[c++] Function passed as template argument

Template parameters can be either parameterized by type (typename T) or by value (int X).

The "traditional" C++ way of templating a piece of code is to use a functor - that is, the code is in an object, and the object thus gives the code unique type.

When working with traditional functions, this technique doesn't work well, because a change in type doesn't indicate a specific function - rather it specifies only the signature of many possible functions. So:

template<typename OP>
int do_op(int a, int b, OP op)
{
  return op(a,b);
}
int add(int a, int b) { return a + b; }
...

int c = do_op(4,5,add);

Isn't equivalent to the functor case. In this example, do_op is instantiated for all function pointers whose signature is int X (int, int). The compiler would have to be pretty aggressive to fully inline this case. (I wouldn't rule it out though, as compiler optimization has gotten pretty advanced.)

One way to tell that this code doesn't quite do what we want is:

int (* func_ptr)(int, int) = add;
int c = do_op(4,5,func_ptr);

is still legal, and clearly this is not getting inlined. To get full inlining, we need to template by value, so the function is fully available in the template.

typedef int(*binary_int_op)(int, int); // signature for all valid template params
template<binary_int_op op>
int do_op(int a, int b)
{
 return op(a,b);
}
int add(int a, int b) { return a + b; }
...
int c = do_op<add>(4,5);

In this case, each instantiated version of do_op is instantiated with a specific function already available. Thus we expect the code for do_op to look a lot like "return a + b". (Lisp programmers, stop your smirking!)

We can also confirm that this is closer to what we want because this:

int (* func_ptr)(int,int) = add;
int c = do_op<func_ptr>(4,5);

will fail to compile. GCC says: "error: 'func_ptr' cannot appear in a constant-expression. In other words, I can't fully expand do_op because you haven't given me enough info at compiler time to know what our op is.

So if the second example is really fully inlining our op, and the first is not, what good is the template? What is it doing? The answer is: type coercion. This riff on the first example will work:

template<typename OP>
int do_op(int a, int b, OP op) { return op(a,b); }
float fadd(float a, float b) { return a+b; }
...
int c = do_op(4,5,fadd);

That example will work! (I am not suggesting it is good C++ but...) What has happened is do_op has been templated around the signatures of the various functions, and each separate instantiation will write different type coercion code. So the instantiated code for do_op with fadd looks something like:

convert a and b from int to float.
call the function ptr op with float a and float b.
convert the result back to int and return it.

By comparison, our by-value case requires an exact match on the function arguments.

Examples related to c++

Method Call Chaining; returning a pointer vs a reference? How can I tell if an algorithm is efficient? Difference between opening a file in binary vs text How can compare-and-swap be used for a wait-free mutual exclusion for any shared data structure? Install Qt on Ubuntu #include errors detected in vscode Cannot open include file: 'stdio.h' - Visual Studio Community 2017 - C++ Error How to fix the error "Windows SDK version 8.1" was not found? Visual Studio 2017 errors on standard headers How do I check if a Key is pressed on C++

Examples related to templates

*ngIf else if in template 'if' statement in jinja2 template How to create a link to another PHP page Flask raises TemplateNotFound error even though template file exists Application not picking up .css file (flask/python) Django: How can I call a view function from template? Angularjs Template Default Value if Binding Null / Undefined (With Filter) HTML email in outlook table width issue - content is wider than the specified table width How to redirect on another page and pass parameter in url from table? How to check for the type of a template parameter?

Examples related to code-generation

How to auto-generate a C# class file from a JSON string Convert Python program to C/C++ code? How do I generate a constructor from class fields using Visual Studio (and/or ReSharper)? What is the correct way to write HTML using Javascript? Function passed as template argument Seeking useful Eclipse Java code templates What is the best way to auto-generate INSERT statements for a SQL Server table? How can I create database tables from XSD files?

Examples related to functor

Function passed as template argument What are C++ functors and their uses?