[ssl] Insecure content in iframe on secure page

I'm in the in the process of developing an application for a client, which will have an SSL certificate and be served under https. However, to integrate with their existing site they want to provide their navigation inside an iframe.

I can see this causing trouble, as I'd expect the browser to complain about the mix of secure and insecure content on the page. I've had a look at similar questions on here and they all seem to refer to this the other way round (secure content in the iframe).

What I'd like to know, then, is: will it cause issues to have insecure content included inside an iframe, placed on a secure page , and if so what sort of problems would they be?

Ideally if it's not a good idea (and I have a strong feeling that it isn't) I need to be able to explain this to the client.

This question is related to ssl iframe https

The answer is


Based on generality of this question, I think, that you'll need to setup your own HTTPS proxy on some server online. Do the following steps:

  • Prepare your proxy server - install IIS, Apache
  • Get valid SSL certificate to avoid security errors (free from startssl.com for example)
  • Write a wrapper, which will download insecure content (how to below)
  • From your site/app get https://yourproxy.com/?page=http://insecurepage.com

If you simply download remote site content via file_get_contents or similiar, you can still have insecure links to content. You'll have to find them with regex and also replace. Images are hard to solve, but Ï found workaround here: http://foundationphp.com/tutorials/image_proxy.php


Note: While this solution may have worked in some browsers when it was written in 2014, it no longer works. Navigating or redirecting to an HTTP URL in an iframe embedded in an HTTPS page is not permitted by modern browsers, even if the frame started out with an HTTPS URL.

The best solution I created is to simply use google as the ssl proxy...

https://www.google.com/search?q=%http://yourhttpsite.com&btnI=Im+Feeling+Lucky

Tested and works in firefox.

Other Methods:

  • Use a Third party such as embed.ly (but it it really only good for well known http APIs).

  • Create your own redirect script on an https page you control (a simple javascript redirect on a relative linked page should do the trick. Something like: (you can use any langauge/method)

    https://example.com That has a iframe linking to...

    https://example.com/utilities/redirect.html Which has a simple js redirect script like...

    document.location.href ="http://thenonsslsite.com";

  • Alternatively, you could add an RSS feed or write some reader/parser to read the http site and display it within your https site.

  • You could/should also recommend to the http site owner that they create an ssl connection. If for no other reason than it increases seo.

Unless you can get the http site owner to create an ssl certificate, the most secure and permanent solution would be to create an RSS feed grabing the content you need (presumably you are not actually 'doing' anything on the http site -that is to say not logging in to any system).

The real issue is that having http elements inside a https site represents a security issue. There are no completely kosher ways around this security risk so the above are just current work arounds.

Note, that you can disable this security measure in most browsers (yourself, not for others). Also note that these 'hacks' may become obsolete over time.


Examples related to ssl

Requests (Caused by SSLError("Can't connect to HTTPS URL because the SSL module is not available.") Error in PyCharm requesting website A fatal error occurred while creating a TLS client credential. The internal error state is 10013 curl: (35) error:1408F10B:SSL routines:ssl3_get_record:wrong version number How to install OpenSSL in windows 10? ssl.SSLError: tlsv1 alert protocol version Invalid self signed SSL cert - "Subject Alternative Name Missing" "SSL certificate verify failed" using pip to install packages ssl.SSLError: [SSL: CERTIFICATE_VERIFY_FAILED] certificate verify failed (_ssl.c:749) Powershell Invoke-WebRequest Fails with SSL/TLS Secure Channel "ssl module in Python is not available" when installing package with pip3

Examples related to iframe

Getting all files in directory with ajax YouTube Autoplay not working Inserting the iframe into react component How to disable auto-play for local video in iframe iframe refuses to display iFrame onload JavaScript event YouTube iframe embed - full screen Change New Google Recaptcha (v2) Width load iframe in bootstrap modal Responsive iframe using Bootstrap

Examples related to https

What's the net::ERR_HTTP2_PROTOCOL_ERROR about? Requests (Caused by SSLError("Can't connect to HTTPS URL because the SSL module is not available.") Error in PyCharm requesting website Android 8: Cleartext HTTP traffic not permitted ssl.SSLError: tlsv1 alert protocol version Invalid self signed SSL cert - "Subject Alternative Name Missing" How do I make a https post in Node Js without any third party module? Page loaded over HTTPS but requested an insecure XMLHttpRequest endpoint How to force Laravel Project to use HTTPS for all routes? Could not create SSL/TLS secure channel, despite setting ServerCertificateValidationCallback Use .htaccess to redirect HTTP to HTTPs