERE id = 2
GROUP BY id
Join to get other fields
SELECT mt.id, mt.name, mt.score, mt.date
FROM myTable mt
INNER JOIN
(
SELECT MIN( date ) AS date, id
FROM myTable
WHERE id = 2
GROUP BY id
) x ON x.date = mt.date AND x.id = mt.id
While this solution, using derived tables, is longer, it is:
It is easier to test as parts of the query can be run standalone.
It is self documenting as the query directly reflects the requirement ie the derived table lists the row where id = 2 with the earliest date.
It is extendable as if another condition is required, this can be easily added to the derived table.