[windows] Do standard windows .ini files allow comments?

Are comments allowed in Windows ini files? (...assuming you're using the GetPrivateProfileString api functions to read them...)

[Section]
Name=Value   ; comment

; full line comment

And, is there a proper spec of the .INI file format anywhere?

Thanks for the replies - However maybe I wasn't clear enough. It's only the format as read by Windows API Calls that I'm interested in. I know other implementations allow comments, but it's specifically the MS Windows spec and implementation that I need to know about.

This question is related to windows comments ini

The answer is


Windows INI API support for:

  • Line comments: yes, using semi-colon ;
  • Trailing comments: No

The authoritative source is the Windows API function that reads values out of INI files

GetPrivateProfileString

Retrieves a string from the specified section in an initialization file.

The reason "full line comments" work is because the requested value does not exist. For example, when parsing the following ini file contents:

[Application]
UseLiveData=1
;coke=zero
pepsi=diet   ;gag
#stackoverflow=splotchy

Reading the values:

  • UseLiveData: 1
  • coke: not present
  • ;coke: not present
  • pepsi: diet ;gag
  • stackoverflow: not present
  • #stackoverflow: splotchy

Update: I used to think that the number sign (#) was a pseudo line-comment character. The reason using leading # works to hide stackoverflow is because the name stackoverflow no longer exists. And it turns out that semi-colon (;) is a line-comment.

But there is no support for trailing comments.


USE A SEMI-COLON AT BEGINING OF LINE --->> ; <<---

Ex.

; last modified 1 April 2001 by John Doe
[owner]
name=John Doe
organization=Acme Widgets Inc.

I have seen comments in INI files, so yes. Please refer to this Wikipedia article. I could not find an official specification, but that is the correct syntax for comments, as many game INI files had this as I remember.

Edit

The API returns the Value and the Comment (forgot to mention this in my reply), just construct and example INI file and call the API on this (with comments) and you can see how this is returned.


Yes. Have a look at Wikipedia and Cloanto Implementation of INI File Format (see bottom of page).


Examples related to windows

"Permission Denied" trying to run Python on Windows 10 A fatal error occurred while creating a TLS client credential. The internal error state is 10013 How to install OpenJDK 11 on Windows? I can't install pyaudio on Windows? How to solve "error: Microsoft Visual C++ 14.0 is required."? git clone: Authentication failed for <URL> How to avoid the "Windows Defender SmartScreen prevented an unrecognized app from starting warning" XCOPY: Overwrite all without prompt in BATCH Laravel 5 show ErrorException file_put_contents failed to open stream: No such file or directory how to open Jupyter notebook in chrome on windows Tensorflow import error: No module named 'tensorflow'

Examples related to comments

Way to create multiline comments in Bash? Jenkins: Can comments be added to a Jenkinsfile? /** and /* in Java Comments Where is the syntax for TypeScript comments documented? Multiple line comment in Python How do I add comments to package.json for npm install? How to comment multiple lines with space or indent Is there a shortcut to make a block comment in Xcode? How to comment and uncomment blocks of code in the Office VBA Editor Which comment style should I use in batch files?

Examples related to ini

PHP Warning: Module already loaded in Unknown on line 0 Python: How would you save a simple settings/config file? How to increase maximum execution time in php How to read and write INI file with Python3? How do I grab an INI value within a shell script? How to locate the php.ini file (xampp) PHP ini file_get_contents external url Do standard windows .ini files allow comments? Reading/writing an INI file What is the easiest way to parse an INI file in Java?