> use the -O option. [...] If the tar file is corrupt, the process will abort with an error.
Sometimes yes, but sometimes not. Let's see an example of a corrupted file:
echo Pete > my_name
tar -cf my_data.tar my_name
# // Simulate a corruption
sed < my_data.tar 's/Pete/Fool/' > my_data_now.tar
# // "my_data_now.tar" is the corrupted file
tar -xvf my_data_now.tar -O
It shows:
my_name
Fool
Even if you execute
echo $?
tar said that there was no error:
0
but the file was corrupted, it has now "Fool" instead of "Pete".