Updating state on props change in React Form

Question

I am having trouble with a React form and managing the state properly  I have a time input field in a form  in a modal   The initial value is set as a state variable in getInitialState  and is passed in from a parent component  This in itself works fine      The problem comes when I want to update the default start time value through the parent component  The update itself happens in the parent component through setState start time  new time  However in my form  the default start time value never changes  since it is only defined once in getInitialState     I have tried to use componentWillUpdate to force a change in state through setState start time  next props start time  which did actually work  but gave me Uncaught RangeError  Maximum call stack size exceeded errors     So my question is  what s the correct way of updating state in this case  Am I thinking about this wrong somehow     Current Code      ModalBody   React createClass    getInitialState  - gt       start time   props start time format  HH mm         works but takes long and causes       Uncaught RangeError  Maximum call stack size exceeded     componentWillUpdate   next props  next state  - gt        setState start time  next props start time format  HH mm         fieldChanged   fieldName  event  - gt       stateUpdate           stateUpdate fieldName    event target value       setState stateUpdate       render  - gt       React DOM div        className   modal-body         React DOM form null           React createElement FormLabelInputField             type   time             id   start time             label name   Start Time             value   state start time            onChange   fieldChanged bind null   start time         FormLabelInputField   React createClass    render  - gt       React DOM div        className   form-group         React DOM label          htmlFor   props id           props label name               React DOM input          className   form-control           type   props type          id   props id          value   props value          onChange   props onChange

User · Answer

I think use ref is safe for me  dont need care about some method above   class Company extends XComponent       constructor props            super props           this data                 fetchData data            this resetState data             render             return                lt Input ref  c   gt  this data  name     c  type  text  className  form-control    gt                     class XComponent extends Component       resetState obj            for  var property in obj                if  obj hasOwnProperty property   amp  amp  typeof this data property       undefined                     if   obj property      this data property  state value                       this data property  setState  value  obj property                     else continue                            continue

User · Answer

From react documentation   https   reactjs org blog 2018 06 07 you-probably-dont-need-derived-state html     Erasing state when props change is an Anti Pattern   Since React 16  componentWillReceiveProps is deprecated  From react documentation  the recommended approach in this case is use   Fully controlled component  the ParentComponent of the ModalBody will own the start time state  This is not my prefer approach in this case since i think the modal should own this state   Fully uncontrolled component with a key  this is my prefer approach  An example from react documentation   https   codesandbox io s 6v1znlxyxn   You would fully own the start time state from your ModalBody and use getInitialState just like you have already done  To reset the start time state  you simply change the key from the ParentComponent

User · Answer

componentWillReceiveProps is being deprecated because using it  often leads to bugs and inconsistencies    If something changes from the outside  consider resetting the child component entirely with key   Providing a key prop to the child component makes sure that whenever the value of key changes from the outside  this component is re-rendered  E g     lt EmailInput   defaultEmail  this props user email    key  this props user id    gt    On its performance      While this may sound slow  the performance difference is usually insignificant  Using a key can even be faster if the components have heavy logic that runs on updates since diffing gets bypassed for that subtree

User · Answer

Apparently things are changing     getDerivedStateFromProps   is now the preferred function    x000D   x000D  class Component extends React Component   x000D    static getDerivedStateFromProps props  current state    x000D      if  current state value     props value    x000D        return   x000D          value  props value  x000D          computed prop  heavy computation props value  x000D          x000D        x000D      return null x000D      x000D    x000D   x000D   x000D     above code by danburzo   github

User · Answer

componentWillReceiveProps is depcricated since react 16  use getDerivedStateFromProps instead   If I understand correctly  you have a parent component that is passing start time down to the ModalBody component which assigns it to its own state  And you want to update that time from the parent  not a child component  React has some tips on dealing with this scenario   Note  this is an old article that has since been removed from the web  Here s a link to the current doc on component props    Using props to generate state in getInitialState often leads to duplication of  quot source of truth quot   i e  where the real data is  This is because getInitialState is only invoked when the component is first created  Whenever possible  compute values on-the-fly to ensure that they don t get out of sync later on and cause maintenance trouble   Basically  whenever you assign parent s props to a child s state the render method isn t always called on prop update  You have to invoke it manually  using the componentWillReceiveProps method   componentWillReceiveProps nextProps         You don t have to do this check first  but it can help prevent an unneeded render   if  nextProps startTime     this state startTime        this setState   startTime  nextProps startTime

User · Answer

There is also componentDidUpdate available    Function signatur   componentDidUpdate prevProps  prevState  snapshot    Use this as an opportunity to operate on the DOM when the component has been updated  Doesn t get called on initial render   See You Probably Don t Need Derived State Article  which describes Anti-Pattern for both componentDidUpdate and getDerivedStateFromProps  I found it very useful

User · Answer

It s quite clearly from their docs   If you used componentWillReceiveProps for re-computing some data only when a prop changes  use a memoization helper instead    Use  https   reactjs org blog 2018 06 07 you-probably-dont-need-derived-state html what-about-memoization

User · Answer

You Probably Don t Need Derived State  1  Set a key from the parent     When a key changes  React will create a new component instance rather   than update the current one  Keys are usually used for dynamic lists   but are also useful here    2  Use getDerivedStateFromProps   componentWillReceiveProps     If key doesn   t work for some reason  perhaps the component is very expensive to initialize    By using getDerivedStateFromProps you can reset any part of state but it seems   a little buggy at this time  v16 7    see the link above for the usage

User · Answer

The new hooks way of doing this is to use useEffect instead of componentWillReceiveProps the old way   componentWillReceiveProps nextProps         You don t have to do this check first  but it can help prevent an unneeded render   if  nextProps startTime     this state startTime        this setState   startTime  nextProps startTime             becomes the following in a functional hooks driven component      store the startTime prop in local state const  startTime  setStartTime    useState props startTime      useEffect      gt      if  props startTime     startTime        setStartTime props startTime           props startTime      we set the state using setState  using useEffect we check for changes to the specified prop  and take the action to update the state on change of the prop

User · Answer

store the startTime prop in local state const  startTime  setStartTime    useState props startTime      useEffect      gt      if  props startTime     startTime        setStartTime props startTime           props startTime     Can this method be migrated to class components

User · Answer

Use Memoize  The op s derivation of state is a direct manipulation of props  with no true derivation needed  In other words  if you have a prop which can be utilized or transformed directly there is no need to store the prop on state    Given that the state value of  start time is simply the prop start time format  HH mm    the information contained in the prop is already in itself sufficient for updating the component   However if you did want to only call format on a prop change  the correct way to do this per latest documentation would be via Memoize  https   reactjs org blog 2018 06 07 you-probably-dont-need-derived-state html what-about-memoization

[reactjs] Updating state on props change in React Form

Examples related to reactjs

Examples related to react-state