[jquery] angular.element vs document.getElementById or jQuery selector with spin (busy) control

I'm using the "Angularised" version of the Spin control, as documented here: http://blog.xvitcoder.com/adding-a-weel-progress-indicator-to-your-angularjs-application/

One of the things I don't like about the shown solution is the use of jQuery in the service that effectively attaches the spin control to the DOM element. I would prefer to use angular constructs to access the element. I'd also like to avoid "hard-coding" the id of the element that the spinner needs to attach to within the service and instead use a directive that sets the id in the service (singleton) so that other users of the service or the service itself don't need to know that.

I'm struggling with what angular.element gives us vs what document.getElementById on the same element id gives us. eg. This works:

  var target = document.getElementById('appBusyIndicator');

None of these do:

  var target = angular.element('#appBusyIndicator');
  var target = angular.element('appBusyIndicator');

I'm clearly doing something that should be fairly obvious wrong! Can any one help?

Assuming I can get the above working, I have a similar problem with trying to replace jQuery access to the element: eg $(target).fadeIn('fast'); works angular.element('#appBusyIndicator').fadeIn('fast') or angular.element('appBusyIndicator').fadeIn('fast') doesn't

Can someone point me to a good example of documentation that clarifies use of an Angular "element" vs the DOM element? Angular obviously "wraps" the element with its own properties, methods etc but it's often hard to get the original value. For example if I have an <input type='number'> field and I want to access the original contents that are visible in the ui when the user types "--" (without the quotes) I get nothing, presumably because the "type=number" means Angular is rejecting the input even though it's visible in the UI and I want to see it so I can test for it and clear it down.

Any pointers/answers appreciated.

Thanks.

If someone using gulp, it show an error if we use document.getElementById() and it suggest to use $document.getElementById() but it doesn't work.

Use -

$document[0].getElementById('id')

var target = document.getElementById('appBusyIndicator');

is equal to

var target = $document[0].getElementById('appBusyIndicator');

You should read the angular element docs if you haven't yet, so you can understand what is supported by jqLite and what not -jqlite is a subset of jquery built into angular.

Those selectors won't work with jqLite alone, since selectors by id are not supported.

  var target = angular.element('#appBusyIndicator');
  var target = angular.element('appBusyIndicator');

So, either :

• you use jqLite alone, more limited than jquery, but enough in most of the situations.
• or you include the full jQuery lib in your app, and use it like normal jquery, in the places that you really need jquery.

Edit: Note that jQuery should be loaded before angularJS in order to take precedence over jqLite:

Real jQuery always takes precedence over jqLite, provided it was loaded before DOMContentLoaded event fired.

Edit2: I missed the second part of the question before:

The issue with <input type="number"> , I think it is not an angular issue, it is the intended behaviour of the native html5 number element.

It won't return a non-numeric value even if you try to retrieve it with jquery's .val() or with the raw .value attribute.

It can work like that:

var myElement = angular.element( document.querySelector( '#some-id' ) );

You wrap the Document.querySelector() native Javascript call into the angular.element() call. So you always get the element in a jqLite or jQuery object, depending whether or not jQuery is available/loaded.

Official documentation for angular.element:

If jQuery is available, angular.element is an alias for the jQuery function. If jQuery is not available, angular.element delegates to Angulars built-in subset of jQuery, that called "jQuery lite" or jqLite.

All element references in Angular are always wrapped with jQuery or jqLite (such as the element argument in a directives compile or link function). They are never raw DOM references.

In case you do wonder why to use document.querySelector(), please read this answer.

You should inject $document in your controller, and use it instead of original document object.

var myElement = angular.element($document[0].querySelector('#MyID'))

If you don't need the jquery style element wrap, $document[0].querySelector('#MyID') will give you the DOM object.

Maybe I am too late here but this will work :

var target = angular.element(appBusyIndicator);

Notice, there is no appBusyIndicator, it is plain ID value.

What is happening behind the scenes: (assuming it's applied on a div) (taken from angular.js line no : 2769 onwards...)

/////////////////////////////////////////////
function JQLite(element) {     //element = div#appBusyIndicator
  if (element instanceof JQLite) {
    return element;
  }

  var argIsString;

  if (isString(element)) {
    element = trim(element);
    argIsString = true;
  }
  if (!(this instanceof JQLite)) {
    if (argIsString && element.charAt(0) != '<') {
      throw jqLiteMinErr('nosel', 'Looking up elements via selectors is not supported by jqLite! See: http://docs.angularjs.org/api/angular.element');
    }
    return new JQLite(element);
  }

By default if there is no jQuery on the page, jqLite will be used. The argument is internally understood as an id and corresponding jQuery object is returned.

Improvement to kaiser's answer:

var myEl = $document.find('#some-id');

Don't forget to inject $document into your directive

You can access elements using $document ($document need to be injected)

var target = $document('#appBusyIndicator');
var target = $document('appBusyIndicator');

or with angular element, the specified elements can be accessed as:

var targets = angular.element(document).find('div'); //array of all div
var targets = angular.element(document).find('p');
var target = angular.element(document).find('#appBusyIndicator');

I don't think it's the right way to use angular. If a framework method doesnt exist, don't create it! This means the framework (here angular) doesnt work this way.

With angular you should not manipulate DOM like this (the jquery way), but use angular helper such as

<div ng-show="isLoading" class="loader"></div>

Or create your own directive (your own DOM component) in order to have full control on it.

BTW, you can see here http://caniuse.com/#search=queryselector querySelector is well supported and so can be use safely.

This worked for me well.

angular.forEach(element.find('div'), function(node)
{
  if(node.id == 'someid'){
    //do something
  }
  if(node.className == 'someclass'){
    //do something
  }
});