How to use concerns in Rails 4

Question

The default Rails 4 project generator now creates the directory  concerns  under controllers and models  I have found some explanations about how to use routing concerns  but nothing about controllers or models   I am pretty sure it has to do with the current  DCI trend  in the community and would like to give it a try   The question is  how am I supposed to use this feature  is there a convention on how to define the naming   class hierarchy in order to make it work  How can I include a concern in a model or controller

User · Answer

It s worth to mention that using concerns is considered bad idea by many    like this guy and this one   Some reasons    There is some dark magic happening behind the scenes - Concern is patching include method  there is a whole dependency handling system - way too much complexity for something that s trivial good old Ruby mixin pattern  Your classes are no less dry  If you stuff 50 public methods in various modules and include them  your class still has 50 public methods  it s just that you hide that code smell  sort of put your garbage in the drawers  Codebase is actually harder to navigate with all those concerns around  Are you sure all members of your team have same understanding what should really substitute concern    Concerns are easy way to shoot yourself in the leg  be careful with them

User · Answer

This post helped me understand concerns     app models trader rb class Trader   include Shared  Schedule end    app models concerns shared schedule rb module Shared  Schedule   extend ActiveSupport  Concern       end

User · Answer

So I found it out by myself  It is actually a pretty simple but powerful concept  It has to do with code reuse as in the example below  Basically  the idea is to extract common and   or context specific chunks of code in order to clean up the models and avoid them getting too fat and messy   As an example  I ll put one well known pattern  the taggable pattern     app models product rb class Product   include Taggable        end    app models concerns taggable rb   notice that the file name has to match the module name     applying Rails conventions for autoloading  module Taggable   extend ActiveSupport  Concern    included do     has many  taggings  as   taggable     has many  tags  through   taggings      class attribute  tag limit   end    def tags string     tags map  amp  name  join         end    def tags string  tag string      tag names   tag string to s split            tag names each do  tag name        tags build name  tag name      end   end      methods defined here are going to extend the class  not the instance of it   module ClassMethods      def tag limit value        self tag limit value   value     end    end  end   So following the Product sample  you can add Taggable to any class you desire and share its functionality   This is pretty well explained by DHH      In Rails 4  we   re going to invite programmers to use concerns with the   default app models concerns and app controllers concerns directories   that are automatically part of the load path  Together with the   ActiveSupport  Concern wrapper  it   s just enough support to make this   light-weight factoring mechanism shine

User · Answer

In concerns make file filename rb  For example I want in my application where attribute create by exist update there value by 1  and 0 for updated by  module TestConcern    extend ActiveSupport  Concern    def checkattributes        if self has attribute   created by        self update attributes created by  1      end     if self has attribute   updated by        self update attributes updated by  0      end   end  end   If you want to pass arguments in action  included do    before action only    create  do      blaablaa options     end end   after that include in your model like this   class Role  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   include TestConcern end

User · Answer

I felt most of the examples here demonstrated the power of module rather than how ActiveSupport  Concern adds value to module    Example 1  More readable modules   So without concerns this how a typical module will be   module M   def self included base      base extend ClassMethods     base class eval do       scope  disabled  - gt    where disabled  true        end   end    def instance method           end    module ClassMethods           end end   After refactoring with ActiveSupport  Concern   require  active support concern   module M   extend ActiveSupport  Concern    included do     scope  disabled  - gt    where disabled  true      end    class methods do           end    def instance method           end end   You see instance methods  class methods and included block are less messy  Concerns will inject them appropriately for you  That s one advantage of using ActiveSupport  Concern     Example 2  Handle module dependencies gracefully   module Foo   def self included base      base class eval do       def self method injected by foo to host klass                   end     end   end end  module Bar   def self included base      base method injected by foo to host klass   end end  class Host   include Foo   We need to include this dependency for Bar   include Bar   Bar is the module that Host really needs end   In this example Bar is the module that Host really needs  But since Bar has dependency with Foo the Host class have to include Foo  but wait why does Host want to know about Foo  Can it be avoided     So Bar adds dependency everywhere it goes  And order of inclusion also matters here  This adds lot of complexity dependency to huge code base   After refactoring with ActiveSupport  Concern  require  active support concern   module Foo   extend ActiveSupport  Concern   included do     def self method injected by foo to host klass               end   end end  module Bar   extend ActiveSupport  Concern   include Foo    included do     self method injected by foo to host klass   end end  class Host   include Bar   It works  now Bar takes care of its dependencies end   Now it looks simple   If you are thinking why can t we add Foo dependency in Bar module itself  That won t work since method injected by foo to host klass have to be injected in a class that s including Bar not on Bar module itself   Source  Rails ActiveSupport  Concern

User · Answer

I have been reading about using model concerns to skin-nize fat models as well as DRY up your model codes  Here is an explanation with examples   1  DRYing up model codes  Consider a Article model  a Event model and a Comment model  An article or an event has many comments  A comment belongs to either Article or Event    Traditionally  the models may look like this   Comment Model   class Comment  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   belongs to  commentable  polymorphic  true end   Article Model   class Article  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   has many  comments  as   commentable     def find first comment     comments first created at DESC    end    def self least commented     return the article with least number of comments   end end   Event Model  class Event  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   has many  comments  as   commentable     def find first comment     comments first created at DESC    end    def self least commented     returns the event with least number of comments   end end   As we can notice  there is a significant piece of code common to both Event and Article  Using concerns we can extract this common code in a separate module Commentable    For this create a commentable rb file in app models concerns   module Commentable   extend ActiveSupport  Concern    included do     has many  comments  as   commentable   end      for the given article event returns the first comment   def find first comment     comments first created at DESC    end    module ClassMethods     def least commented        returns the article event which has the least number of comments     end   end end   And now your models look like this    Comment Model    class Comment  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   belongs to  commentable  polymorphic  true end   Article Model   class Article  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   include Commentable end   Event Model   class Event  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   include Commentable end   2  Skin-nizing Fat Models   Consider a Event model  A event has many attenders and comments   Typically  the event model might look like this  class Event  lt  ActiveRecord  Base      has many  comments   has many  attenders     def find first comment       for the given article event returns the first comment   end    def find comments with word word        for the given event returns an array of comments which contain the given word   end     def self least commented       finds the event which has the least number of comments   end    def self most attended       returns the event with most number of attendes   end    def has attendee attendee id        returns true if the event has the mentioned attendee   end end   Models with many associations and otherwise have tendency to accumulate more and more code and become unmanageable  Concerns provide a way to skin-nize fat modules making them more modularized and easy to understand    The above model can be refactored using concerns as below  Create a attendable rb and commentable rb file in app models concerns event folder  attendable rb  module Attendable   extend ActiveSupport  Concern    included do      has many  attenders   end    def has attender attender id        returns true if the event has the mentioned attendee   end    module ClassMethods     def most attended         returns the event with most number of attendes     end   end end   commentable rb  module Commentable   extend ActiveSupport  Concern    included do      has many  comments   end    def find first comment       for the given article event returns the first comment   end    def find comments with word word        for the given event returns an array of comments which contain the given word   end    module ClassMethods     def least commented         finds the event which has the least number of comments     end   end end   And now using Concerns  your Event model reduces to   class Event  lt  ActiveRecord  Base   include Commentable   include Attendable end     While using concerns its advisable to go for  domain  based grouping rather than  technical  grouping  Domain Based grouping is like  Commentable    Photoable    Attendable   Technical grouping will mean  ValidationMethods    FinderMethods  etc

[ruby-on-rails] How to use concerns in Rails 4

Examples related to ruby-on-rails

Examples related to ruby-on-rails-4

Examples related to dci