Notice that your error message only contains five K, V pairs, 10 arguments total. This is by design; the ImmutableMap class provides six different of() methods, accepting between zero and five key-value pairings. There is not an of(...) overload accepting a varags parameter because K and V can be different types.
You want an ImmutableMap.Builder:
ImmutableMap<String,String> myMap = ImmutableMap.<String, String>builder()
.put("key1", "value1")
.put("key2", "value2")
.put("key3", "value3")
.put("key4", "value4")
.put("key5", "value5")
.put("key6", "value6")
.put("key7", "value7")
.put("key8", "value8")
.put("key9", "value9")
.build();