[python] Django - what is the difference between render(), render_to_response() and direct_to_template()?

Whats the difference (in language a python/django noob can understand) in a view between render(), render_to_response() and direct_to_template()?

e.g. from Nathan Borror's basic apps examples

def comment_edit(request, object_id, template_name='comments/edit.html'):
    comment = get_object_or_404(Comment, pk=object_id, user=request.user)
    # ...
    return render(request, template_name, {
        'form': form,
        'comment': comment,
    })

But I've also seen

    return render_to_response(template_name, my_data_dictionary,
              context_instance=RequestContext(request))

And

    return direct_to_template(request, template_name, my_data_dictionary)

Whats the difference, what to use in any particular situation?

This question is related to python django

The answer is


Rephrasing Yuri, Fábio, and Frosts answers for the Django noob (i.e. me) - almost certainly a simplification, but a good starting point?

  • render_to_response() is the "original", but requires you putting context_instance=RequestContext(request) in nearly all the time, a PITA.

  • direct_to_template() is designed to be used just in urls.py without a view defined in views.py but it can be used in views.py to avoid having to type RequestContext

  • render() is a shortcut for render_to_response() that automatically supplies context_instance=Request.... Its available in the django development version (1.2.1) but many have created their own shortcuts such as this one, this one or the one that threw me initially, Nathans basic.tools.shortcuts.py


Just one note I could not find in the answers above. In this code:

context_instance = RequestContext(request)
return render_to_response(template_name, user_context, context_instance)

What the third parameter context_instance actually does? Being RequestContext it sets up some basic context which is then added to user_context. So the template gets this extended context. What variables are added is given by TEMPLATE_CONTEXT_PROCESSORS in settings.py. For instance django.contrib.auth.context_processors.auth adds variable user and variable perm which are then accessible in the template.


From django docs:

render() is the same as a call to render_to_response() with a context_instance argument that that forces the use of a RequestContext.

direct_to_template is something different. It's a generic view that uses a data dictionary to render the html without the need of the views.py, you use it in urls.py. Docs here


Render is

def render(request, *args, **kwargs):
    """ Simple wrapper for render_to_response. """
    kwargs['context_instance'] = RequestContext(request)
    return render_to_response(*args, **kwargs)

So there is really no difference between render_to_response except it wraps your context making the template pre-processors work.

Direct to template is a generic view.

There is really no sense in using it here because there is overhead over render_to_response in the form of view function.