Understanding checked vs unchecked exceptions in Java

Question

Joshua Bloch in  Effective Java  said that      Use checked exceptions for   recoverable conditions and runtime   exceptions for programming errors    Item 58 in 2nd edition    Let s see if I understand this correctly   Here is my understanding of a checked exception   try      String userInput     read in user input     Long id   Long parseLong userInput    catch NumberFormatException e       id   0    recover the situation by setting the id to 0     1  Is the above considered a checked exception   2  Is RuntimeException an unchecked exception   Here is my understanding of an unchecked exception   try      File file   new File  my file path        FileInputStream fis   new FileInputStream file       catch FileNotFoundException e      3  What should I do here        Should I  throw new FileNotFoundException  File not found            Should I log        Or should I System exit 0        4  Now  couldn t the above code also be a checked exception  I can try to recover the situation like this  Can I   Note  my 3rd question is inside the catch above   try      String filePath     read in from user input file path     File file   new File filePath       FileInputStream fis   new FileInputStream file       catch FileNotFoundException e         Kindly prompt the user an error message       Somehow ask the user to re-enter the file path      5  Why do people do this   public void someMethod throws Exception       Why do they let the exception bubble up  Isn t handling the error sooner better  Why bubble up    6  Should I bubble up the exact exception or mask it using Exception   Below are my readings  In Java  when should I create a checked exception  and when should it be a runtime exception   When to choose checked and unchecked exceptions

User · Answer

Why do they let the exception bubble up  Isn t handling the error sooner better  Why bubble up   For example let say you have some client-server application and client had made a request for some resource that couldn t be find out or for something else error some might have occurred at the server side while processing the user request then it is the duty of the server to tell the client why he couldn t get the thing he requested for so to achieve that at server side  code is written to throw the exception using throw keyword instead of swallowing or handling it if server handles it swallow it  then there will be no chance of intimating to the client that what error had occurred   Note To give a clear description of what the error type has occurred we can create our own     Exception object and throw it to the client

User · Answer

All exceptions must be checked exceptions    Unchecked exceptions are unrestricted gotos  And unrestricted gotos are considered a bad thing  Unchecked exceptions break encapsulation  To process them correctly  all the functions in the call tree between the thrower and the catcher must be known to avoid bugs  Exceptions are errors in the function that throws them but not errors in the function that processes them  The purpose of exceptions is to give the program a second chance by deferring the decision of whether it s an error or not to another context  It s only in the other context can the correct decision be made

User · Answer

Here is a simple rule that can help you decide  It is related to how interfaces are used in Java   Take your class and imagine designing an interface for it such that the interface describes the functionality of the class but none of the underlying implementation  as an interface should   Pretend perhaps that you might implement the class in another way   Look at the methods of the interface and consider the exceptions they might throw   If an exception can be thrown by a method  regardless of the underlying implementation  in other words  it describes the functionality only  then it should probably be a checked exception in the interface   If an exception is caused by the underlying implementation  it should not be in the interface  Therefore  it must either be an unchecked exception in your class  since unchecked exceptions need not appear in the interface signature   or you must wrap it and rethrow as a checked exception that is part of the interface method   To decide if you should wrap and rethrow  you should again consider whether it makes sense for a user of the interface to have to handle the exception condition immediately  or the exception is so general that there is nothing you can do about it and it should propagate up the stack  Does the wrapped exception make sense when expressed as functionality of the new interface you are defining or is it just a carrier for a bag of possible error conditions that could also happen to other methods  If the former  it might still be a checked exception  otherwise it should be unchecked   You should not usually plan to  bubble-up  exceptions  catch and rethrow   Either an exception should be handled by the caller  in which case it is checked  or it should go all the way up to a high level handler  in which case it is easiest if it is unchecked

User · Answer

My absolute favorite description of the difference between unchecked and checked exceptions is provided by the Java Tutorial trail article   Unchecked Exceptions - the Controversy   sorry to get all elementary on this post - but  hey  the basics are sometimes the best       Here s the bottom line guideline  If a client can reasonably be   expected to recover from an exception  make it a checked exception  If   a client cannot do anything to recover from the exception  make it an   unchecked exception   The heart of  what type of exception to throw  is semantic  to some degree  and the above quote provides and excellent guideline  hence  I am still blown away by the notion that C  got rid of checked exceptions - particularly as Liskov argues for their usefulness     The rest then becomes logical  to which exceptions does the compiler expect me to respond  explicitly  The ones from which you expect client to recover

User · Answer

1   If you are unsure about an exception  check the API    java lang Object  extended by java lang Throwable   extended by java lang Exception    extended by java lang RuntimeException     lt -NumberFormatException is a RuntimeException       extended by java lang IllegalArgumentException      extended by java lang NumberFormatException   2   Yes  and every exception that extends it  3   There is no need to catch and throw the same exception  You can show a new File Dialog in this case  4   FileNotFoundException is already a checked exception  5   If it is expected that the method calling someMethod to catch the exception  the latter can be thrown  It just  quot passes the ball quot   An example of it usage would be if you want to throw it in your own private methods  and handle the exception in your public method instead  A good reading is the Oracle doc itself  http   download oracle com javase tutorial essential exceptions runtime html  Why did the designers decide to force a method to specify all uncaught checked exceptions that can be thrown within its scope  Any Exception that can be thrown by a method is part of the method s public programming interface  Those who call a method must know about the exceptions that a method can throw so that they can decide what to do about them  These exceptions are as much a part of that method s programming interface as its parameters and return value  The next question might be   quot If it s so good to document a method s API  including the exceptions it can throw  why not specify runtime exceptions too  quot  Runtime exceptions represent problems that are the result of a programming problem  and as such  the API client code cannot reasonably be expected to recover from them or to handle them in any way  Such problems include arithmetic exceptions  such as dividing by zero  pointer exceptions  such as trying to access an object through a null reference  and indexing exceptions  such as attempting to access an array element through an index that is too large or too small   There s also an important bit of information in the Java Language Specification   The checked exception classes named in the throws clause are part of the contract between the implementor and user of the method or constructor   The bottom line IMHO is that you can catch any RuntimeException  but you are not required to and  in fact the implementation is not required to maintain the same non-checked exceptions thrown  as those are not part of the contract

User · Answer

To answer the final question  the others seem thoroughly answered above    Should I bubble up the exact exception or mask it using Exception    I am assuming you mean something like this   public void myMethod   throws Exception              something that throws FileNotFoundException         No  always declare the most precise exception possible  or a list of such   The exceptions you declare your method as capable of throwing are a part of the contract between your method and the caller   Throwing  FileNotFoundException  means that it is possible the file name isn t valid and the file will not be found  the caller will need to handle that intelligently   Throwing Exception means  Hey  sh t happens   Deal    Which is a very poor API   In the comments on the first article there are some examples where  throws Exception  is a valid and reasonable declaration  but that s not the case for most  normal  code you will ever write

User · Answer

Just to point out that if you throw a checked exception in a code and the catch is few levels above  you need to declare the exception in the signature of each method between you and the catch  So  encapsulation is broken because all functions in the path of throw must know about details of that exception

User · Answer

Checked Exceptions     The exceptions which are checked by the compiler for smooth execution of the program at runtime are called Checked Exception  These occur at compile time  If these are not handled properly  they will give compile time error  Not Exception   All subclasses of Exception class except RuntimeException are Checked Exception   Hypothetical Example - Suppose you are leaving your house for the exam  but if you check whether you took your Hall Ticket at home compile time  then there won t be any problem at Exam Hall runtime     Unchecked Exception     The exceptions which are not checked by the compiler are called Unchecked Exceptions  These occur at runtime  If these exceptions are not handled properly  they don   t give compile time error  But the program will be terminated prematurely at runtime  All subclasses of RunTimeException and Error are unchecked exceptions   Hypothetical Example - Suppose you are in your exam hall but somehow your school had a fire accident  means at runtime  where you can t do anything at that time but precautions can be made before  compile time

User · Answer

Many people say that checked exceptions  i e  these that you should explicitly catch or rethrow  should not be used at all  They were eliminated in C  for example  and most languages don t have them  So you can always throw a subclass of RuntimeException  unchecked exception   However  I think checked exceptions are useful - they are used when you want to force the user of your API to think how to handle the exceptional situation  if it is recoverable   It s just that checked exceptions are overused in the Java platform  which makes people hate them   Here s my extended view on the topic   As for the particular questions    Is the NumberFormatException consider a checked exception  No  NumberFormatException is unchecked    is subclass of RuntimeException   Why  I don t know   but there should have been a method isValidInteger      Is RuntimeException an unchecked exception  Yes  exactly  What should I do here  It depends on where this code is and what you want to happen  If it is in the UI layer - catch it and show a warning  if it s in the service layer - don t catch it at all - let it bubble  Just don t swallow the exception  If an exception occurs in most of the cases you should choose one of these    log it and return rethrow it  declare it to be thrown by the method  construct a new exception by passing the current one in constructor    Now  couldn t the above code also be a checked exception  I can try to recover the situation like this  Can I  It could ve been  But nothing stops you from catching the unchecked exception as well Why do people add class Exception in the throws clause  Most often because people are lazy to consider what to catch and what to rethrow  Throwing Exception is a bad practice and should be avoided    Alas  there is no single rule to let you determine when to catch  when to rethrow  when to use checked and when to use unchecked exceptions  I agree this causes much confusion and a lot of bad code  The general principle is stated by Bloch  you quoted a part of it   And the general principle is to rethrow an exception to the layer where you can handle it

User · Answer

Checked - Prone to happen  Checked in Compile time     Eg   FileOperations  UnChecked - Due to Bad data  Checked in Run time     Eg     String s    abc   Object o   s  Integer i    Integer  o   Exception in thread  main  java lang ClassCastException  java lang String cannot be cast to java lang Integer     at Sample main Sample java 9    Here exception is due to bad data and in no way it can be determined during compile time

User · Answer

If anybody cares for yet another proof to dislike checked exceptions  see the first few paragraphs of the popular JSON library    Although this is a checked exception  it is rarely recoverable  Most callers should simply wrap this exception in an unchecked exception and rethrow     So why in the world would anyone make developers keep checking the exception  if we should  simply wrap it  instead  lol  http   developer android com reference org json JSONException html

User · Answer

All of those are checked exceptions   Unchecked exceptions are subclasses of RuntimeException   The decision is not how to handle them  it s should your code throw them   If you don t want the compiler telling you that you haven t handled an exception then you use an unchecked  subclass of RuntimeException  exception   Those should be saved for situations that you can t recover from  like out of memory errors and the like

User · Answer

Is the above considered to be a checked exception  No The fact that you are handling an exception does not make it a Checked Exception if it is a RuntimeException  Is RuntimeException an unchecked exception  Yes   Checked Exceptions are subclasses of java lang Exception Unchecked Exceptions are subclasses of java lang RuntimeException  Calls throwing checked exceptions need to be enclosed in a try   block or handled in a level above in the caller of the method  In that case the current method must declare that it throws said exceptions so that the callers can make appropriate arrangements to handle the exception   Hope this helps      Q  should I bubble up the exact   exception or mask it using Exception    A  Yes this is a very good question and important design consideration  The class Exception is a very general exception class and can be used to wrap internal low level exceptions  You would better create a custom exception and wrap inside it  But  and a big one - Never ever obscure in underlying original root cause  For ex  Don t ever do following -   try        attemptLogin userCredentials     catch  SQLException sqle         throw new LoginFailureException  Cannot login         lt -- Eat away original root cause  thus obscuring underlying problem      Instead do following   try        attemptLogin userCredentials     catch  SQLException sqle         throw new LoginFailureException sqle      lt -- Wrap original exception to pass on root cause upstairs       Eating away original root cause buries the actual cause beyond recovery is a nightmare for production support teams where all they are given access to is application logs and error messages  Although the latter is a better design but many people don t use it often because developers just fail to pass on the underlying message to caller  So make a firm note  Always pass on the actual exception back whether or not wrapped in any application specific exception      On try-catching RuntimeExceptions   RuntimeExceptions as a general rule should not be try-catched  They generally signal a programming error and should be left alone  Instead the programmer should check the error condition before invoking some code which might result in a RuntimeException  For ex   try       setStatusMessage  Hello Mr      userObject getName        Welcome to my site      catch  NullPointerException npe       sendError  Sorry  your userObject was null  Please contact customer care         This is a bad programming practice  Instead a null-check should have been done like -   if  userObject    null        setStatusMessage  Hello Mr      userObject getName        Welome to my site      else      sendError  Sorry  your userObject was null  Please contact customer care         But there are times when such error checking is expensive such as number formatting  consider this -   try       String userAge    String request getParameter  age        userObject setAge Integer parseInt strUserAge      catch  NumberFormatException npe       sendError  Sorry  Age is supposed to be an Integer  Please try again         Here pre-invocation error checking is not worth the effort because it essentially means to duplicate all the string-to-integer conversion code inside parseInt   method - and is error prone if implemented by a developer  So it is better to just do away with try-catch    So NullPointerException and NumberFormatException are both RuntimeExceptions  catching a NullPointerException should replaced with a graceful null-check while I recommend catching a NumberFormatException explicitly to avoid possible introduction of error prone code

User · Answer

Checked exceptions are checked at compile time by the JVM and its related to resources files db stream socket etc   The motive of checked exception is that at compile time if the resources are not available the application should define an alternative behaviour to handle this in the catch finally block   Unchecked exceptions are purely programmatic errors  wrong calculation  null data or even failures in business logic can lead to runtime exceptions  Its absolutely fine to handle catch unchecked exceptions in code   Explanation taken from http   coder2design com java-interview-questions

User · Answer

In short  exceptions which your module or modules above are supposed to handle during runtime are called checked exceptions  others are unchecked exceptions which are either RuntimeException or Error   In this video  it explains checked and unchecked exceptions in Java  https   www youtube com watch v ue2pOqLaArw

User · Answer

Whether something is a  checked exception  has nothing to do with whether you catch it or what you do in the catch block  It s a property of exception classes  Anything that is a subclass of Exception except for RuntimeException and its subclasses is a checked exception   The Java compiler forces you to either catch checked exceptions or declare them in the method signature  It was supposed to improve program safety  but the majority opinion seems to be that it s not worth the design problems it creates      Why do they let the exception bubble   up  Isnt handle error the sooner the   better  Why bubble up    Because that s the entire point of exceptions  Without this possibility  you would not need exceptions  They enable you to handle errors at a level you choose  rather than forcing you to deal with them in low-level methods where they originally occur

User · Answer

Java distinguishes between two categories of exceptions  checked  amp  unchecked   Java enforces a catch or declared requirement for checked exceptions  An exception s type determines whether an exception is checked or unchecked  All exception types that are direct or indirect subclasses of class RuntimeException are unchecked exception  All classes that inherit from class Exception but not RuntimeException are considered to be checked exceptions  Classes that inherit from class Error are considered to be unchecked  Compiler checks each method call and deceleration to determine whether the method throws checked exception    If so the compiler ensures the exception is caught or is declared in a throws clause   To satisfy the declare part of the catch-or-declare requirement  the method that generates the exception must provide a throws clause containing the checked-exception  Exception classes are defined to be checked when they are considered important enough to catch or declare

User · Answer

1  No  a NumberFormatException is an unchecked Exception  Even though you caught it  you aren t required to  because it s unchecked  This is because it is a subclass of IllegalArgumentException which is a subclass of RuntimeException   2  RuntimeException is the root of all unchecked Exceptions  Every subclass of RuntimeException is unchecked  All other Exceptions and Throwable are checked except for Errors   Which comes under Throwable    3 4  You could alert the user that they picked a non-existent file and ask for a new one  Or just quit informing the user that they entered something invalid   5  Throwing and catching  Exception  is bad practice  But more generally  you might throw other exceptions so the caller can decide how to deal with it  For example  if you wrote a library to handle reading some file input and your method was passed a non-existent file  you have no idea how to handle that  Does the caller want to ask again or quit  So you throw the Exception up the chain back to the caller   In many cases  an unchecked Exception occurs because the programmer did not verify inputs  in the case of NumberFormatException in your first question   That s why its optional to catch them  because there are more elegant ways to avoid generating those exceptions

User · Answer

I just want to add some reasoning for not using checked exceptions at all  This is not a full answer  but I feel it does answer part of your question  and complements many other answers   Whenever checked exceptions are involved  there s a throws CheckedException somewhere in a method signature  CheckedException could be any checked exception   A signature does NOT throw an Exception  throwing Exceptions is an aspect of implementation  Interfaces  method signatures  parent classes  all these things should NOT depend on their implementations  The usage of checked Exceptions here  actually the fact that you have to declare the throws in the method signature  is binding your higher-level interfaces with your implementations of these interfaces   Let me show you an example   Let s have a nice and clean interface like this  public interface IFoo       public void foo        Now we can write many implementations of method foo    like these  public class Foo implements IFoo        Override     public void foo             System out println  I don t throw and exception              Class Foo is perfectly fine  Now let s make a first attempt at class Bar  public class Bar implements IFoo        Override     public void foo               I m using InterruptedExcepton because you probably heard about it somewhere  It s a checked exception  Any checked exception will work the same          throw new InterruptedException              This class Bar won t compile  As InterruptedException is a checked exception  you must either capture it  with a try-catch inside method foo    or declare that you re throwing it  adding throws InterruptedException to the method signature   As I don t want to capture this exception here  I want it to propagate upwards so I can properly deal with it somewhere else   let s alter the signature   public class Bar implements IFoo        Override     public void foo   throws InterruptedException           throw new InterruptedException              This class Bar won t compile either  Bar s method foo   does NOT override IFoo s method foo   since their signatures are different  I could remove the  Override annotation  but I want to program against interface IFoo like IFoo foo  and later on decide on which implementation I want to use  like foo   new Bar     If Bar s method foo   doesn t override IFoo s method foo  when I do foo foo    it won t call Bar s implementation of foo     To make Bar s public void foo   throws InterruptedException override IFoo s public void foo   I MUST add throws InterruptedException to IFoo s method signature  This  however  will cause problems with my Foo class  since it s foo   method s signature differs from IFoo s method signature  Furthermore  if I added throws InterruptedException to Foo s method foo   I would get another error stating that Foo s method foo   declares that it throws an InterruptedException yet it never throws an InterruptedException   As you can see  if I did a decent job at explaining this stuff   the fact that I m throwing a checked exception like InterruptedException is forcing me to tie my interface IFoo to one of it s implementations  which in turn causes havoc on IFoo s other implementations   This is one big reason why checked exceptions are BAD  In caps   One solution is to capture the checked exception  wrap it in an unchecked exception and throw the unchecked exception

User · Answer

I think that checked exceptions are a good reminder for the developer that uses an external library that things can go wrong with the code from that library in exceptional situations

User · Answer

Runtime Exceptions   Runtime exceptions are referring to as unchecked exceptions  All other exceptions are checked exceptions  and they don t derive from java lang RuntimeException   Checked Exceptions    A checked exception must be caught somewhere in your code  If you invoke a method that throws a checked exception but you don t catch the checked exception somewhere  your code will not compile  That s why they re called checked exceptions   the compiler checks to make sure that they re handled or declared    A number of the methods in the Java API throw checked exceptions  so you will often write exception handlers to cope with exceptions generated by methods you didn t write

[java] Understanding checked vs unchecked exceptions in Java

Examples related to java

Examples related to exception

Examples related to runtimeexception

Examples related to checked-exceptions

Examples related to unchecked-exception